The Second Opinion

by Michael Palmer Narrated by Franette Liebow

Overview

Struck down by a hit-and-run driver, one of the world's most respected doctors lies comatose in the ICU unit of Boston's Beaumont Clinic. No one thinks he will survive. Two of his children believe treatment should be stopped. But his daughter Thea refuses to give up hope-and begins to suspect a cover-up. As a brilliant physician who left the hospital to work with the poor, Thea knows all too well the hidden agendas and personal conflicts that lurk beneath the surface of an elite medical center. When a late-night hospital intruder is identified as a professional killer, Thea is convinced her father's accident was no accident-and someone plans to finish the job...

Who would want to kill a man who saves lives-and why? The answers, Thea fears, are locked deep inside the mind of the only living witness-her father-a man who cannot move or speak. Until the flutter of a single eyelid provides him the means to communicate...and offers Thea a terrifying glimpse into an unfathomable conspiracy.

Editorial Reviews

Publishers Weekly

In this routine medical thriller from bestseller Palmer (The First Patient), Dr. Thea Sperelakis, an idealist who's been working for Doctors Without Borders in the Congo, rushes back to Boston after learning her physician father, Petros, an intimidating figure known as the Lion, is close to death, the victim of a hit-and-run. Thea faces one challenge after another, including having to resuscitate Petros when his heart stops beating. Her brilliant if socially challenged older brother, Dimitri, adds to her anxiety with his computer reconstruction of the accident, which indicates the driver struck Petros deliberately. When Thea manages to communicate haltingly with her father, she suspects he's stumbled on some medical fraud that's made him the target of those behind the fraud. Aided by the requisite hunky ex-cop turned hospital security guard, Thea doggedly seeks out the truth. Robin Cook fans have seen all this before and in more engaging form. (Feb.)

Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

Library Journal

Thea Sperelakis has returned home to Boston from her latest assignment in the Congo for Doctors Without Borders. Her father, Petros, also a physician and medical director of the Sperelakis Institute, lies comatose as a result of a car accident. Although Petros apparently has locked-in syndrome and can communicate with her only by blinking an eye, Thea soon suspects that the crash was no accident. Her twin siblings, Niko and Selene, who are also doctors, never see such communications from their father and believe that he should just be allowed to die peacefully. However, older brother Dimitri, a reclusive computer programmer, is also convinced someone tried to kill their father. With help from ex-policeman and hospital security guard Dan Cotton and wealthy patient Hayley Long, Thea must overcome the limitations of her Asperger's syndrome to uncover the conspiracy behind the attempt on her father's life. Physician Palmer's 14th medical thriller (after The First Patient) puts the attractive and capable Thea in various kinds of peril before the surprising resolution. Buy anywhere Robin Cook and other medical thriller authors are popular. [See Prepub Alert, LJ10/15/08.].
—A.J. Wright

From the Publisher

“A heart-pounding medical thriller…satisfying, expertly paced [with] enough suspense to keep readers happily turning the pages.” —Boston Globe

“The novel is not merely a thriller but also an exploration of its central character's unique gifts and her determination to communicate with her comatose father despite overwhelming odds. Another winner from a consistently fine writer.” —Booklist

“A splendid novel.” —Globe and Mail (Canada)

APRIL 2009 - AudioFile

Dr. Thea Sperelakis is forced to rush home from the Congo, where she works as a doctor, after her father falls ill. Of course, this is a Palmer thriller, so there is far more than meets the eye going on at home. Thea's neurotic brother, Dmitri, uncovers a murderous plot to conceal medical fraud. Narrator Franette Liebow delivers a consuming performance that makes this over-the-top story seem plausible. Liebow's voice captures the expansive range of emotions that abound in each character, especially Thea and her ailing father. Liebow's accents are pitch perfect, and her voice is the ideal medium to bring a complex medical thriller to life. She never sounds as though she is reading but as though the events in question could actually be happening to her. L.B. © AudioFile 2009, Portland, Maine

Product Details

BN ID:	2940172502477
Publisher:	Brilliance Audio
Publication date:	02/17/2009
Edition description:	Unabridged

Read an Excerpt

PROLOGUE

“I’m afraid I have some bad news.”

