Law and Legacy in Medical Jurisprudence: Essays in Honour of Graeme Laurie

by Edward S. Dove (Editor), Niamh Nic Shuibhne (Editor)

Overview

Graeme Laurie stepped down from the Chair in Medical Jurisprudence at the University of Edinburgh in 2019. This edited collection pays tribute to his extraordinary contributions to the field. Graeme often spoke about the importance of 'legacy' in academic work and forged a remarkable intellectual legacy of his own, notably through his work on genetic privacy, human tissue and information governance, and the regulatory salience of the concept of liminality. The essays in this volume animate the concept of legacy to analyse the study and practice of medical jurisprudence. In this light, legacy reveals characteristics of both benefit and burden, as both an encumbrance to and facilitator of the development of law, policy and regulation. The contributions reconcile the ideas of legacy and responsiveness and show that both dimensions are critical to achieve and sustain the health of medical jurisprudence itself as a dynamic, interdisciplinary and policy-engaged field of thinking.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9781108842433
Publisher:	Cambridge University Press
Publication date:	03/10/2022
Pages:	448
Product dimensions:	6.22(w) x 9.25(h) x 1.06(d)

About the Author

Edward S. Dove is Lecturer in Health Law and Regulation at the University of Edinburgh. His research examines confidentiality and data protection law as well as the regulatory work of research ethics committees and other bodies involved in health research. He is the author of Regulatory Stewardship of Health Research: Navigating Participant Protection and Research Promotion (2020).

Niamh Nic Shuibhne is Professor of European Union Law at the University of Edinburgh, and a joint editor of the Common Market Law Review. Her research examines questions of substantive EU law from a constitutional perspective. She recently completed a project on equal treatment for EU citizens, funded by a Leverhulme Trust Major Research Fellowship (2016–2019).

Table of Contents

Introduction: law and legacy in medical jurisprudence Edward Dove and Niamh Nic Shuibhne; 1. Doing medical law and ethics: putting interdisciplinarity to work Sharon Cowan, Emily Postan and Nayha Sethi; 2. A philosopher looks at 'law and medical ethics' Richard Ashcroft; 3. Thinking outside the box: Graeme Laurie's legacy to medical jurisprudence Roger Brownsword; 4. The public interest in health research: from concept to context Annie Sorbie; 5. Taking the legacy of liminality forward: reflections on Graeme Laurie's approach to liminality and its relevance for the ethics and governance of reproduction Catriona McMillan and Agomoni Ganguli-Mitra; 6. The once and future importance of impact Eric M. Meslin; 7. Breathing life into law: what it means to take an ethics+ approach to conceptualise law in research governance Calvin Ho and Justin Wong; 8. Biomedical research policy: back to the future? Bartha Maria Knoppers, Ruth Chadwick and Michael Beauvais; 9. The burden of history: how past scandals have shaped the future governance of human tissue and health data Nils Hoppe and José Miola; 10. Body parts and baleful stars? Margaret Brazier and Alexandra Mullock; 11. The legacy of the Warnock Report Emily Jackson; 12. Escape from the medically assisted suicide spiral Murray Earle; 13. Integrating the biological and the technological: time to move beyond law's binaries? Muireann Quigley and Laura Downey; 14. UK Biobank and the legal regulation of genetic research: preserving the legacy and empowering future regulation Jean McHale; 15. Overcoming the regulatory impasse in stem cell research and advanced therapy medicines in Argentina through shared norms and values Fabiana Arzuaga; 16. Institutions, interpretive communities and legacy in decision-making: a case study of patents, morality and biotechnological inventions Aisling McMahon; 17. Towards a new privacy: informed consent as an encumbrance to group interests? Mark Taylor and David Townend; 18. A tale of two legacies: drawing on humanist interpretations to animate the right to the benefits of science Shawn Harmon; Afterword – the great coronavirus pandemic: a pivotal moment for health law and ethics: an afterword in appreciation of Graeme Laurie's legacy to the field Lawrence Gostin.

Editorial Reviews

‘This magnificent collection of essays is a worthy tribute to one of the greats of medical law. It is a powerful reflection of the enormous contribution Graeme Laurie has made to the subject, that his work has inspired such an outstanding book.' Jonathan Herring, DM Wolfe-Clarendon Fellow in Law, Exeter College, University of Oxford

‘An outstanding collection of essays and a fitting tribute to Graeme Laurie's academic work, his scholarly impact and an illuminating guide to many of the challenges confronting bioethics.' Christopher Newdick, Professor Emeritus, University of Reading

‘This book is a worthy mark of the significance of Graeme Laurie's contribution to legal academia. It presents insights from some of the most impressive scholars currently working in law, ethics and medical jurisprudence. The result is a powerful testament to Graeme's legacy and the affection of his peers.' Shaun Pattinson, Professor of Medical Law and Ethics, University of Durham

From the Publisher