Book of the Month Club Selection
New York Times Editor’s Choice
“Heller gives us a dishy tale of nosy neighbors, mysterious vandalism, family shame — and murder…Heller places a ticking time bomb inside each character’s house, and locating them is half the fun of this book. The other half comes from Heller’s sense of humor, which is wicked without being unkind."
—New York Times
“If you've been craving a Big Little Lies-esque thriller, then The Neighbor's Secret by L. Alison Heller is sure to be one of your favorite reads this year.”
—PopSugar, The 55 Best New Books of October
“A complicated story of women and their secrets...that come together in an Oh-My-God ending… a first-rate Colorado mystery set around the challenges mothers face.”
—The Denver Post
"Perfect for fans of Big Little Lies."
—The Sentinel Colorado
“With its imaginative plot, charismatic characters, and wealth of dramatic revelations, this addictive tale is one of those novels that demands to be gobbled up in a single sitting. Great for book clubs (whose members may or may not have their own secrets) and for domestic-thriller lovers in general.”
—Booklist, starred review
“Heller excels at the complex characterization required to engage readers, resulting in a book that’s truly impossible to put down. The myriad anxieties her characters feel—fear for their children, their reputation, their community—are entirely relatable...With such a wonderful buildup and a truly surprising finish, The Neighbor’s Secret is a delight to read."
—BookPage, starred review
“Entertaining psychological thriller…Readers will relate to these appealing women, who toss off one-liners even as they wrestle with such issues as teen substance abuse, bullying, and workaholic spouses. This is perfect for Liane Moriarty fans—as well as potential book club catnip.”
—Publishers Weekly
“Unfolding as delicately and suspensefully as the most finely crafted puzzle box, The Neighbor’s Secret is chock-full of mysteries that are elegantly solved as the narrative unravels…L. Alison Heller has definitely knocked it out of the park.”
—Criminal Element
“Addictive, suspenseful and masterfully written, The Neighbor’s Secret kept me glued to the page. This searing portrait of the suburbs, where the perfect surface conceals deadly secrets, will delight fans of Big Little Lies.” —Michele Campbell, bestselling author of The Wife Who Knew Too Much
“I love it when a thriller hits me in the funny bone, and The Neighbor’s Secret did just that. Smart and darkly comedic, with nuanced characters delivering whip-smart dialogue, this story will have you grinning as you race through the pages. An absorbing tale that delivers some juicy surprises.” —Kimberly Belle, bestselling author of Dear Wife and Stranger in the Lake
“The Neighbor’s Secret is the rare thriller that actually leaves you feeling better about humanity. I had zero self-control when it came to inhaling chapters to uncover each delicious new secret. Buoyant and big-hearted, this will be an easy book to recommend to everyone I know—an absolute crowd pleaser!” —Chandler Baker, bestselling author of The Husbands
“Like the characters that populate it, The Neighbor’s Secret is funny and engaging on the surface, but full of deliciously dark surprises underneath. Fans of Liane Moriarty just might read it all in one day — I certainly did.” —Laura Hankin, author of A Special Place for Women
“An enjoyable satire on book clubs...The characters are well-defined with their flaws and foibles…An entertaining look at the question of how far some people will go to protect their children – and their secrets.”
—Deadly Pleasures Magazine
“A book club becomes a lifeline for a group of women dealing with betrayal, gossip and secrets in this poignant and often amusing thriller.”
—Shelf Awareness
“The Cottonwood Book Club is where the neighbors go to gossip, drink, and enjoy twisty thrillers, safe in the knowledge that nothing bad could ever happen in their own neighborhood. But when acts of vandalism start to target the members of the book club, everyone starts taking a look at their own secrets.”
—The New York Post, This Week's Best New Books
“Heller is a master chef who blends her ingredients smoothly… The Neighbor’s Secret has all the elements of an HBO or Hulu series—wealthy suburb, female friendships, troubled children, secret pasts, and murder. Fingers crossed that the book will get picked up soon.”
—Chick Lit Central
"How well do you know your neighbors? That question has been asked time and time again in the book world, but Heller’s latest offers something a bit more imaginative, with dramatic plot twists and smart characters who come to life when lies and cover-ups disrupt the lives of a suburban book club.”
—Parade
2021-08-18
Mystery and skulduggery in an upscale Colorado subdivision.
A vandal is disrupting the peaceful facade of Cottonwood Estates, spray-painting graffiti, bashing carved pumpkins, and breaking a window in a private home. This miscreant is an emblem of what lies beneath this family-friendly community—secrets, lies, betrayals, and worse. The story focuses on three members of the Cottonwood Book Club: Annie Perley, who has a complicated past and a teenage daughter suddenly acting strangely; Jen Pagano, who’s put her career on hold to deal with her violence-prone 13-year-old son; and Lena Meeker, a new book-club recruit who’s older, wealthier, and lonelier than the others. Something terrible happened in Cottonwood 15 years ago, and Lena was directly involved (exactly how, we don’t know). Author Heller interrupts the present-day narrative with occasional flashbacks that provide clues about who did what to whom. Overall, the novel is intended as frothy fun with serious undertones. There are some clever digs at suburbia—for example, Annie’s worried musings about her kids: “Should Hank and Laurel be composing oboe concertos? Why haven’t they written cookbooks for charity?” And the book club’s selections are amusingly eclectic, from Lolita to something called The Spicy Hot Marriage. As for drama, Jen’s anguish over son Abe—who may or may not be the vandal—seems authentic. But much of the book is overly familiar. The characters are hard to differentiate at first, and it's hard to care about them. The plot twists often seem arbitrary, if not unbelievable. Too many of the characters “feel a bitter taste in their throat”—or words to that effect—in tense moments. And the big reveals at the end may leave readers a bit puzzled.
Not as entertaining or absorbing as it means to be.
