Joshua Redman's sophomore effort found him leading a piano-less quartet that also included guitar great
Pat Metheny and half of
Ornette Coleman's trailblazing late-'50s/early-'60s quartet: acoustic bassist
Charlie Haden and drummer
Billy Higgins. With such company,
Redman could have delivered a strong avant-garde or free jazz album;
Haden and
Higgins had played an important role in jazz's avant-garde because of their association with
Coleman, and
Metheny had himself joined forces with
Coleman on their thrilling
Song X session of 1985. But
Wish isn't avant-garde; instead, it's a mostly inside post-bop date that emphasizes the lyrical and the introspective. The musicians swing hard and fast on
Charlie Parker's
"Moose the Mooche," but things become very reflective on pieces like
Redman's
"The Undeserving Many" and
Metheny's
"We Had a Sister." One of the nice things about
Redman is his ability to provide jazz interpretations of rock and R&B songs. While neo-conservatives ignore them and many NAC artists simply provide boring, predictable, note-for-note covers,
Redman isn't afraid to dig into them and show their jazz potential. In
Redman's hands,
Stevie Wonder's
"Make Sure You're Sure" becomes a haunting jazz-noir statement, while
Eric Clapton's ballad
"Tears in Heaven" is changed from moving pop/rock to moving pop-jazz. The latter, in fact, could be called "smooth jazz with substance." Some of bop's neo-conservatives disliked the fact that
Redman was playing with two of
Coleman's former sidemen and a fusion icon like
Metheny, but then,
Redman never claimed to be a purist. Although
Wish isn't innovative, it's an appealing CD from an improviser who is willing to enter a variety of musical situations. ~ Alex Henderson
