The Politics of Historic Districts: A Primer for Grassroots Preservation

by William E. Schmickle

Overview

The worst thing in politics is to be right and to lose. This how-to guide will give citizens who are fighting to designate a local historic district the political know-how to win the support of fellow residents and city hall. Everything is here: learning to think politically, mastering the political process; planning and strategy; campaign organizing and leadership; framing a practical vision; anticipating and handling the opposition; conducting community meetings; skirmishing with property rightists; managing issues, petitions, and public opinion; dealing with public officials; strategizing for public hearings; and winning the vote for district designation. The Politics of Historic Districts is an indispensable resource whose practical, hands-on lessons are informed by extensive research and the author's own experiences in winning a district designation, chairing a historic preservation commission, and teaching political science. By showing how and why communities make political decisions to designate historic districts, Bill Schmickle encourages preservationists to ignore the traditional tensions between preservation and political action and points the way to a fuller understanding of the politics that shape local historic districts.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780759114098
Publisher:	AltaMira Press
Publication date:	09/18/2006
Sold by:	Barnes & Noble
Format:	eBook
Pages:	280
File size:	2 MB

About the Author

Bill Schmickle currently chairs the Annapolis Historic Preservation Commission and was a cofounder of the Oak Ridge, NC, Historic District. He and his wife, Charlotte, own and operate Flag House Inn in the Annapolis National Landmark Historic District. A former professor of political science, he now writes and consults on preservation issues.

Table of Contents

Chapter 1 Introduction: What D'ya Know?
Chapter 2 1. Before You Take Another Step
Chapter 3 2. Thinking Politically about Historic District Designation
Chapter 4 3. How It Starts
Chapter 5 4. A Walk through the Designation Process
Chapter 6 5. On Planning and Strategy
Chapter 7 6. Our Strategic Line: A Community in/ within Conflict
Chapter 8 7. Makers, Breakers, Takers, and Shapers: The Political Field of Play
Chapter 9 8. Leadership and Organization
Chapter 10 9. Working with Shapers
Chapter 11 10. A Practical Vision
Chapter 12 11. Thinking Politically about Design Guidelines
Chapter 13 12. It's Personal
Chapter 14 13. Sticks&Stones
Chapter 15 14. The Campaign Kickoff
Chapter 16 15. Community Meeting Arrangements
Chapter 17 16. Your Community Presentation
Chapter 18 17. FAQs: Frequently Asked Questions
Chapter 19 18. Thinking Politically about Q&A: The Moving Pattern of Opponents' Challenges
Chapter 20 19. Our Reframing Q&A Strategy
Chapter 21 20. Answering Opposition Questions I: From "Distrust of Them" to the "Pivotal Shift"
Chapter 22 21. Answering Opposition Questions II: From the "Pivotal Shift" to "Distrust of Us"
Chapter 23 22. Skirmishing with Radical Property Rightists
Chapter 24 23. Petition Politics
Chapter 25 24. Reaching Out to the Opposition
Chapter 26 25. Moving on to City Hall
Chapter 27 26. Behind-the-Scenes Intelligence
Chapter 28 27. Working with the Press
Chapter 29 28. A Civic Vision
Chapter 30 29. The Politics of Public Hearings
Chapter 31 30. A Conversation with a Lobbyist
Chapter 32 31. A Checklist for One-on-One Meetings
Chapter 33 32. Our Public Hearing Presentation
Chapter 34 33. The Politics of Compromise
Chapter 35 34. Winning the Vote

What People are Saying About This

Dan Becker

Food for thought! What first appears to be an hors d'oeuvres tray of thirty-four quick-bite chapters turns out to be a deeply satisfying multi-course meal of substance and insight. Bill Schmickle has jumped out of the fire of his own historic districting experience to grab the handle of the political frying pan. Follow his practical and easy-to-read recipe and you too can blend the complex ingredients of political advocacy into a home-cooked feast of preservation success.

Nita Parry

One of preservations biggest threats is relying on the reactive approach. Bill details why this is not good preservation and then moves on to provide the tools to become a true preservationist who is passionate all the time, not just when the threat becomes public knowledge and front page news. . . . In those democratic systems that American cherish, there can be very little long term preservation without politics. This book could just as easily be called "When reality meets preservation!

