Arizona Grand Canyon Reader Award
nominee 2021
Pennsylvania Young Reader's Choice Award
nominee 2021, Grades 6-8
Compass Book Ratings
"This is the perfect read for the middle grader who is struggling to figure his/her place out in the social department of life. The book does a really good job of helping one to see that everyone’s lives are not as perfect as they may appear on the outside. It also illustrates that the perspective you choose to see people may be just that – your perspective and there may be an alternate perspective to the situation. The take away point of the book is: “ … a person could be different, look different, have struggles, make mistakes, and still have so much to offer.”
Foreword Reviews
"Pulls off the seemingly impossible; it is an empathy-building novel with a message that's fun to read. Flint is a sharply observant narrator. He is self-deprecatingly humorous rather than self-pitying, and he easily embodies the secret freakishness that many teens feel. Despite the book's dual medical issues, this is not a "sick kid" book...it sends a strong message about making the most of what you have. The writing is perfectly tuned, trusting its audience enough not to hammer at its main themes. With its sophisticated themes and thoroughly likable main character, Squint takes on a lot and delivers beyond expectations."
Missouri Mark Twain Award
2020-2021 Nominee in grades 4-6 category
Ohio Buckeye Children's Book Award
2019 nominee for grades 3-5
School Library Journal
10/01/2018
Gr 5–7—Sixth grader Flint (aka Squint) is feverishly trying to finish making his comic book in order to enter it in the "Find a Comic Star" contest. Due to a genetic eye disease, keratoconus, he wears thick glasses and has double, sometimes triple or quadruple, vision. Flint, who lives with his grandparents, spends most of his time alone working on his comic book. When McKell, a new girl at school and part of the popular group, sits with him at lunch, he's wary at first, but she seems genuine. She invites him to take a hike after school and talks about her brother Danny's YouTube videos where he posts challenges asking people to push themselves and try new things. After Flint tears his cornea and has surgery, he sees better than he has in years, a cause for celebration until he sees his comic more clearly and realizes that it isn't as good as he thought. He quits drawing, but after Danny dies of heart disease, a consequence of having progeria, a disease where you prematurely age, he works with McKell to fulfill Danny's last challenge, a chance for them both to achieve their dreams. Flint and McKell are sympathetic protagonists with relatable concerns and issues. The challenges of middle school are leavened with humor through the "Middle School Rules" sprinkled throughout the story. The use of the comic book as a metaphor for Flint's experiences would have been more impactful if it had been shown as the actual comic rather than written as text. This small flaw aside, this is a moving story about friendship, loss, and seeing life from other people's point of view. VERDICT Recommended for any library serving middle grade readers.—Kefira Phillipe, Nichols Middle School, Evanston, IL
NOVEMBER 2018 - AudioFile
Narrator Kirby Heyborne nimbly conveys a range of emotions as he narrates the story of 13-year-old Squint. Heyborne tenderly portrays awkward but impassioned Squint, with his impossibly thick glasses and nerdy comic book obsession. Having withdrawn from school life, Squint finds a surprising friend in McKell, a troubled new girl who challenges him to experiment, explore, and go adventuring. Heyborne communicates Squint’s complex inner life, from his initial introspection to the implacable confidence that he wields at the story’s close. Heyborne’s exquisite rendering of Squint’s sorrow when faced with unimaginable loss is affecting and authentic. Listeners will be captivated by this unlikely hero and will cheer him on as he boldly faces his deepest fears and inspires forgiveness and bravery in those around him. S.A.H. Winner of AudioFile Earphones Award © AudioFile 2018, Portland, Maine
Kirkus Reviews
2018-07-24
Thirteen-year-old Flint, aka "Squint," is determined to finish his comic book in time to enter it in a contest—and before he loses so much more of his eyesight that he can no longer see to draw.
Squint has a degenerative corneal disease that has left him with thick glasses that do little to correct his vision but make him a magnet for bullying by popular kids. When popular McKell reaches out to him, his first reaction is to protect himself by rejecting her. But then he discovers that she's dealing with plenty herself; her older brother, Danny, has progeria, a rare disease that's killing him. Danny has a popular YouTube channel in which he suggests challenges or activities designed to bring people together. After his death, the videos keep coming, serving, poignantly, to draw McKell and Squint closer as he gradually emerges from his self-imposed isolation. Squint's comic-book tale accompanies and parallels his first-person narration, crafting a fantasy world where Squint can be the superhero of his dreams. But it's the drawing of the comics that presents the greatest challenge to him with his poor vision. The book assumes a white default, with Squint assumed white and biracial McKell half-Filipina and presumably half-white. That Squint's drawings are not included seems like a major missed opportunity to broaden this sometimes-maudlin tale of loss and redemption.
In spite of its predictability, likely to find an appreciative audience among young teens. (Fiction. 11-14)
