The Sublime Perversion of Capital: Marxist Theory and the Politics of History in Modern Japan

by Gavin Walker

Overview

In The Sublime Perversion of Capital Gavin Walker examines the Japanese debate about capitalism between the 1920s and 1950s, using it as a "prehistory" to consider current problems of uneven economic development and contemporary topics in Marxist theory and historiography.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780822361411
Publisher:	Duke University Press
Publication date:	03/25/2016
Series:	Asia-Pacific: Culture, Politics, and Society
Pages:	264
Product dimensions:	6.10(w) x 9.20(h) x 0.80(d)

About the Author

Gavin Walker is Assistant Professor of History and East Asian Studies at McGill University.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments  ix

Note on Translations  xiii

Three Orientations  xv

1. The Sublime Perversion of Capital   1

2. The Feudal Remnant and the Historical Outside  28

3. Primitive Accumulation, or the Logic of Origin  75

4. Labor Power: Capital's Threshold  108

5. The Continent of History and the Theoretical Inside  152

6. "The Ready-Made World of Capital"  182

Notes  195

Bibliography  225

Index  243

What People are Saying About This

Marx After Marx: History and Time in the Expansion of Capitalism - Harry Harootunian

"Gavin Walker's superb The Sublime Perversion of Capital is a brilliantly imaginative recovery of Marx's worldly vocation and the original premises of historical materialism dedicated to combining the immediacy of local contemporary circumstances with the global reach of capital. He realizes this singularly vital program by reflecting on the writings of the economist Uno Kōzō, especially his thinking on logic and history, as they intervened and culminated in the famous Marxian debate on capitalism in Japan's 1920s and 1930s in a context sparked by a rapidly uneven passage into capitalist modernity and its spillover into imperialism."
 

Border as Method, or, The Multiplication of Labor - Sandro Mezzadra

"What is capital? What is its relation with the 'world' and with the nation? What is its origin, its limit, and its 'other'? Reading the 'debate on Japanese capitalism' in the 1920s and 1930s against the grain of contemporary concerns, Gavin Walker invites us to a breathtaking intellectual journey. He provides a masterful interpretation of a crucial historical debate and makes a landmark contribution to our understanding of global capitalism and to the forging of a new project of liberation."
 

Editorial Reviews

"Gavin Walker’s book on the Japanese capitalism debate of the 1920s and 1930s, The Sublime Perversion of Capital, brings this important set of arguments on Marxist theory and history out of the domain of Japanese studies, where it is often cited but scarcely appreciated, and into dialogue with contemporary historiography and political theory. . . . The Sublime Perversion of Capital is an important and singular contribution to scholarship on Marxism and capitalism. It restores the sophistication of interwar Japanese debates on the country’s development and the development of capitalism on a global scale. Walker shows the significance of these debates for Marxism at a time when the Comintern’s dicta were challenged by the heterogeneity of the global political economy. His book thus reinstates the historicity of debates on the nature of capitalism and its historical manifestation, then and now.” 

American Historical Review - Christopher L. Hill

"Walker’s work offers something of value to both economic historians as well as Japanologists: an opportunity to catch a glimpse of the contributions of Japanese intellectuals as you focus on the tensions of Marxism and capitalism for the former and a review (if not (re)discovery) of the essentials of Marxism and capitalist theory while in pursuit of the history of contemporary Japanese social sciences for the latter."

New Books Asia - Anthony Rausch

"Gavin Walker's superb The Sublime Perversion of Capital is a brilliantly imaginative recovery of Marx's worldly vocation and the original premises of historical materialism dedicated to combining the immediacy of local contemporary circumstances with the global reach of capital. He realizes this singularly vital program by reflecting on the writings of the economist Uno Kozo, especially his thinking on logic and history, as they intervened and culminated in the famous Marxian debate on capitalism in Japan's 1920s and 1930s in a context sparked by a rapidly uneven passage into capitalist modernity and its spillover into imperialism."
 

Marx After Marx: History and Time in the Expansion of Capitalism - Harry Harootunian

"What is capital? What is its relation with the 'world' and with the nation? What is its origin, its limit, and its 'other'? Reading the 'debate on Japanese capitalism' in the 1920s and 1930s against the grain of contemporary concerns, Gavin Walker invites us to a breathtaking intellectual journey. He provides a masterful interpretation of a crucial historical debate and makes a landmark contribution to our understanding of global capitalism and to the forging of a new project of liberation."
 