Pratt Cassity

Living with politics and historic preservation has always been unpredictable and controversial. This book will make it easier to navigate the treacherous path of creating a local historic district. Bill Schmickle's adventurous and often humorous approach to demystifying the citizen's journey is a must read for the seasoned or novice preservationist.

Karen Gordon

It's not enough to be passionate about protecting historic resources—you have to be strategic. This book is a great 'how-to' guide for the novice or even the experienced community activist. Bill Schmickle really zeroes in on what you can anticipate and how you can succeed. It is a 'must-read' for anyone who contemplates leading a citizen campaign for historic district status.

Stephen Frantzich

'Think globally, act locally,' can have no more practical application than historical preservation. While virtually everyone favors preserving the best of the past for future generations in the abstract, putting concrete plans into action engenders some of the most basic political instincts and conflicts. While this well-written and lively book can effectively be used as a 'how to' manual for historic preservationists developed by someone who has been there in the trenches, it also provides a myriad of insights on the general topic of effective political activism. If nothing else, the book is worth it for the pithy quotes that begin its succinct 34 chapters. Its author brings a political scientist’s perspective and a participant’s passion to a policy realm where today’s decisions clearly preclude future reversal.

Editorial Reviews

This how-to guide gives citizens who are struggling to designate a local historic district the political wherewithal to gain the support of fellow residents and city hall. A former professor of political science, the author pushes preservationists to disregard the long-established conflicts between preservation and political action and points the way to a more comprehensive understanding of the politics that fashions local historic districts.

The Courier

Food for thought! What first appears to be an hors d'oeuvres tray of thirty-four quick-bite chapters turns out to be a deeply satisfying multi-course meal of substance and insight. Bill Schmickle has jumped out of the fire of his own historic districting experience to grab the handle of the political frying pan. Follow his practical and easy-to-read recipe and you too can blend the complex ingredients of political advocacy into a home-cooked feast of preservation success.

Dan Becker

Through thirty-four brief, often lightly humorous, rapid-fire chapters, the author engages readers in the battles over historic zoning so they understand the necessary steps on a path to victory. They will learn how to engage in and use politics to good effect throughout the lengthy process of shaping sound public policy...If you decide to make a difference in preserving your community's sense of place, then decide to win by reading this book. You will be more than prepared for the fight.

AASLH History News

The Politics of Historic Districts would be a useful volume for any historic preservation commission's library.

The Commissioner

It's not enough to be passionate about protecting historic resources—you have to be strategic. This book is a great 'how-to' guide for the novice or even the experienced community activist. Bill Schmickle really zeroes in on what you can anticipate and how you can succeed. It is a 'must-read' for anyone who contemplates leading a citizen campaign for historic district status.

Karen Gordon

Living with politics and historic preservation has always been unpredictable and controversial. This book will make it easier to navigate the treacherous path of creating a local historic district. Bill Schmickle's adventurous and often humorous approach to demystifying the citizen's journey is a must read for the seasoned or novice preservationist.

Pratt Cassity

One of preservations biggest threats is relying on the reactive approach. Bill details why this is not good preservation and then moves on to provide the tools to become a true preservationist who is passionate all the time, not just when the threat becomes public knowledge and front page news.. .. In those democratic systems that American cherish, there can be very little long term preservation without politics. This book could just as easily be called "When reality meets preservation!"

Nita Parry

'Think globally, act locally,' can have no more practical application than historical preservation. While virtually everyone favors preserving the best of the past for future generations in the abstract, putting concrete plans into action engenders some of the most basic political instincts and conflicts. While this well-written and lively book can effectively be used as a 'how to' manual for historic preservationists developed by someone who has been there in the trenches, it also provides a myriad of insights on the general topic of effective political activism. If nothing else, the book is worth it for the pithy quotes that begin its succinct 34 chapters. Its author brings a political scientist’s perspective and a participant’s passion to a policy realm where today’s decisions clearly preclude future reversal.

Stephen Frantzich

Through thirty-four brief, often lightly humorous, rapid-fire chapters, the author engages readers in the battles over historic zoning so they understand the necessary steps on a path to victory. They will learn how to engage in and use politics to good effect throughout the lengthy process of shaping sound public policy...If you decide to make a difference in preserving your community's sense of place, then decide to win by reading this book. You will be more than prepared for the fight.

History News