Unlike many of his country contemporaries in the 2020s,
Zach Bryan embraces naked pretension. The opening track of
The Great American Bar Scene bears a parenthetical distinguishing it as a "poem" which, in all practical purposes, means
Bryan clearly enunciates every one of its lines in a deliberate recitation. None of the other 18 songs on
The Great American Bar Scene are explicitly stamped as a poem, but they are poetic, plump with purple imagery and plaintive rhymes. Three studio albums into his major-label career -- a discography that also includes indie releases, non-LP singles, EPs, duets, and live albums --
Bryan's emphasis on the lyrics is now familiar. He makes some effort to open up his production to faint echoes of heartland rock and occasionally shoring up his meditations with a suggestion of a backbeat, a shifting in arrangements that help gives
The Great American Bar Scene a more discernable shape than
American Heartbreak or
Zach Bryan. Cameos from a pair of rock superstars --
John Mayer sculpts "Better Days,"
Bruce Springsteen haunts the corridors of "Sandpaper" -- help pull
Bryan's aspirations into focus. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine