Disc 1
- At the Beginning
- "Hi, I'm Lynn Ahrens & I'm Stephen Flaherty..."
- Journey to the Past
- Waiting for Life
- Mama Will Provide
- Rain
- "I Had the Great Fortune..."
- Love Who You Love
- The Cuddles Mary Gave
- "Lynn Asked Me to Let You Know..."
- Streets of Dublin
- "Good Evening! And Introducing in His Acting Debut..."
- Rita's Confession
- "And Now, Because Stephen's Acting Chops..."
- Fancy Meeting You Here
- "I Feel Like My Life is Flashing Before My Eyes Here..."
- Ballerina
- Dancing Still
- "I Have a Lyric Sheet in My Hand..."
- Raining [Hamburg Version]
- Raining
- Speaking French
- Times Like This
- The Show Biz
Disc 2
- Green Eggs and Ham
- Alone in the Universe
- Solla Sollew
- "This Was the First Show That Lynn and Steve Wrote Together..."
- Never Really Knew the Guy
- "And So, in the Second Song From 'Bedazzled'..."
- Close (But No Cigar)
- White Milk and Red Blood
- Larger Than Life
- "And Now Here's Another Song..."
- Funny/The Duck Joke
- "Hi, Everybody..."
- Something Beautiful
- Sarah Brown Eyes
- The Night That Goldman Spoke at Union Square
- Something of My Own
- Wheels of a Dream
- "It's Always Exciting When You Find the First Notes..."
- Ragtime [Piano Solo]
- Make Them Hear You
- Goodbye, My Love/Back to Before
- "The Song That Lynn and Stephen..."
- I Was Here
- Nice/How Lucky We Are