Hayley Long, just two weeks past her fi fty- fi rst birthday, heard her

physician’s words as if they were being spoken through a long steel

tube.

I’m afraid I have some bad news. . . .

She wondered fl eetingly how many thousands of people heard the

same thing from their doctor every day? How many patients every

hour, maybe every minute, rode those words screeching through a

sudden right- angle turn in their lives.

I’m afraid . . .

Stephen Bibby, a graduate of Emory Med, had been her physician

since a bout of pneumonia twenty or so years ago. He was a man

Hayley respected, if for no other reason than that Bibby knew his

limitations and never hesitated to make a phone call and arrange a

specialist referral for a second opinion.

Hayley felt a wave of nausea sweep over her, and thought for a moment

she was going to have to excuse herself to go and get sick even

before she found out precisely what she was up against. She made a

largely unsuccessful attempt at a calming breath, and tried to maintain

an even gaze.

“It’s cancer?”

Hayley heard the word in her own voice, but couldn’t believe she

had actually uttered it. Her thoughts wouldn’t stay still.

Cancer . . . How could that be? . . . Oh, God, no.

Her initial symptom had been nothing more than an annoying sequence

of belly pain and gas. She almost hadn’t even bothered to

mention them to her executive assistant. He was the one who had

talked her into calling Bibby. It was his fault.

The MRI Bibby had requested was of her abdomen.

Cancer.

The dizziness and nausea intensifi ed.

David didn’t handle illness at all well, in himself or others, but at

some point she would have to tell him. Not yet, though. Not until all

the data were in. He was off skippering his boat in a round- the- world

race—his lifetime dream. He had lost his fi rst wife to a brain aneurysm,

and had waited more than ten years before marrying again.

Now this.

She had to tell him soon, but not yet.

Bibby, a Southern gentleman in his early sixties, looked toward

the door as if hoping that another doctor would march into the offi ce

and take over.

“I asked, is it cancer?”

Biting at his lip, the physician nodded.

“Operable?” she asked.

Come on, Stephen! Help me out here!

“I . . . I don’t know. It looks to have started in your pancreas.

That’s the organ which—”

“I know what the pancreas is. I hear Jimmy Carter talking about

pancreatic cancer every time I turn on the damn TV. Has it spread?”

“It’s . . . it appears to be in some places in your liver.”

Bibby turned on his computer with a click of his mouse and rotated

it so Hayley could see. A child could have picked out the cancer

in her MRI—an obscene white mass, dead center in her belly. Dead

center. How ironic that her mind’s default for something in the middle

would have been those words.

Please let this be a dream. Please let it be a fucking dream.

Hayley rubbed at her eyes as if trying to paw away the disbelief. At

fi fty, she had everything she could ever have wanted—marriage to a

wonderful, caring man; stepchildren who treated her like their birth

mother; more money and infl uence than most people could even

dream of; and a perspective on life that made everything make sense.

Now this.

Pancreatic cancer . . . Inoperable . . . God, don’t let it be, Hayley Long

thought desperately. Let it be a dream. . . . Let it be nothing but a

bad dream.

Petros Sperelakis’s awareness returned gradually and spasmodically.

The pain came fi rst—a dull throbbing in his groin and burning sensation

in his low back. He tried to move, to shift his position, but his

body did not respond.

Please, I don’t think I can move. Someone please help me. I’m Sperelakis,

Dr. Petros Sperelakis. I can’t see and I can’t move.

“Connie, why don’t you take a break. I’ll be here for another

hour.”

“Okay, thanks. Listen, Vernice, he could use some range- of- motion

work on his wrists and ankles.”

Connie? Vernice? I can hear you. I can hear you. Are you Beaumont nurses?

It’s me, Dr. Sperelakis. What do you mean, range of motion? Am I paralyzed?

