Vicos and Beyond: A Half Century of Applying Anthropology in Peru

by Tom Greaves Bucknell University (Editor), Ralph Bolton (Editor), Florencia Zapata (Editor), Clifford Barnett (Contribution by), Paul L. Doughty (Contribution by)

Overview

In 1952, Professor Allan Holmberg arranged for Cornell University to lease the Hacienda Vicos, an agricultural estate in the central Peruvian highlands on which some 1800 Quechua-speaking highland peasants resided. Between 1952 and 1957 Holmberg, with colleagues and students, initiated a set of social, economic, and agrarian changes, and nurtured mechanisms for community-based management of the estate by the resident peasants. By the end of a second lease in 1962, sufficient political pressure had been brought to bear on a reluctant national government to force the sale of Vicos to its people. Holmberg's twin goals for the Vicos Project were to bring about community possession of their land base and to study the process as it unfolded, advancing anthropological understanding of cultural change. To describe the process of doing both, he invented the term "participant intervention."

Despite the large corpus of existing Vicos publications, this book contains much information that here reaches print for the first time. The chapter authors do not entirely agree on various key points regarding the nature of the Vicos Project, the intentions of project personnel and community actors, and what interpretive framework is most valid; in part, these disagreements reflect the relevance and importance of the Vicos Project to contemporary applied anthropologists and the contrasting ways in which any historical event can be explained. Some chapters contrast Vicos with other projects in the southern Andean highlands; others examine new developments at Vicos itself. The conclusion suggests how those changes should be understood, within Andean anthropology and within anthropology more generally.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780759119741
Publisher:	AltaMira Press
Publication date:	11/16/2010
Pages:	358
Product dimensions:	6.20(w) x 9.10(h) x 1.10(d)

About the Author

Tom Greaves is emeritus professor of anthropology at Bucknell University. Ralph Bolton is professor of anthropology at Pomona College. Florencia Zapata is Cultural Heritage Program Officer at The Mountain Institute.

Table of Contents

Introduction Tom Greaves Ralph Bolton vii

Part I Remembering the Vicos Project

Chapter 1 Who Was That Gringo? Holmberg before Vicos Tom Greaves 3

Chapter 2 Early Years of the Vicos Project from the Perspective of a Sympathetic Participant Observer William Mangin 19

Chapter 3 Lessons from Vicos Clifford R. Barnett 39

Chapter 4 Anthropological Journeys: Vicos and the Callejón de Huaylas, 1948 to 2006 Paul L. Doughty 51

Part II Evaluating the Vicos Project

Chapter 5 Anthropological Hope and Social Reality: Cornell's Vicos Project Reexamined William P. Mitchell 81

Chapter 6 Modernizing Peru: Negotiating Indigenismo, Science, and the "Indian Problem" in the Cornell-Peru Project Jason Pribilsky 103

Chapter 7 Reflections on Vicos: Anthropology, the Cold War, and the Idea of Peasant Conservatism Eric B. Ross 129

Chapter 8 Vicos as a Model: A Retrospective Enrique Mayer 163

Part III Alternatives to the Vicos Project

Chapter 9 Globalizing Andean Society: Migration and Change in Peru's Peasant Communities Karsten Paerregaard 195

Chapter 10 Chijnaya-The Birth and Evolution of an Andean Community: Memories and Reflections of an Applied Anthropologist Ralph Bolton 215

Chapter 11 The Case of Kuyo Chico Jorge A. Flores Ochoa 265

Part IV Vicos Today

Chapter 12 Cornell Returns to Vicos, 2005 Billie Jean Isbell 283

Chapter 13 Remembering Vicos: Local Memories and Voices Florencia Zapata 309

Conclusion Tom Greaves Ralph Bolton Florencia Zapata 345

Index 349

About the Editors and Contributors 355

What People are Saying About This

Dwight B. Heath

Full of pros, cons, and new informative details, these insiders' essays offer fresh perspectives on Cornell's audacious social experiment.

