Publishers Weekly
03/27/2023
“To fully communicate with others, and maybe even with ourselves, we need to understand what’s happening with our hands,” asserts Goldin-Meadow (Hearing Gesture), a psychology professor at the University of Chicago, in this comprehensive offering. Goldin-Meadow suggests that people gesture partly because language is imperfect and better at capturing some details than others, and because gesturing provides a “different modality” through which to learn or work through a problem. In addition to aiding communication, the author writes, gestures can reveal internal bias and has been shown to improve memory (researchers found that adults who gestured while describing videos of people performing “sometimes odd actions” had a stronger recollection of them several weeks later than the nongesturers). Drawing on her own studies, Goldin-Meadow explores the practical applications of better understanding gesture, such as helping parents track their children’s cognitive development; explores how gesture can reveal conversational subtext; and examines how public figures gesture both subconsciously and intentionally, such as the way National Youth Poet Laureate Amanda Gorman used choreographed gestures to bring alive her 2020 poem, “The Hill We Climb.” Though the author tends to pile on the research a bit too thickly for the nonspecialist, readers will be captivated by the nuance and depth of her analysis, which excavates a topic that’s universally relevant yet little understood by most. This fascinates. (June)Correction: An earlier version of this review listed an incorrect title for the book.
From the Publisher
Thinking With Your Hands is a book of science exposition, something like a lecture from a good professor. …The subject is fascinating.”
—Timothy Farrington, Wall Street Journal
"a masterly tour through a lifetime’s research… No one who reads his book could ever again think that gesturing shows only a lack of control. It is about thinking and communication, and is a sophisticated aid to both.” —The Economist
“[a] thorough and powerful book”—Lisa Aziz-Zadeh, Science
"Thorough and insightful"—Dan Falk, Undark Magazine
"This book is big."—Terri Schlichenmeyer, Bookworm Sez
“readers will be captivated by the nuance and depth of her analysis, which excavates a topic that’s universally relevant yet little understood by most. This fascinates.”—Publishers Weekly
“thought-provoking… a fascinating look into communicating with gestures.”—Bridgette Whitt, Library Journal
"We modern humans swim in a sea of words, both written and spoken. Susan Goldin-Meadow reveals a deeper current of communication: the gestures we make with our hands. Her book is a fascinating exploration of the way gesture shapes how we learn, how we interact, even how we imagine and create. Thinking With Your Hands is an accessible and enjoyable book by the researcher who remade the field."—Annie Murphy Paul, author of The Extended Mind
“Susan Goldin-Meadow has expanded our understanding of language with her fascinating research on gesturing, and in this book she illuminates the nature of gesture and its intimate relationship to language and communication. Thinking With Your Hands is rich with information and insight.” —Steven Pinker, Johnstone Professor of Psychology, Harvard University, and author of The Language Instinct
“Susan Goldin-Meadow has astonished the scientific community time and again with her pathbreaking discoveries. Now she has written a tour de force for the rest of the world to benefit from. Thinking With Your Hands is one of those rare books that doesn’t just entertain and inform but changes the way you think about yourself and the people around you. It should be required reading for anyone who has ever used their hands to convey an idea or witnessed someone else do the same, which is to say, all of us.”
—Ethan Kross, bestselling author of Chatter
“This fascinating book will make you watch others’ hands—and be aware of your own. You will think differently about the nature of language, the nature of communication, and about the many ways that gestures can change thought, your own, and that of others.”—Barbara Tversky, author of Mind in Motion
“Thinking With Your Hands provides a fascinating look into the universal human phenomenon of gesturing, in both children and adults. Gesture is a critically important component of human communication, and this book is a wonderful and enjoyable contribution to its understanding. I highly recommend it.”—Henry L. Roediger III, James S. McDonnell Distinguished University Professor, Washington University in St. Louis
“Thinking With Your Hands gives us an inspirational overview of a lifetime of work on an aspect of human behavior that is fundamental to who we are as a species. With humor and humility, Susan Goldin-Meadow introduces us to the inner workings of gesture and the tireless efforts of those scientists trying to understand it. Richly illustrating her explanations with a huge array of thought-provoking examples, she reveals how our hands help us think and convey information about our unspoken inner world; what gesture can tell us about the evolution of language; and how understanding gesture could help us become better parents, doctors, and teachers. This is an accessible, eye-opening, and endlessly fascinating account from the undisputed authority in the field.” —Simon Kirby, Professor of Language Evolution, University of Edinburgh
“Gesture is all around us, but we often fail to understand its importance. In this book, Susan Goldin-Meadow shows how gesture forms an essential parallel to language, one that provides a unique window into our thoughts. Thinking With Your Hands reveals a hidden dimension of human communication.”—Carol Dweck, Stanford University
“Young children communicate in rich ways with gestures before language. With the acquisition of language, their gestures take on new functions - not just for communication but for supporting thinking. Susan Goldin-Meadow’s new book tells this story, much of it based on her own research, with both wisdom and wit.”—Michael Tomasello, Duke University
Library Journal
05/01/2023
In this thought-provoking book, leading gesture expert Goldin-Meadow (psychology, Univ. of Chicago; Hearing Gesture), a former president of the International Society for Gesture Studies, explains that people's hand movements when they speak often express hidden thoughts and unspoken details. The book takes an in-depth look at homesigns, invented gestures used by Deaf children to communicate when they either do not know the ASL gesture for the word or when they are communicating with others who do not know sign language. One particularly interesting chapter discusses how hand gestures can be used to unconsciously express thoughts, change minds, and also influence others' responses. The author asserts that hand gestures can affect the pace of learning and improve abstract reasoning and education. The book also indicates that restricting hand gestures can affect thinking processes. The book's three-part chapter groupings (with notes and index) provide logical, convincing arguments and a fascinating look into communicating with gestures. VERDICT Highly recommended for those interested in communication, nonverbal language, and kinesics.—Bridgette Whitt