What happened to me? An accident? A stroke? A tumor? Why can’t I see? Why

can’t I speak?

The man many considered to be among the premier diagnostic

physicians in the world struggled to make sense of his own symptoms.

He knew he was having diffi culty holding on to a thought, and

that fact frightened him more than almost anything.

Why am I in such pain? Can someone please tell me what happened? What

happened to me? I can feel that, Vernice. I can feel you moving my ankle. Oh,

my God. . . .

CHAPTER 1

Multiple contusions and abrasions . . . Fractured pelvis . . . Nondisplaced

fracture, proximal humerus . . . Pulmonary contusion and laceration secondary

to posterior displaced fractures of right seventh, eighth, and ninth

ribs . . .

With the grim litany ticking through her thoughts, Thea Sperelakis

approached Cubicle 4 in the medical ICU of the Beaumont

Clinic.

Transverse linear skull fracture . . . Extensive mid– brain stem hemorrhage . . .

Level I coma . . .

Thea hesitated, envisioning what her father would look like and

knowing that, as an internal medicine specialist herself, her projection

would not be far from on the mark. According to her brother

Niko, police estimated that the vehicle that struck their father at fi ve

thirty in the early morning eight days ago, then drove away, had to

have been traveling seventy, at least. It was a miracle he had survived

the impact, which threw him more than twenty- fi ve feet. But then,

for as long as Thea could remember, Petros Sperelakis was, to his

children, the Lion—aloof, powerful, and brilliant, often to the point

of majesty.

The Lion.

The absence of skid marks suggested that the driver never saw his

victim. Make that his or her victim, Thea edited, intent on enforcing

that sort of accuracy, even in her thoughts. The police still had no

clues and no witnesses.

Alcohol, she guessed. According to an article by Eileen Posnick in

a seven- year- old issue of the American Journal of Drug and Alcohol Abuse,

alcohol was involved in more than 90 percent of hit- and- run accidents

where the drivers were eventually apprehended.

Behind her, Niko stepped out from the group that included his

twin, Selene, plus a trio of Beaumont Clinic dignitaries, and took

Thea’s arm. He was swarthy and broad- shouldered, with their father’s

strong nose and piercing dark eyes, but with features that were

somewhat softer. At forty, he was already an associate professor of

cardiac surgery at Harvard—a wunderkind, with several signifi cant

contributions to the fi eld. Selene, exotic, elegant, and totally selfassured,

was no less accomplished as a hand surgeon.

“You okay, Thea?” Niko asked softly.

As she had been taught to do, Thea searched her feelings before

responding. Her father, bigger than life itself, was in a deep coma

from which there was a 0.01 percent chance he would recover even

minimal function—at least according to the retrospective study of

traumatic midbrain hemorrhages published by Harkinson et al. in the

American Archives of Neurology, volume 117, page 158. One in ten thousand,

not counting the ribs and other fractures.

Poor Dad.

“I’m okay,” she replied.

“Want to go in alone?”

Why would I want to do that? she wondered, shaking her head.

Would their father be any less comatose if she saw him by herself?

She shrugged that it made no diff erence, but sensed she could have

come up with a more acceptable response.

“Suit yourself,” Niko said in a tone that was quite familiar to her.

Thea knew her brother cared about her—Selene, too. She also

knew that the twins had always thought she was odd, though certainly

not as odd as their oldest sibling, Dimitri. But their attitude, as

emphasized over and over by Thea’s longtime therapist and mentor,

Dr. Paige Carpenter, was their problem.

One in ten thousand . . . Poor Dad.

Thea ran her fi ngers through her short chestnut hair, took a single

deep breath, and stepped through the doorway.

As anticipated, there were no surprises. Legendary Petros Sperelakis,

medical director of the Sperelakis Institute for Diagnostic

Medicine, lay motionless—the central fi gure in a tableau of medical

machines. Across the room, his private duty nurse (Haitian, Thea

guessed) rose and introduced herself as Vernice.

“I have heard a great deal about you, Dr. Thea,” she said. “I hope

your fl ight was an easy one.”

