Overdiagnosis in Psychiatry: How Modern Psychiatry Lost Its Way While Creating a Diagnosis for Almost All of Life's Misfortunes

by Joel Paris

Overview

As one of the few books to thoroughly examine the critical problem of over-diagnosis in psychiatry today, Dr. Joel Paris - author of The Intelligent Clinician's Guide to the DSM-5RG - shows how over-diagnosis leads to over-treatment in Overdiagnosis in Psychiatry: How Modern Psychiatry Lost Its Way While Creating a Diagnosis for Almost All of Life's Misfortune. Leaving no stone unturned, Dr. Paris considers the complications of the DSM-5 system with particular reference to major depression, bipolar disorder, PTSD and attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder. While each of these conditions have given rise to diagnostic fads and epidemics, the classification of mental disorders remains provisional without any biomarkers for mental disorders. Because of this, Dr. Paris makes the case for the importance of conservative diagnoses, recognizing that normal variants are not necessarily disorders.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780199350667
Publisher:	Oxford University Press
Publication date:	04/15/2015
Sold by:	Barnes & Noble
Format:	eBook
Pages:	272
File size:	425 KB

About the Author

Joel Paris was born in New York City, but has spent most of his life in Canada. Dr. Paris' research interest is in borderline personality disorder. Dr. Paris has 193 peer-reviewed articles, and is the author of 17 books and 40 book chapters. Dr. Paris is an educator who has has won awards for his teaching.

Table of Contents

Preface
Acknowledgments
Introduction
Part I. Background
1. Diagnosis in Psychiatry
2. The DSM and Its Discontents
3. Overdiagnosis and Over-Treatment
4. Science, Philosophy, and Diagnosis
Part II. Categories Most Likely to Be Overdiagnosed
5. How Major Is Major Depression?
6. Bipolar Disorders
7. Post-traumatic Stress Disorder
8. Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder
9. Personality and Personality Disorder
10. Other Disorders in Which Overdiagnosis Is a Risk
PART III: CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS
11. The Rise of Aggressive Psychopharmacology
12. Transdiagnostic Approaches
Part IV. Diagnosis and Normality
13. How Do We Know What Is Normal?
14. Where Do We Go From Here?
References
Index

Editorial Reviews

Reviewer: Brett C. Plyler, M.D.(Northwestern Memorial Hospital)
Description: This is the author's polemic against normality becoming psychopathology and the overprescription of psychiatric medications and diagnoses.
Purpose: The author's purpose is to address the problem of overdiagnosis in psychiatry.
Audience: The book is written for mental health practitioners, patients, and the lay public interested in psychiatry, according to the author.
Features: The book begins with the author's prologue, which reveals the motivation behind the title and the book. The first section is background concerning the DSM and important chapters on why overdiagnosis happens in medicine in general and in psychiatry specifically. The second portion of the book examines five distinct psychiatric diagnoses and how/why they have become overdiagnosed. Each chapter looks at the progression from the DSM III until now, as well as discussing the role of the pharmaceutical industry. The third and final section focuses on normality and how we determine what is and what is not normal. The last chapter is the expected "Where do we go from here?" and includes the author's thoughts on how to get psychiatry back on track.
Assessment: I am always interested in reading what Dr. Paris has to say and this book is no exception. I agree with his fears of overdiagnosis/prescribing by "biologically minded" psychiatrists who do not take the time to consider the psychosocial aspects of patient distress, although I may not be as strident on the subject as he is. His place in the history of the DSM gives him a unique perspective on how this occurred, and I think these are the most interesting parts of the book. He delineates how psychiatry as a field wanted to be "real" medicine (leading to overdiagnosis) and how the advent of psychopharmacological advances led to the overprescription problem. The individual chapters on specific diagnoses, such as major depression, are excellent, case-in-point examples that support his argument. Dr. Paris touts a return to diagnostic validity, scientific rigor, and a better understanding of the individual patient — wonderful goals but difficult to achieve. I would highly recommend this book for anyone interested in psychiatry and, in particular, concerned about the pathologizing of normality.

Doody's Review Service

"Dr. Paris is a psychiatrist who knows his onions and so can make you weep. He weeps at the failure to recognize strengths in people rather than weaknesses, and after reading his book we should all gain from one of its key sentences 'it would probably be better to define mental health, not as happiness, but as resilience in the face of adversity'." - Peter Tyrer, Professor of Community Psychiatry, Centre for Mental Health, Imperial College, London

"Most discussions of diagnosis focus on problems with missed diagnoses or misdiagnosis. Dr. Paris does the field a great favor by focusing on the problem of overdiagnosis, and showing how it is as great a problem as underdiagnosis." - Mark Zimmerman, Professor of Psychiatry and Human Behavior, Brown Medical School, Providence, RI

"Too much medicine can be bad for your health- over-diagnosis and over-treatment are now serious public health problems. Dr Paris has provided an important pebble in the David vs Goliath battle to contain the medical-industrial complex." - Allen Frances, Professor Emeritus and former Chair Duke University and author of Saving Normal

"Dr. Joel Paris has written a wonderfully provocative book that will irritate some readers and delight others. With opinions based on his many years working in the trenches, Dr. Paris points out the problems of overdiagnosis, misdiagnose, and diagnostic epidemics that have been fueled in part by overenthusiasm for the DSM. Written in an accessible style, this book is bound to become a classic in the field." - Donald W. Black, MD, Professor, Department of Psychiatry, University of Iowa Roy J. and Lucille A. Carver College of Medicine, Iowa City, IA

"I would highly recommend this book for anyone interested in psychiatry and, in particular, concerned about the pathologizing of normality. " — Brett C. Plyler, M.D., Doody's

From the Publisher