Editorial Reviews

Vicos and Beyond is a thoughtfully put-together compilation on the contentious community development project run by Cornell in highland Peru in the mid-twentieth century.. . .[The book] challenge[s] methodological and theoretical paradigms on development work and make the collected works reviewed here invaluable to anthropologists struggling through the labyrinthine intricacies of applied collaborations today.. . .Vicos and Beyond is a keen exploration of the historiography of Andean applied anthropology that has brought novel and much-needed material from Peruvianists to the discipline-wide discussion on changes in applied research. It is thus fitting that the concluding portion of the volume points to a future in collaborative applied work where we include the stories, interpretations, and perceptions of the subjects who participate in research projects.

Collaborative Anthropologies

Full of pros, cons, and new informative details, these insiders' essays offer fresh perspectives on Cornell's audacious social experiment.

Dwight B. Heath

Considered a groundbreaking example of applied anthropology, the Cornell-Peru Project (CPP, 1952-62) is now mostly forgotten. Editors Greaves (emer., Bucknell Univ.), Bolton (Pomona College), and Zapata (The Mountain Institute) have assembled a volume that is part detailed history by surviving members of the project and part evaluation of it by anthropologists who were not part of it. Chapters by researchers describing similar projects and by anthropologists discussing the current state of Vicos round out the book. No consensus emerges as to the CPP's success or failure, but each contribution provides an important perspective on the project, the role of applied anthropology then and now, and the changes in Peruvian society since the 1950s. Graduate students and researchers interested in the relationship between anthropology and development, or the history of the discipline in Latin America, will find the book useful. Undergraduates will find the specificity of the contributions daunting, but those by Jason Pribilsky, Bolton, and Zapata discussing, respectively, anthropology in the era of Cold War politics, the continued relevance of applied anthropology, and a specific case of a cultural heritage program provide treatments accessible to advanced undergraduates. Summing Up: Recommended. Graduate students, researchers, faculty.

Choice Reviews

Considered a groundbreaking example of applied anthropology, the Cornell-Peru Project (CPP, 1952-62) is now mostly forgotten. Editors Greaves (emer., Bucknell Univ.), Bolton (Pomona College), and Zapata (The Mountain Institute) have assembled a volume that is part detailed history by surviving members of the project and part evaluation of it by anthropologists who were not part of it. Chapters by researchers describing similar projects and by anthropologists discussing the current state of Vicos round out the book. No consensus emerges as to the CPP's success or failure, but each contribution provides an important perspective on the project, the role of applied anthropology then and now, and the changes in Peruvian society since the 1950s. Graduate students and researchers interested in the relationship between anthropology and development, or the history of the discipline in Latin America, will find the book useful. Undergraduates will find the specificity of the contributions daunting, but those by Jason Pribilsky, Bolton, and Zapata discussing, respectively, anthropology in the era of Cold War politics, the continued relevance of applied anthropology, and a specific case of a cultural heritage program provide treatments accessible to advanced undergraduates. Summing Up: Recommended. Graduate students, researchers, faculty.

Choice

Considered a groundbreaking example of applied anthropology, the Cornell-Peru Project (CPP, 1952-62) is now mostly forgotten. Editors Greaves (emer., Bucknell Univ.), Bolton (Pomona College), and Zapata (The Mountain Institute) have assembled a volume that is part detailed history by surviving members of the project and part evaluation of it by anthropologists who were not part of it. Chapters by researchers describing similar projects and by anthropologists discussing the current state of Vicos round out the book. No consensus emerges as to the CPP's success or failure, but each contribution provides an important perspective on the project, the role of applied anthropology then and now, and the changes in Peruvian society since the 1950s. Graduate students and researchers interested in the relationship between anthropology and development, or the history of the discipline in Latin America, will find the book useful. Undergraduates will find the specificity of the contributions daunting, but those by Jason Pribilsky, Bolton, and Zapata discussing, respectively, anthropology in the era of Cold War politics, the continued relevance of applied anthropology, and a specific case of a cultural heritage program provide treatments accessible to advanced undergraduates. Summing Up: Recommended. Graduate students, researchers, faculty.

CHOICE