“I just read,” Thea said, taking the husky woman’s smooth, ample

hand.

I just read.

It was, Thea knew, the most resounding of understatements. During

the twenty- hour series of fl ights and layovers from the Democratic

Republic of the Congo to Boston, she had read Don Quixote, the

second edition of Deadman’s A Manual of Acu punc ture (for the second

time), and Darwin’s Voyage of the Beagle—more than sixteen hundred

pages in all. She would have made the trip home sooner, but she

was on a mission moving from refugee camp to camp in the bush

with a team of nutritionists, and simply couldn’t be reached.

“There’s been no change,” Vernice said.

“I’d be most surprised if there were. He has taken a severe

beating—especially to his head.”

Thea approached the bedside, instinctively checking the monitors

and intravenous infusions. Petros lay quite peacefully, connected via

a tracheotomy tube to a state- of- the- art ventilator. The various

Medecins Sans Frontières (Doctors Without Borders) hospitals to

which Thea had been assigned over the past fi ve years had been reasonably

well equipped, but nothing like this place.

The Beaumont, as nearly everyone referred to the institution, was

a sprawling campus, the size of a small university, consisting of what

had once been Boston Metropolitan Hospital, now augmented by

two dozen more buildings, varying widely in architectural style. The

buildings were linked by tree- lined sidewalks above, and an intricate

maze of tunnels below, some with moving walkways and others with

tarnished tile walls, leading in places to stairways that went down for

two or three damp stories, and dating back to Metro’s earliest days

in the mid- nineteenth century.

Oxygen saturation . . . arterial blood pressure . . . cerebrospinal

fl uid pressure . . . central venous pressure . . . urine output . . .

chest tube drainage . . . cardiac rhythm and ECG pattern . . .

Thea took in the complex data and pro cessed them as if they were

a grade- school primer. Steady. Everything was nice and steady. At

the moment, the fi erce battle for the life of Petros Sperelakis was being

fought at a cellular and even subcellular level. And his youn gest

off spring, cursed by him when she made the decision to avoid academic

medicine and “give her ser vices away,” to third- world countries,

pictured the microscopic confl ict clearly in her mind’s eye.

At best it would probably be weeks before the man regained any

consciousness. Along the way, his system would have to negotiate a

minefi eld of infections, blood clots, kidney stones, embolisms, ce rebral

swelling, chemical imbalance, intestinal obstructions, and cardiac

events. But in this setting, with this equipment, he would at

least have a fi ghting chance. Still, from what Thea knew of her father,

if it were his choice, it was doubtful he would try very hard to steer

clear of the mines.

She took the man’s hand and held it for a time. It had been only

eight days since the accident, but his muscle mass was already beginning

to waste away. In addition to the trach, he had a gastric feeding

tube in place, two IVs, a urinary catheter, which was draining briskly

into a collection bag, and a BOLT pressure manometer that passed

through his skull and into the spinal fl uid–containing ventricle of his

brain. His eyelids were paper- taped down to protect his corneas

from drying out, and splints on his wrists and ankles were strapped

in place to prevent joint contractures, against the remote possibility

of a return of function.

Petros Sperelakis—an icon brought down by a driver who was either

in an alcoholic blackout or was aware enough to try and get away

before anyone showed up. Never had Thea’s father looked even remotely

vulnerable to her. Now, he looked frail and pathetically infantile.

Thea sensed that she was expected to stay at the bedside a bit longer,

and she planned to be there as much as possible in the days to

come. But she had slept little if any on the planes, and the exhaustion

of the fl ights was beginning to take hold. Fifteen minutes, she decided.

Fifteen more minutes would be enough to stay at the bedside

whether the others thought so or not.

Niko had invited her to stay at his house, but three kids under ten,

much as she loved them, provided more commotion than she could

handle.

Selene and her partner, a banker or businesswoman of some kind,

lived in a designer high- rise condo by the harbor.

