More like a history of the world than an economics book…An awe-inspiring breadth of data is tapped…And after dives into such detail, unlike the average data aficionado, Piketty always soars back up to the big picture. On occasion, a blistering insight can cut through reams of history.
Outlines a fairer economic system for the world.
Management Today - Claire Warren
Mixes history and polemic—case studies from modern Sweden and Soviet Russia alongside a genuine political program to help mitigate, at least, the cruelest inequities highlighted in his first book.
New York Magazine - David Wallace-Wells
The scope of Piketty’s inquiry sets his book apart from most work by economists on inequality.
Society - Roger E. Backhouse
Piketty’s own historical and cross-national analysis is deeply informed by his concern with contemporary injustices, notably income and wealth inequities but also the ecological crisis and resurgent, racist or ‘social-nativist’ populisms.
International Sociology Review - Elaine Coburn
[A] sweeping survey of the root causes of inequality…Loaded with rich comparative data, much of which has been compiled for the first time. This information includes not only standard economic fare, such as data on growth and, of course, inequality, but also political data on voting behavior, stratified by class. This allows Piketty to show how political alliances were forged in the 1980s and ’90s in support of a global order that fostered inequality.
Public Books - Katharina Pistor
Ranges widely across continents and centuries in its analysis of economic inequality and the ways it is justified.
Times Higher Education - Matthew Reisz
Has virtues that many post-Marxist critiques lack…Piketty’s sweeping scholarship enhances, rather than obscures, his central argument.
An encyclopaedic, rewarding work that merits thoughtful engagement…Piketty successfully puts forward a superb, data-driven normative defense of democratic socialism. The principles that Piketty proposes—fair tax, fair trade, clean air and, above all, a democratic economy—have a huge amount to commend them, and make this book an essential read.
A book of remarkable clarity and dynamism. Drawing lessons from a breathtaking survey of different historical experiences, it teaches us that nothing is inevitable, that there exist a whole range of possibilities between hypercapitalism and the disasters of the communist experience. It’s up to us to make our future. Let’s roll up our sleeves.
His magnum opus…It is difficult not to agree with Piketty’s compelling thesis—that inequality is a ‘man-made’ construct rooted in ideologies that have historically been dominated by the elite…Government officials and policymakers would find it useful in charting new economic policies for the future.
Arab Studies Quarterly - Omar Darwazah
Nothing less than a global history of inequality and the stories that societies tell to justify it, from pre-modern India to Donald Trump’s U.S.
Worth the wait. Like Capital in the Twenty-First Century , it is an empirical tour de force that ends with a new policy proposal to reduce inequality…But bringing the issue of ideology and power into the debate over rising inequality is the truly great achievement of Capital and Ideology …Piketty has distanced himself from standard economics and provides a multidisciplinary, historical explanation of inequality.
Dollars & Sense - Steven Pressman
Focuses on the relationship between inequality and the way in which the concept of private property has evolved over time…Fascinating analysis.
The journey through this book is long but rewarding. Piketty’s historical analysis of inequality around the world is fascinating, and even the wishful thinking underlying his ‘participatory socialism’ makes for interesting reading.
Project Syndicate - Willem H. Buiter
Thomas Piketty’s new book starts where Capital in the Twenty-First Century left off, revealing how inequality was allowed to develop into an acceptable condition, now and in the past, in the West and in the rest of the world. Still, not all is bad: if inequality is a social construct, that means it can also be undone. Based on monumental research, Capital and Ideology is an appeal to rethink capitalism—if not for today’s politicians then perhaps for tomorrow’s revolution!
Spenglerian in scope, Piketty’s critique reaches far back in history and across the globe…It’s an admirable corrective to the usual Eurocentrism of Western economists…Piketty has modified his thinking since his previous opus. Rather than imply that rising inequality is a problem inherent in capitalism, he now suggests that the levels of inequality we get are the ones we countenance—that they’re entirely a matter of political and ideological choices.
New Yorker - Idrees Kahloon
Both a history of the world and a theory of history. Every society is unequal, and therefore constitutes an ‘inequality regime’ maintained not solely by force but also by ideology… Most of the book is a history of how those ideologies have helped bolster social structures characterized by extreme inequality, from feudal and slave societies through colonial regimes to the hypercapitalist world of today…The bleakly unequal impact of the coronavirus pandemic on rich and poor may reinforce that discontent.
