Alice in Shandehland: Scandal and Scorn in the Edelson/Horwitz Murder Case

by Monda Halpern

Overview

By 1931, Ben and Alice Edelson had been married for two decades and had seven children, but for years Alice had been having an affair with the married Jack Horwitz. On the night of 24 November, Ben, Alice, and Jack met at Edelson Jewellers to "settle the thing." Words flew, a brawl erupted, and Jack was shot and killed. The tragedy marked the start of a sensational legal case that captured Ottawa headlines, with the prominent jeweller facing the gallows. Through a detailed examination of newspaper coverage, interviews with family and community members, and evocative archival photographs, Monda Halpern's Alice in Shandehland reconstructs a long-silenced murder case in Depression-era Canada. Halpern contends that despite his crime, Ben Edelson was the object of far less contempt than his adulterous wife whose shandeh - Yiddish for shame or disgrace - seemed indefensible. While Alice endured the censure of both the Jewish community and the courtroom, Ben’s middle-class respectability and the betrayal he suffered earned him favoured standing and, ultimately, legal exoneration. Revealing the tensions around ethnicity, sexuality, gender, and class, Alice in Shandehland explores the divergent reputations of Ben and Alice Edelson within a growing but insular and tenuous Jewish community, and within a dominant culture that embraced male success and valour during the emasculating 1930s.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780773583405
Publisher:	McGill-Queens University Press
Publication date:	06/15/2015
Series:	McGill-Queen's Studies in Ethnic History , #2
Sold by:	Barnes & Noble
Format:	eBook
File size:	4 MB

About the Author

Monda Halpern is associate professor of history at the University of Western Ontario and the author of And on That Farm He Had a Wife: Ontario Farm Women and Feminism, 1900–1970.

Table of Contents

Illustrations xv

Acknowledgments xi

Introduction 3

1 "This terrible drama of humanity": An Affair, a Shooting, a Death, an Arrest 13

2 "A prominent Ottawa jeweller" and "the jeweller's comely young wife": The Rise of the Edelsons 37

3 "Startling evidence … of a sensational character": The, Inquest, and Respectability Challenged 53

4 "Her life was pure impulse without control": Trial by Jewry, Community Anxiety, and the Spurning of Alice 91

5 "In a court of British justice, sympathy has no place": Trial by Jury, Respectability and Honour, and the Acquittal of Ben 115

6 "A sudden silence fell": The Legacy of the Case 151

Conclusion 172

A Note on Sources 177

Notes 183

Bibliography 255

Index 269

Editorial Reviews

Based on meticulous research, Alice in Shandehland is a superbly-written and illuminating portrait of Jewish life in Ottawa and the struggles toward a middle-class respectability.” Amanda Glasbeek, York University


“A well-written and often surprising investigation of a once-prominent scandal and the aftermath.” Booklist


“Halpern spent years tracking down a story that no one wanted to talk about. Pouring over newspaper accounts of the sensational three day trial, interviewing surviving family members — many reluctant to talk, searching through archives and walking the str

From the Publisher