The obvious choice was the spacious Wellesley home in which she

and the others had grown up, and where Petros still lived with the

ghost of their mother and with Dimitri who, many years before, had

moved into the carriage house along with his computers, his monitors,

his shortwave radio, his telescope, his machinery, his library of

manga, graphic novels, and Dungeons and Dragons manuals, and his

vast collection of Coca- Cola and Star Wars memorabilia.

It would be good to see her brother again for many reasons, not

the least of which was that of all those in her family, he was the one

she related to the most—something of a mirror of what she might

have been like had she not had the benefi t of early diagnosis, intervention,

and extensive behavior modifi cation therapy.

From her early childhood, Thea had memories of the family talking

about Dimitri’s aloofness and strange behaviors—his lack of

friends, off beat humor, and often- inappropriate statements. Physical

age, twelve years ahead of her. Emotional age, inconsistent and unpredictable.

“Dimitri, this is Robert, your new piano teacher.”

“Oh, hello. When’s the last time you went to the dentist?”

She would never know the bulk of what the family said to one another

about her, but she also knew that the choices she had made,

with Dr. Carpenter’s help, were the right ones for her, and ultimately,

for her patients. Keeping her life as uncomplicated as possible,

she had learned, was not only a pathway to happiness, it was

her roadmap to survival. If there was any single word that did not apply

to Petros Sperelakis, it was uncomplicated.

Born and raised in Athens until his late teens, Petros was strictly

Old Country in his attitudes and philosophy—a brilliant physician as

dedicated to his calling and his patients as he was hard on his family.

Verbal chastisement and high expectations were his weapons, as well

as his only means of expressing love. His wife, Eleni, had rebelled

against him in one way and one way only, by continuing to smoke

cigarettes despite his vehement edicts that she stop. The lung cancer

that took her did nothing to soften Petros, and virtually every mention

of her by him was followed by the impotent plea: “If she had only

listened to me . . . If only she had listened.”

Thea reached between the tubes and brushed some damp, gray

hair from her father’s brow. The sadness she was feeling at seeing

him in such a state was, she knew, as much learned as it was deepseated

and visceral. But she also knew that it was still as real an emotion

as those of her two “neurotypical” siblings.

From the beginning, Petros could never understand her shyness,

or the severe reactions she had to certain noises—especially vacuum

cleaners and hair dryers—as well as to certain foods, and diff erent

textures of clothing. When she was twelve, pressured by Eleni that

she was seeming more and more like Dimitri in her lack of friends

and her pathological obsessions, especially with books of all kinds,

Petros consented to allow his wife to bring her to Dr. Carpenter. It

was Carpenter who subsequently suggested that Thea was exhibiting

many of the symptoms associated with the condition called Asperger

syndrome.

The decision to allow his younger daughter to undergo neuropsychiatric

testing and therapy did not come easily to Petros. In the

lexicon of his life, there was no such word as can’t and no such concept

as psychotherapy. If he had any weakness at all as a diagnostician,

it was in the area of psychosomatic illness and the mind- body

connection.

“I think he’s comfortable,” Vernice ventured from across the bed.

“I’m sure he is,” Thea replied, managing with some diffi culty to

swallow her belief that if Petros was feeling anything, then he was

certainly not comfortable, and if he was feeling nothing at all, then

trying to equate that void with comfort was a stretch.

“Your brother Dimitri said that if your father was in as deep a

coma as he appears to be, it was a futile exercise to wonder if he was

comfortable or not.”

“Sometimes, Dimitri says things just for the shock eff ect,” Thea

replied, smiling inwardly at the number of times and situations in

which her eccentric sibling had done just that. Vernice had gotten off

relatively easily.

“Well,” the nurse said, “at least we have the comfort of knowing

that Dr. S. is being taken care of in the greatest hospital in the

world.”

“Yes,” Thea said, wondering where Vernice, and Newsweek, and the

countless others who believed as she did about the Beaumont, could

have gotten such quantifi cation about something so unquantifi able.

at virtually the same instant, in the Susan and Clyde Terry Cancer

Center, on the far side of the broad campus of the so- called greatest

hospital in the world, the treatment nurse was doing her job,

injecting a cutting- edge experimental drug into the central IV port

of a burly man named Jeff rey Fagone.

