"His frank observations about the personalities of these actors, along with their recollections of silent filmmaking, creates a kind of meta-portrait of celebrity itself its grandeur and its foolishness." American Cinematographer
"Slide's approach, focusing on talented and vibrant personalities, differentiates this work from others chronicling the silent film era." American Reference Book Annual
"Anthony Slide is an authority on silent films." Beverly Hills Courier
"The grand master of silent film scholarship." Choice
"Slide sets the standard for film research that other writers can study and emulate." Daily Variety
"One writer who possesses the special insight necessary to any intelligent discussion of the silent movie is Slide." Films in Review
"A fascinating, entertaining, and occasionally poignant work that invites the reader into the fabulous work of art, industry, and experimentation that was Hollywood in the 1910s and 1920s." Library Journal
"Our preeminent historian of the silent film." Lillian Gish
"Slide profiles 100 silent film stars 57 of whom he knew personally including such well-known names as Mary Astor, Lillian Gish, and Harold Lloyd." Los Angeles Times
"Most cinemabilia collectors concentrate on films and personalities from the 1930's on, but there are other, more serious students of cinema interested in the earlier silent period, and they will welcome film historian Anthony Slide's Silent Players." Massillon (OH) Independent, Hartford (CT) Courant
"Slide uses the lives of 100 stars to capture some of the diverse and creative charm of the period before sound was introduced to movies." Register of the Kentucky Historical Society
"Immensely entertaining." Sight & Sound
"If you love learning about the movies, you'll truly enjoy a classic in its own right." WTBF Radio