Why Grundnorm?: A Treatise on the Implications of Kelsen's Doctrine

by Uta Bindreiter

Overview

Who presupposes Kelsen's basic norm? Is it possible to defend the presupposition in a way that is convincing? And what difference does the presupposition make? Endeavouring to highlight the role of basic assumptions in the law, the author argues that the verb "to presuppose', with Kelsen, has not only a conceptual but also a normative dimension; and that the expression 'presupposing the basic norm'is adequate in so far as it marks the descriptive-normative nature of utterances made in specifically legal speech-situations.

Addressed to legal theorists in general, the treatise purports to show that Kelsen's doctrine lends itself to an interpretation according to which the very act of "presupposing" the Grundnorm can be understood as a Grund, i.e. normative source of all positive law; and, what is more, that this interpretation admits of addressing the issue of the (formal) legitimacy of supra-national and directly applicable rules and other norms.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9789041118677
Publisher:	Springer Netherlands
Publication date:	12/31/2002
Series:	Law and Philosophy Library , #58
Edition description:	2003
Pages:	249
Product dimensions:	6.10(w) x 9.25(h) x 0.36(d)

Table of Contents

Acknowledgements. Table of Abbreviations. Introduction. Part I: Traditional Theories: Kelsen v. Hart. 1. Kelsen's Doctrine of the Basic Norm. 2. Hart's Doctrine of the Rule of Recognition. 3. Choice of Doctrine. Part II: Juristic Consciousness. 1. Presupposing the Basic Norm I. 2. Presupposing the Basic Norm II. 3. Summary and Conclusion. Part III: Kelsen and Beyond. 1. Norm Conflicts. 2. Directly Applicable EC Law. Part IV: Why Kelsen's Basic Norm? 1. Democracy on the Supra-National Level. 2. A Basic Norm for EC Law. 3. Outlook. Bibliography. Index.