Plato's Second Republic: An Essay on the Laws

Plato's Second Republic: An Essay on the Laws

by André Laks
Plato's Second Republic: An Essay on the Laws

Plato's Second Republic: An Essay on the Laws

by André Laks

Hardcover

$35.00 
  • SHIP THIS ITEM
    Qualifies for Free Shipping
  • PICK UP IN STORE
    Check Availability at Nearby Stores

Related collections and offers


Overview

An argument for why Plato’s Laws can be considered his most important political dialogue

In Plato's Second Republic, André Laks argues that the Laws, Plato’s last and longest dialogue, is also his most important political work, surpassing the Republic in historical relevance. Laks offers a thorough reappraisal of this less renowned text, and examines how it provides a critical foundation for the principles of lawmaking. In doing so, he makes clear the tremendous impact the Laws had not only on political philosophy, but also on modern political history.

Laks shows how the four central ideas in the Laws—the corruptibility of unchecked power, the rule of law, a “middle” constitution, and the political necessity of legislative preambles—are articulated within an intricate and masterful literary architecture. He reveals how the work develops a theological conception of law anchored in political ideas about a god, divine reason, that is the measure of political order. Laks’s reading opens a complex analysis of the relationships between rulers and citizens; their roles in a political system; the power of reason and persuasion, as opposed to force, in commanding obedience; and the place of freedom.

Plato's Second Republic presents a sophisticated reevaluation of a philosophical work that has exerted an enormous if often hidden influence even into the present day.


Product Details

ISBN-13: 9780691233130
Publisher: Princeton University Press
Publication date: 11/29/2022
Pages: 296
Product dimensions: 6.20(w) x 9.30(h) x 1.10(d)

About the Author

André Laks is professor emeritus of ancient philosophy at the Paris-Sorbonne University and teaches at the Panamerican University in Mexico City. He is the coeditor of the Loeb Classical Library’s nine-volume Early Greek Philosophy.

Table of Contents

Introduction 1

Editorial Note 11

1 The Form of the Laws: An Overview 13

Late Style 13

From Encounter to Synthesis 14

The Walk 16

The First Focal Point: The Great Divide 17

The First Theologico-Political Treatise 17

Law between Form and Content 19

Two Critical Prologues (Books 1 to 3) 20

Slow Beginnings (Books 4 and 5) 24

The Second Focal Point: The Retreat 26

Specifying the Laws 26

The Centrality of the General Preamble 28

Constitution and Laws (Books 6 to 12) 28

A Meta-Constitutional Law 30

A Last Complication 30

The Bare Bones of the Laws 31

2 Paradigms and Utopias 32

From the Laws to the Republic 32

A Republic in Two Acts and an Epilogue 33

From Best to Possible 35

Approximating Approximation 38

From lexis to praxis 40

The Philosopher as Craftsman 41

Contradictory Signals 43

The Possibility of the Wise Ruler 45

The Moot Question of Utopia 50

3 Paradigm and Retreats 53

The Duplication of the Paradigm 53

Completion and Revision 55

A Parallel with the Timaeus 56

Types of Distancing 58

What Is the Second City Second To? 60

A Note on the Titles Republic and Laws 62

4 What Is Human? 64

A City for Human Beings 64

Plato's Anthropology 65

A Wonderful Puppet 67

The Fragility of Choral Dance 69

Aspects of the Human Wonder 71

5 The Multiplication of Goals 74

Aims and Targets 74

Freedom Comes In 77

Sparta, Ancient Persia, Ancient Athens 80

6 Mixtures, Blends, and Other Metamorphoses 86

Middle and Mean 86

Balance 88

Two Equalities 90

Kinds of Freedom 96

Voluntary Servitude to the Law 99

Statutory Freedom and Its Obligation 102

7 Construing the Preambles 107

The Violence of the Law 107

Correcting the Past 110

Poet and Lawgiver on 'Measure' 110

The Medical Analogy, First Version 113

An Example: Marriage 118

Preamble vs. Law 119

The Medical Analogy, Second Version 120

8 A Rhetoric in the Making 124

Three Scales 124

Two Typologies 125

Appealing to Reflection (On Marrying) 128

Praise and Blame (On Hunting) 130

From Argument to Incantation (On the Choice of a Spouse) 131

The Reintroduction of Threat 133

9 Two Exceptional Preambles 136

Socrates Implemented 136

The Theological Foundation of the Law 142

A Structural Paradox 145

10 Plato's Best Tragedy 149

In Retrospect 154

Appendix A On the Status of the Statesman 159

Appendix B On a Supposed Evolution of Plato's Psychology 169

Appendix C Aristotle and Posidonius on Plato's Preambles 177

Notes 181

Bibliography 235

Index Locorum 253

General Index 269

What People are Saying About This

From the Publisher

“Laks is the leading expert on Plato’s Laws and his magisterial knowledge of the Greek corpus and Greek grammar is infused throughout this book. This is a landmark in the scholarly literature on Plato.”—Melissa Lane, Princeton University

“This is one of the most important books on Plato published in the last fifty years or more. Laks is one of the best, subtlest readers of Plato we have and Beyond the Republic is a necessary corrective, whether for general readers, classicists, historians of philosophy, or indeed—and especially—political philosophers.”—Christopher Rowe, Durham University

From the B&N Reads Blog

Customer Reviews