Relative Truth

by Manuel Garcïa-Carpintero, Max Kolbel

Overview

The truth of an utterance depends on various factors. Usually these factors are assumed to be: the meaning of the sentence uttered, the context in which the utterance was made, and the way things are in the world. Recently, however, a number of cases have been discussed where there seems to be reason to think that the truth of an utterance is not yet fully determined by these three factors, and that truth must therefore depend on a further factor. The most prominent examples include utterances about values, utterances attributing knowledge, utterances that state that something is probable or epistemically possible, and utterances about the contingent future. In these cases, some have argued, the standard picture needs to be modified to admit extra truth-determining factors, and there is further controversy about the exact role of any such extra factors.

With contributions from some of the key figures in the contemporary debate on relativism this book is about a topic that is the focus of much traditional and current interest: whether truth is relative to standards of taste, values, or subjective informational states. It is an issue in the philosophy of language, but one with important connections to other areas of philosophy, such as meta-ethics, metaphysics, and epistemology.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780199234950
Publisher:	Oxford University Press
Publication date:	10/15/2008
Pages:	326
Product dimensions:	6.40(w) x 9.30(h) x 1.10(d)

About the Author

Max Kölbel received his PhD from King's College London in 1997. He has taught philosophy at UNAM in México City, at Swansea, Cambridge, and since 2001 at the University of Birmingham. From 2008, he will be ICREA Research Professor at the University of Barcelona.

Manuel García-Carpintero received his PhD from the University of Barcelona in 1988 and has taught in the department of Lògica, Història i Filosofia there since 1984.

Table of Contents

Preface1. Introduction: "Motivations for Relativism", Max KölbelI: RELATIVISM ELABORATED2. Moderate Relativism, François Recanati3. Semantic Relativism and the Logic of Indexicals, Stefano Predelli and Isidora Stojanovic4. Truth in the Garden of Forking Paths, John MacFarlane5. Margins for Error in Context, Denis Bonnay and Paul Egré6. Relativism, Vagueness and What Is Said, Manuel García-CarpinteroII: THE METAPHYISCAL SIGNIFICANCE OF RELATIVISM7. Relativism about Truth Itself: Haphazard Thoughts about the Very Idea, Crispin Wright8. Three Forms of Truth-Relativism, Iris EinheuserIII: OBJECTIONS TO RELATIVISM9. Assertion, Belief and Disagreement, Sebastiano Moruzzi10. Frege, Relativism and Faultless Disagreement, Sven Rosenkranz11. Epistemic Modals and Correct Disagreement, Richard DietzIV: ALTERNATIVES TO RELATIVISM12. Content Relativism, Herman Cappelen13. Faultless or Disagreement, Andrea Iacona14. Presuppositions of Commonality: an Indexical Relativist Account of Disagreement, Dan Lopez de Sa