Fagone, a trucking magnate from western Pennsylvania, had his

rapid accumulation of wealth interrupted by an unusual variant of

the blood cancer known as Waldenstrom’s macroglobulinemia. His

presenting symptom had been lower-back pain. The referral by his primary

care doctor had been to the expert in the disease at the Beaumont,

where Fagone went yearly for his fi ve- day spa pampering and

executive medical checkup. Now, he was part of a cutting- edge treatment

protocol—the sort of protocol that the doctors at the Beaumont

were renowned for establishing.

Fagone fl ew up to the Terry Center weekly on his Gulfstream

G500 corporate jet. Now he was about to receive the third in a series

of ten treatments. The fi rst two had been absolutely uneventful.

This injection, however, would be diff erent.

The vial from which the medication was drawn had been skillfully

switched during its journey from the research pharmacy to the cancer

center. The new vial, with the same ID number as the old one, now

contained enough concentrated bee venom to turn Fagone’s bee sting

allergy, duly noted in his medical record, into an anaphylactic

reaction—a fearsome medical emergency, equivalent to the Fourth

of July fi reworks on the Charles River Esplanade.

The eruption did not take long to begin. The fi rst few molecules of

the venom instantly began mobilizing mast cells from all over

Fagone’s body. The cells released huge amounts of histamine and

other sensitivity chemicals. More venom, more mast cells, more histamine.

In less than a minute, Fagone’s tongue, cardinal red, had

swollen to the size of a golf ball, and his lips to violet sausages. The

muscles in the walls of his bronchial tubes went into vicious spasm.

Seconds after that, his larynx, also in spasm, closed off altogether.

His entire body became scarlet, and his fi ngers became nothing more

than nubs protruding from softball- sized hands.

The team in the Terry unit acted quickly, bringing out a stretcher

and hoisting the two- hundred- and- seventy- pound former teamster

onto it, then wheeling him to an area that could be screened off from

other patients.

But they were paddling against a medical tsunami.

The IV port was available, but the oncologist covering the unit, a

young woman less than half Fagone’s size, was not skilled in dealing

with emergencies of this magnitude. By the time she got the right

medications into the man, Fagone’s blood pressure had been zero

for nearly three minutes. By the time she gave up trying to force an

endotracheal breathing tube past the massively swollen, distorted

vocal cords, and began clumsily performing her fi rst emergency tracheotomy

while waiting for the ENT surgeon to answer his page,

there had been no eff ective respirations for four minutes. She had

just sliced a scalpel across her patient’s massive throat when his

heart stopped. The blood fl owing from the gaping laceration was

gentian.

When the oncologist, frustrated and utterly demoralized, called

off the resuscitation at the ten- minute mark, a useful airway had still

not been established.

Jeff rey Fagone, who years before had survived two assassination

attempts during his rise to wealth and power in the Teamsters

Union, had no chance of surviving this one.

Unlike the other attempts, however, there was no suspicion of

anything sinister at work here. Fagone had been done in by a lethal

allergic reaction to Waldenstrom’s macroglobulinemia experimental

drug #BW1745. No one present that day thought otherwise. There

would be no analysis of the contents of the vial, and the perfunctory

autopsy performed the next morning would disclose nothing out of

the ordinary.

The treatment protocol for #BW1745 would be suspended indefi -

nitely, but within just a few months, the principal investigator, supported

by a hefty grant from one of the pharmaceutical giants, would

roll out another experimental drug to meet the demand of referrals

from all over the world.

The Susan and Clyde Terry Cancer Center closed for cleanup and

staff support for an hour after the tragic event, but there were patients

to treat, many of whom had come from even greater distances

than Jeff rey Fagone.

Soon, like the surface of a pond disturbed by a jumping fish, the

ripples had subsided, and the world’s greatest hospital had gone back

to being the world’s greatest hospital.

Videos