Seven years after the publication of his best-selling Capital in the Twenty-First Century , Piketty returns with a global overview to understand some of the most pressing economic and social issues of our time.
New York Times Book Review
A work of political economy in the broadest sense—a staggeringly ambitious effort attempting to synthesize centuries of history, economics, and politics into one grand picture…A fascinating, essential study both of where we came from and of two possible paths forward: how we might create a better future for all human society, and the dark possibilities should we fail.
Ventures to trace the origin of inequalities and propose methods of eradication…Lands on the world’s doorstep in the midst of an unfolding economic crisis, when the shutdown required to prevent the spread of the coronavirus is sending the world into a spiraling recession…Piketty has put forward proposals for long-term, permanent change, but impressively, they would also be immediately useful in speeding along the recovery.
A magisterial history of economic development as seen through the prism of inequality. It is breathtaking in its scholarship and sweep (almost no corner of the globe is left unvisited) and incandescent in its insights…[Piketty] casts his discerning gaze on history’s sweep, not just to understand the world but also to transform it.
Foreign Affairs - Arvind Subramanian
[In] Piketty’s magisterial survey of the central role that ideas and discourse have played in alternately justifying and questioning societies’ inequities, we are reminded that political uprisings, financial collapses, and wars—think the French Revolution, the Great Depression, and World War II—are what drive change.
Harvard Business Review - Scott LaPierre
An astonishing experiment in social science, one that defies easy comparison. In its ambition, obsessive testimony and sheer oddness, it is closer to the spirit of Karl Ove Knausgård than of Karl Marx…Will be impossible to ignore.
The Guardian - William Davies
Thomas Piketty’s magisterial global and connected history takes us on a whirlwind journey across the world during the past 500 years to show how shifting ideas and politics have shaped a wide variety of inequality regimes. Fully embracing the power of historical analysis, Capital and Ideology emboldens us to reimagine the possibilities of our present. Enormously rich in argument and evidence, this tour de force by one of the most influential thinkers of our age is a must-read for anyone grappling with the dilemmas of our present.
Boldly proclaims that inequality is ultimately rooted in ideology…Offer[s] a global history of how different political systems have justified inequality, and how these systems have been transformed over time.
Thomas Piketty’s books are always monumental…In the same way that Capital in the Twenty-First Century has transformed how economists look at inequality, Capital and Ideology will transform the way political scientists look at their own field.
ProMarket - Branko Milanovic
[Has] the potential to start an important debate about how to restructure society in a more egalitarian and ecologically sustainable way.
Nature - Ingrid Harvold Kvangraven
At its heart, Capital and Ideology seeks to understand why the less advantaged masses, who’ve seen their share of the economic pie drastically shrink in recent decades, don’t unite to press for sweeping political changes that could bring economic justice…Given the starring role that inequality has assumed in today’s political discourse—in no small part due to his previous book—Piketty’s latest effort is very welcome.
Might become even more politically influential than the French economist’s 2013 overview of inequality, Capital in the Twenty-First Century …Piketty explains why this could be the moment for a turn to equality, and which policies could make that happen.
Financial Times - Simon Kuper
The breadth of Piketty’s learning is extraordinary…Politicians who hope for more than a short durée in power would do well to digest the main thesis.
Literary Review - Howard Davies
Bears little resemblance to anything else written by contemporary economists, or even those of one or two generations past. The tendency in economics now—as well as in a great deal of public discussion—is to view the economy as a natural force, existing independently from our ideas about what it is and how it ought to work. This book systematically demolishes that self-serving conceit…Makes clear that a political and ideological revolution is necessary in order to achieve a new era of economic justice.
Boston Review - Marshall Steinbaum
Packed with fascinating detail and vast quantities of skillfully assembled data…A systematic examination of inequality across time and place, and of the ideas the powerful have used to justify it…We learn a good deal about the lengths to which the powerful will go to assert their privilege (and the often outrageous injustice this entails), and about the only things that have ever thwarted them: mass violence and progressive taxation…Whether or not his revolution without revolutionaries can get us where we need to go, his analysis of how we got here demands our attention.
London Review of Books - Geoff Mann
A believer in how capitalism can be used to eradicate inequality, Piketty argues for new taxation systems that might minimize the gap between the one percent and the underserved. Whether he’s right or wrong, his dazzling intellect makes for thought-provoking reading.
