Negative Cat

by Sophie Blackall, Sophie Blackall (Illustrator)

Overview

Two-time Caldecott winner Sophie Blackall spins a winning tale about Max, a feline whose behavior doesn't win any raves, except from the boy who believes in him and finds a way to turn a negative into a positive.

When a boy is FINALLY allowed to get a cat, he has no doubts about which one to bring home from the shelter. But Max the cat isn’t quite what the family expected. He shuns the toy mouse, couldn’t care less about the hand-knitted sweater, and spends most of his time facing the wall. One by one, the family gives up on Max, but the boy loves his negative cat so much, he’ll do anything to keep him. Even the thing he dreads most: practicing his reading. Which, as it turns out, makes everything positive!

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780399257193
Publisher:	Penguin Young Readers Group
Publication date:	08/31/2021
Pages:	32
Sales rank:	121,102
Product dimensions:	8.60(w) x 11.00(h) x 0.50(d)
Age Range:	4 - 8 Years

About the Author

Sophie Blackall has illustrated more than thirty books, including the New York Times Best Illustrated Children's Books Big Red Lollipop and The Baby Tree, which she also wrote.  Born in Australia, Sophie lives in Brooklyn with her children, Olive and Edward.Sophie Blackall has illustrated more than thirty books, including Finding Winnie, for which she won the Caldecott medal, and the New York Times Best Illustrated books Big Red Lollipop and The Baby Tree, which she also wrote.  Born in Australia, Sophie lives in Brooklyn with her children Olive and Edward.

Editorial Reviews

06/14/2021

“Ugh! I’m not so great at reading!” confesses the cat enthusiast who narrates this story by Caldecott Medalist Blackall (If You Come to Earth). Having persuaded their family to adopt a feline “on Day 427 of asking for a cat,” the brown-skinned child promises to care for the animal and read for 20 minutes each day as part of the deal. But “words only make sense when I read them out loud slowly,” and Maximilian August Xavier, the orange-striped cat from the shelter, proves utterly devoid of charm—a negative cat. While classmates’ felines perform all manner of tricks, Max “stares at the wall” and “leaves hairballs on the rug, his tail in the butter, and poop in the vestibule.” The family complains, and a consultation with a shelter worker is arranged. In a sweetly suspenseful sequence, the narrator discovers that reading—“slowly. Out loud. The only way I know how”—is the key to Max’s heart. In dusty blues and greens, oranges and pinks, digital artwork “superimposed on the reverse side of vintage wallpaper” dials in on the interracial family’s dynamics and facial expressions. (Scorn demonstrated by the child’s older sibling is particularly vivid: “We should’ve gotten a dog,” they mutter, busy with nail polish.) Max is, of course, adorable, and the discovery that reading to animals can benefit both the children who read and the animals who listen is the story’s hidden treasure. Ages 4–8. Agent: Marietta Zacker, Gallt & Zacker Literary. (Aug.)

Publishers Weekly

Humorous, heartwarming.” —People Magazine

“A must-read for anyone that loves cats, books, and reading.” —Brightly

“[An] adorable and sweet picture book.” —Book Riot

“Sometimes things aren’t what they seem at first. . . . Understated text brings a dry sense of humor to the child’s plight. . . . An author’s note describes the true event on which this story is based and offers readers ideas on how they can go read to animals. A humorous tale in which everyone gets what they want—even a negative cat!” —Kirkus Reviews

“Max is, of course, adorable, and the discovery that reading to animals can benefit both the children who read and the animals who listen is the story’s hidden treasure.” —Publishers Weekly

“[Blackall’s] illustrations, ‘created digitally and superimposed on the reverse side of vintage wallpaper salvaged from a falling-down house,’ have a charmingly old-school feel, deepened by the dull-toned color palette and design choices. A touching story that adds depth to the usual sweet humor of cat books.” —Booklist

"A boy's new pet starts out as a problem and becomes the solution to another problem in Sophie Blackall's droll and commiserative picture book." —Shelf Awareness

"This entertaining tale is a tribute to animal rescue shelters—and to literacy. . . . The many eye-catching details in Blackall’s fine-lined illustrations invite close inspection. . . . Blackall expertly captures body language and extracts a lot of humor from the surly cat, especially when comparing him to the animated pet-owner: we see the child attempt to connect (“I tell him all my best jokes. He doesn’t even smile”); the cat is shown with his back to readers, staring at the wall or rudely putting his tail in a stick of butter. As a result, it’s immensely rewarding to see the connection that occurs when the boy starts to read (and to enjoy it!) and Max crawls closer to cuddle. A positive and satisfying tale." —Horn Book

"This readaloud is an excellent depiction of the drawbacks of cat ownership, from cleaning up unwanted messes to only receiving affection when it’s desired by the feline party, but its message that cats are still worth keeping around (and make particularly good reading buddies) is both sweet and helpful to would-be cat owners with certain expectations. The digital art has a vintage look." —The Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books

From the Publisher

2021-06-16
Sometimes things aren’t what they seem at first.

A child with brown skin has been asking for a cat for 427 days! His family finally says yes if he agrees to certain conditions, including reading every day. Uh-oh; reading is not this child’s favorite activity. When the cat arrives, he reveals his true personality—gloomy. He won’t play, listen to jokes, or fetch. What’s worse, he leaves a hairball on the carpet, poops in the vestibule, and stares at the wall. What’s even worse is that the kid’s parents point out their unmet conditions. What to do? Well, as it turns out, what the cat likes best is what the child likes least—reading. An unusual cat for sure. Set against brown-paper backgrounds, the illustrations feature muted tones of orange, pink, blue, and green. Attention has been paid to portraying a variety of skin tones, from lighter beige to deeper brown, both within the protagonist’s interracial family and among his friends; however, the mother’s facial features lack consistency. Varying compositions in the spreads adds to the tension and resolution of the story. Understated text brings a dry sense of humor to the child’s plight even if the interactions between the child and the family seem at times a bit adversarial. An author’s note describes the true event on which this story is based and offers readers ideas on how they can go read to animals. (This book was reviewed digitally.)

A humorous tale in which everyone gets what they want—even a negative cat! (Picture book. 4-7)

Kirkus Reviews