Border as Method, or, The Multiplication of Labor - Sandro Mezzadra

"The Sublime Perversion of Capital makes an important intervention in both Japanese intellectual history and Marxist theory."--Viren Murthy "Journal of Asian Studies" (2/1/2019 12:00:00 AM)

"A truly interdisciplinary work that understands Japanese Marxism as part of a larger global moment. . . .Through Japanese Marxist writings, [Walker] shows how capital needs the state to commodify labor power, leading to a global system of borders and policing. In this light one might compare the book to recent Althusserian readings of Marx that theorize capitalism as comprising class structures related to the market, state, and world system. Walker also gestures in the direction of combined and uneven development and attempts to posit an alternative to the theoretical impasse between universal- ism and particularism by grounding both in a theory of capitalism. The Sublime Perversion of Capital remains essential reading for scholars interested in area studies, Japanese intellectual history, and Marxist theory and helps us rethink the role that capitalism and the nation-state play in shaping the world in which we live."--Viren Murthy "Monumenta Nipponica" (9/13/2018 12:00:00 AM)

"Gavin Walker's book on the Japanese capitalism debate of the 1920s and 1930s, The Sublime Perversion of Capital, brings this important set of arguments on Marxist theory and history out of the domain of Japanese studies, where it is often cited but scarcely appreciated, and into dialogue with contemporary historiography and political theory. . . . The Sublime Perversion of Capital is an important and singular contribution to scholarship on Marxism and capitalism. It restores the sophistication of interwar Japanese debates on the country's development and the development of capitalism on a global scale. Walker shows the significance of these debates for Marxism at a time when the Comintern's dicta were challenged by the heterogeneity of the global political economy. His book thus reinstates the historicity of debates on the nature of capitalism and its historical manifestation, then and now." --Christopher L. Hill "American Historical Review" (6/1/2018 12:00:00 AM)

"Original and erudite. . . . Gavin Walker develops a wide-ranging and densely argued Marxist theoretical account of capital and its (il)logics. The heart of his inquiry is what he calls capital's "sublime perversion" its ability to overcome, without resolving, its own contradictions, its 'constant and relentless transformation of limits into thresholds.' Walker's theorization of this perversion interweaves a set of concepts and approaches derived from Marx and from Walker's extensive reading (in, by my count, seven languages) of twentieth- and early twenty-first-century thinkers." --Derek Hall "Pacific Affairs" (3/1/2018 12:00:00 AM)

"Walker's book does much to clarify the relevance of Uno's work for both historical research and studies of the present moment; it occupies a central place in the on-going 'Uno Renaissance.'"--Katsuhiko Endo "Journal of Social History" (11/19/2016 12:00:00 AM)

"Walker's work offers something of value to both economic historians as well as Japanologists: an opportunity to catch a glimpse of the contributions of Japanese intellectuals as you focus on the tensions of Marxism and capitalism for the former and a review (if not (re)discovery) of the essentials of Marxism and capitalist theory while in pursuit of the history of contemporary Japanese social sciences for the latter."--Anthony Rausch "New Books Asia" (9/15/2017 12:00:00 AM)

From the Publisher

"A truly interdisciplinary work that understands Japanese Marxism as part of a larger global moment. . . .Through Japanese Marxist writings, [Walker] shows how capital needs the state to commodify labor power, leading to a global system of borders and policing. In this light one might compare the book to recent Althusserian readings of Marx that theorize capitalism as comprising class structures related to the market, state, and world system. Walker also gestures in the direction of combined and uneven development and attempts to posit an alternative to the theoretical impasse between universal- ism and particularism by grounding both in a theory of capitalism. The Sublime Perversion of Capital remains essential reading for scholars interested in area studies, Japanese intellectual history, and Marxist theory and helps us rethink the role that capitalism and the nation-state play in shaping the world in which we live.

Monumenta Nipponica - Viren Murthy

Original and erudite. . . . Gavin Walker develops a wide-ranging and densely argued Marxist theoretical account of capital and its (il)logics. The heart of his inquiry is what he calls capital’s “sublime perversion”: its ability to overcome, without resolving, its own contradictions, its 'constant and relentless transformation of limits into thresholds.' Walker’s theorization of this perversion interweaves a set of concepts and approaches derived from Marx and from Walker’s extensive reading (in, by my count, seven languages) of twentieth- and early twenty-first-century thinkers.” 

Pacific Affairs - Derek Hall

"Walker’s book does much to clarify the relevance of Uno’s work for both historical research and studies of the present moment; it occupies a central place in the on-going 'Uno Renaissance.'"

Journal of Social History - Katsuhiko Endo