An important contribution by Piketty. He has enlarged the scope of economic analysis appropriately to include political power and ideology. The historical record he presents is greatly enriching.
Forum for Social Economics - Stephanie Seguino
This is an immense work of scholarship on the history of inequality. It also contains a penetrating analysis of contemporary politics, especially the failures of what Piketty calls the ‘Brahmin Left,’ along with a radical new program of socialist egalitarianism.
Financial Times - Martin Wolf
Adds something vital to the author’s decades-old, impressively data-rich indictment of unequal wealth accumulation. This book proposes a lively, tendentious, debatable account of the ideologies that propel different property regimes—as well as a nuanced genealogy of how such ideologies can change.
Public Books - John Plotz
A truly monumental work, reviewing trends in income and wealth inequality across of host of nations and eras, and attempting to find some overarching explanation for them.
Business Economics - Charles Steindel
Just as powerful [as Capital in the Twentieth-First Century ].
In an election cycle where the political discourse has been thoroughly shaped by Piketty’s work, his new book feels especially urgent.
A remarkable achievement.
Central Banking - Geoffrey Wood
[Piketty] expand[s] his investigations across the globe and over long periods of history to reveal how ideologies fuel inequalities.
Nothing less than a global history of inequality and the stories that societies tell to justify it, from pre-modern India to Donald Trump’s U.S.
Focuses on the relationship between inequality and the way in which the concept of private property has evolved over time…Fascinating analysis.
American Affairs - Thomas Fazi
Nothing less than a global history of inequality and the stories that societies tell to justify it, from pre-modern India to Donald Trump’s U.S.
03/06/2020
Piketty's (Capital in the Twenty-First Century , The Economics of Inequality ) latest book is an ambitious attempt to analyze inequality and offer ways to reduce it. He presents a history of inegalitarianism from preindustrial times to the present in various parts of the world, discussing the forms this unfairness has taken and the defenses of it that have been made. Piketty believes it is impossible to understand and correctly analyze inequality if it's considered in the abstract, ignoring the various particular economic, political, and social circumstances in which it occurs. While he believes there is no one ideal form of society, he is also insistent that inequalities can and should be reduced. In order to accomplish this, he argues that business organizations should be set up in a way that calls for the participation in decision making of both the workers and representatives of communities in which the businesses are embedded, along with the owners of capital. Additionally, international organizations should provide the means and context for making at least some economic decisions since many issues transcend national boundaries. VERDICT This meticulous analysis will interest those with a serious concern for economic public policy.—Shmuel Ben-Gad, Gelman Lib., George Washington Univ., Washington, DC
★ 2019-12-22
Readers who like their political manifestoes in manageable sizes, à la Common Sense or The Communist Manifesto , may be overwhelmed by the latest from famed French economist Piketty (Top Incomes in France in the Twentieth Century: Inequality and Redistribution, 1901-1998 , 2014, etc.), but it's a significant work. The author interrogates the principal forms of economic organization over time, from slavery to "non-European trifunctional societies," Chinese-style communism, and "hypercapitalist" orders, in order to examine relative levels of inequality and its evolution. Each system is founded on an ideology, and "every ideology, no matter how extreme it may seem in its defense of inequality, expresses a certain idea of social justice." In the present era, at least in the U.S., that idea of social justice would seem to be only that the big ones eat the little ones, the principal justification being that the wealthiest people became rich because they are "the most enterprising, deserving, and useful." In fact, as Piketty demonstrates, there's more to inequality than the mere "size of the income gap." Contrary to hypercapitalist ideology and its defenders, the playing field is not level, the market is not self-regulating, and access is not evenly distributed. Against this, Piketty arrives at a proposed system that, among other things, would redistribute wealth across societies by heavy taxation, especially of inheritances, to create a "participatory socialism" in which power is widely shared and trade across nations is truly free. The word "socialism," he allows, is a kind of Pandora's box that can scare people off—and, he further acknowledges, "the Russian and Czech oligarchs who buy athletic teams and newspapers may not be the most savory characters, but the Soviet system was a nightmare and had to go." Yet so, too, writes the author, is a capitalism that rewards so few at the expense of so many.
A deftly argued case for a new kind of socialism that, while sure to inspire controversy, bears widespread discussion.
