Summing Up: The Science of Reviewing Research

by Richard J. Light, David B. Pillemer

Overview

How can a scientist or policy analyst summarize and evaluate what is already known about a particular topic? This book offers practical guidance.

The amount and diversity of information generated by academic and policy researchers in the contemporary world is staggering. How is an investigator to cope with the tens or even hundreds of studies on a particular problem? How can conflicting findings be reconciled? Richard Light and David Pillemer have developed both general guidelines and step-by-step procedures that can be used to synthesize existing data. They show how to apply quantitative methods, including the newest statistical procedures and simple graphical displays, to evaluate a mass of studies and combine separate data sets. At the same time, they insist on the value of qualitative information, of asking the right questions, and of considering the context in which research is conducted. The authors use exemplary reviews in education, psychology, health, and the policy sciences to illustrate their suggestions.

Written in nontechnical language and addressed to the beginning researcher as well as to the practicing professional, Summing Up will set a new standard for valid research reviews and is likely to become a methodological classic.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780674854314
Publisher:	Harvard University Press
Publication date:	10/15/1984
Pages:	212
Product dimensions:	6.50(w) x 9.50(h) x 0.50(d)

About the Author

Richard J. Light is Professor in the Graduate School of Education and the John F. Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University.

David B. Pillemer is Professor of Psychology at Wellesley College.

Table of Contents

1. Introduction

2. Organizing a Reviewing Strategy

3. Quantitative Procedures

4. Numbers and Narrative: The Division of Labor

5. What We Have Learned

6. A Checklist for Evaluating Reviews

Reference

Index

What People are Saying About This

Astute and wonderfully lucid, Summing Up will be a treasure for inexperienced researchers and contains messages for many experienced ones as well. The book goes beyond techniques for boiling down multiple studies to a single summary "effect size" showing how qualitative information from the original studies improves interpretation.

Thomas D. Cook

Light and Pillemer show an exemplary, nondoctrinaire catholic that I much admire, as well as a willingness to get deep into their, our, and others' experiences as reviewers in order to learn the lessons these experiences teach. Their book is therefore more comprehensive and practical than most books on methods.
— Thomas D. Cook, Northwestern University

Julian C. Stanley

A much-needed book--interesting, readable, attractively presented, practical.
— Julian C. Stanley, The Johns Hopkins University

Frederick Mosteller

An engaging readable, and well-illustrated account of the current art of combining information from several studies.
— Frederick Mosteller, Harvard University

Lee J. Cronbach

Astute and wonderfully lucid, Summing Up will be a treasure for inexperienced researchers and contains messages for many experienced ones as well. The book goes beyond techniques for boiling down multiple studies to a single summary "effect size" showing how qualitative information from the original studies improves interpretation.
— Lee J. Cronbach, Stanford University

Editorial Reviews

Astute and wonderfully lucid, Summing Up will be a treasure for inexperienced researchers and contains messages for many experienced ones as well. The book goes beyond techniques for boiling down multiple studies to a single summary ‘effect size’ showing how qualitative information from the original studies improves interpretation.

Lee J. Cronbach

An engaging readable, and well-illustrated account of the current art of combining information from several studies.

Frederick Mosteller

A much-needed book—interesting, readable, attractively presented, practical.

Julian C. Stanley

Light and Pillemer show an exemplary, nondoctrinaire catholicism that I much admire, as well as a willingness to get deep into their, our, and others’ experiences as reviewers in order to learn the lessons these experiences teach. Their book is therefore more comprehensive and practical than most books on methods.

Thomas D. Cook