The Four Tops' early years as a jazz-vocal group are generally glossed over in capsule histories. Long before they signed to
Motown -- nearly a full decade as a matter of fact -- they had been one of the popular Detroit jazz-vocal groups, earning the admiration of such luminaries as
Smokey Robinson and
Billy Eckstine, whom the group supported. After some persuasion, the group signed with
Motown on the condition that they could record jazz. Over the course of a year, they cut nearly two albums' worth of material, which boiled down to one album,
Breaking Through.
Berry Gordy pulled the record at the last minute, believing that it would have been a commercial failure.
Gordy's fears were not unfounded -- indeed, had the album that comprises
Breaking Through (1963-1964) been put out in 1964, it likely wouldn't have found much of an audience. Still,
Breaking Through is a strong record, firmly within its tradition and working well on those terms.
The Four Tops may not sound as distinctive singing jazz as they did with pop-soul, but they are convincing, as are the
Motown house band. Neither of them take many chances, however. The songs are primarily standards, plus four new songs that feel like standards, all given good generic arrangements. This may sound like a dismissal, but it isn't; it's hard to do this kind of music right, but the group most certainly does. And it's not just one member that shines; everyone gets to take a lead, and the results are uniformly strong. Even so,
Breaking Through appeals primarily to hardcore fans of the group, plus a handful of straight-ahead vocal-jazz aficionados. Reminiscent of a cross between
Eckstine and
the Four Freshmen, it's good stuff, but it's essentially a curiosity. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine
