John Wesley's Teachings, Volume 1: God and Providence

by Thomas C. Oden

Overview

John Wesley's Teaching is the first systematic exposition of John Wesley's theology that is also faithful to Wesley's own writings. Wesley was a prolific writer and commentator on Scripture--his collected works fill eighteen volumes--and yet it is commonly held that he was not systematic or consistent in his theology and teachings. On the contrary, Thomas C. Oden demonstrates that Wesley displayed a remarkable degree of internal consistency over sixty years of preaching and ministry. This series of 4 volumes is a text-by-text guide to John Wesley's teaching. It introduces Wesley's thought on the basic tenets of Christian teaching: God, providence, and man (volume 1), Christ and salvation (volume 2), the practice of pastoral care (volume 3), and issues of ethics and society (volume 4). In everyday modern English, Oden clarifies Wesley's explicit intent and communicates his meaning clearly to a contemporary audience. Both lay and professional readers will find this series useful for devotional reading, moral reflection, sermon preparation, and for referencing Wesley's opinions on a broad range of pressing issues of contemporary society.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780310328155
Publisher:	Zondervan Academic
Publication date:	08/11/2012
Pages:	240
Product dimensions:	5.90(w) x 8.90(h) x 0.70(d)
Age Range:	18 Years

About the Author

Thomas C. Oden (PhD, Yale) is Director of the Center for Early African Christianity at Eastern University in St. Davids, Pennsylvania and Henry Anson Buttz Professor of Theology and Ethics at Drew University. He is an ordained Methodist minister and the author of many books, including The Rebirth of Orthodoxy: Signs of New Life in Christianity, How Africa Shaped the Christian Mind: Rediscovering the African Seedbed of Western Christianity, Doctrinal Standards in the Wesleyan Tradition, and Classic Christianity. Dr. Oden is also the general editor for the widely-used Ancient Christian Commentary on Scripture series.

Read an Excerpt

John Wesley's Teachings, Volume 1

---

By Thomas C. Oden

Zondervan

Copyright © 2012 Thomas C. Oden
All right reserved.
ISBN: 978-0-310-32815-5

---

Chapter One

God

In a series of homilies from his mature years, Wesley entered into a meticulous, detailed consideration of the divine attributes, especially the eternity, omnipresence, and unity of God. Though sparse, these homilies convey sufficient argument to indicate the main lines of Wesley's doctrine of God.

A. Attributes of God

The ancient Christian writers and the earliest ecumenical councils formed the foundation for the Anglican evangelicalism that Wesley affirmed. He was also very close to classic Protestant sources—Luther and Augsburg, Calvin and the Heidelberg Confession—regarding the knowledge and attributes of God.

Wesley summarized key points of the doctrine of God he had received in his renowned "Letter to a Roman Catholic": "As I am assured that there is an infinite and independent Being and that it is impossible there should be more than one, so I believe that this one God is the Father of all things," especially of self-determining rational creatures, and that this one "is in a peculiar manner the Father of those whom he regenerates by his Spirit, whom he adopts in his Son as coheirs with him." The eternity of God received more explicit treatment in Homily #54, "On Eternity."

1. The Eternity of God

a. Eternity Past and Future

The text of the homily "On Eternity" is Psalm 90:2: "From everlasting to everlasting, thou art God" [Homily #54 (1789), B 2:358–72; J #54, VI:189–98].

As immensity is boundless space, so eternity is "boundless duration." As omnipresence refers to God's relation to space, as present in every location, eternity refers to God's sovereign relation to time. God is intimately present in every moment.

There was no time when God was not. There will be no time when God will not be. If eternity is from everlasting to everlasting, it can be thought of as distinguishable in two directions: (1) Eternity past is that duration that reaches from everlasting, eternity before creation, time viewed as before, the eternity that precedes this now and all past nows, which Wesley calls a parte ante. (2) Eternity yet to come is the duration that reaches to everlasting, which will have no end, the whole of time after now, everything eternally on the future side of now (a parte post). Time viewed synoptically is a "fragment of eternity broken off at both ends."

The eternity of God embraces and surrounds time. Time is that portion of duration that begins when the world begins and ends when the world comes to its final days. We do not see all of time, but only a momentary glimpse, which we call the present.

b. Eternity as Decision Now

The faithful stand before God in a way that keeps them in the presence of eternity. When faith receives God as the Lord of time, everything is changed, all relationships are reshaped, all are reborn, all things become new. Social and ethical responsibility come from that change of heart of each person one by one, in due time affecting the flow of the political order and economic life. Only the renewed, whole person who is serious about eternity is rightly prepared to work effectively to make a better society.

Wesley offered a practical way of thinking personally about the eternity of God by placing his hearer imaginatively on the brink of a here-and-now decision: think of yourself as deciding now for or against eternal life. Each hearer is invited to enter now into an unending relationship with the Eternal by choosing a happy eternity, a life of eternal blessedness, or the misery of missing what is eternally good and worthy of worship. This is the choice being offered in the emerging reign of God. This decision is being made implicitly every temporal moment. It is hidden tacitly in every single human experience of time.

This continuing act of choosing has vast consequences for human happiness. It is no exaggeration to view human existence as deciding every moment toward the joy of eternal life or the despair of eternal emptiness. Only when we think of ourselves as standing on the edge of either a happy or a pitiable eternity does present life become meaningful and serious. "The Creator bids thee now stretch out thy hand either to the one or to the other."

Even if we doubt this, we can test the hypothesis that our personal lives will continue beyond bodily death in eternity. We all have a high stake in our relation to our eternal future. This premise alone has the latent power of transforming human actions.

2. Time

a. The Fleet Flow of Time

Every moment of time has the fleeting character of beginning and ending. That is what characterizes it as time. It is not a sad thought that time, which had a finite beginning in God and which has a fleeting present, will have a consummate ending in God. The faithful know that the Sovereign over time is in process of duly completing and fittingly refinishing the good but fallen creation. Nothing that happens within the distortions of history has power to undo God's long-range eternal purpose within time.

It is evident that we experience our living souls only as embodied within space. Similarly, we experience eternity only from within the crunch of time. This is why we who are so enmeshed in time and its demands are so permeated with finitude. We have great difficulty in grasping the very concept of eternity because of this condition of being so wrapped up in time. Our human awareness, as creatures of fleeting time, can form only a veiled idea of eternity, and that only by fragile analogies. As God is immense beyond any conceivable finite immensity, so eternity is infinite beyond any imaginable duration of time.

Time remains for temporal minds an ever-flowing mystery. There is no nontemporal moment or place for the finite mind to step away, as if to depart from time, to think trans-temporally about time, as if we had a point outside time to perceive time. Time is an uncommon mystery. It is difficult to wrap our minds around precisely because we are creatures lodged in time. It is right here in time that we are called to understand ourselves within the frame of reference of eternity, living life in this world as if accountable to the giver of time.

b. God in the Now

What divides past and future is now, the infinitely fleeting moment that can never be possessed as a fixed entity. We can never capture or hold a moment except in the tenuous form of memory. This is why temporal life is rightly compared to a dream.

What we call "now" keeps on vanishing, eluding our grasp, changing its face. Yet the present is the only position from which anyone can ever know or see the world, through the tiny keyhole of this constantly disappearing moment we call "now." This fleeting present lies "between two eternities." The moment we say "now," we have already lost the now in which we just said "now." We have this little splinter of ongoing time, which itself is a continuing refraction of the eternal.

God meets us in time, but as the incomparable Creator of time, God is not bound by time. Only one who is simultaneously present with every moment of time can fully know the future and past reaches of eternity. That one we call God.

c. Knowing Time from within Time

God is radically different from creatures in that God inhabits all eternity, whereas creatures inhabit fleeting successive temporal moments held together by memory and imagination.

Since God has a present relation to all past and future moments, God can know time in a far larger way than our knowing. The whole of time is beyond our knowing.

God's complete memory and foreknowledge of time do not coercively predetermine events to come or arbitrarily undo events that have occurred. God's relation to the future and past is entirely different from ours.

Time-drenched minds have limited access through memory to their personal past and to their future through imagination. Meanwhile, the eternal God is always already present to the past. God embraces the entirety of all times.

Harder to conceive is the premise that God is present to all future moments, a premise essential to the Christian teaching of the eternal God—that God already knows the future because he is eternally present to all moments. "Strictly speaking, there is no 'fore' knowledge, no more than 'after' knowledge with God: but all things are known to Him as present from eternity to eternity."

This does not mean that God determines the future so as to ignore or arbitrarily overrule human freedom. Divine foreknowledge does not imply predetermination. It simply means that God knows what outcomes the freedom of creatures will bring, because he dwells in the future. The omniscient God knows how the free choices of creatures will interplay with incalculable contingencies, because he has accompanied every step of every hypothetical choice. God has become paradoxically revealed in history as having already secured final outcomes that are still in process of unfolding in the decisions of free creatures in time. Nothing is taken away from the reality of human choice by the fact that God dwells in the future as well as the now.

d. Whether Spiritual Creatures Have a Beginning in Time

The human soul (psuche, anima) is the living aspect of human existence in time. Through conception and birth we are entrusted with soul, which is to say a life, an enlivening of flesh. The soul is generated in sexual procreation as a gift of God. Once given, psuche continues to exist beyond death as a relation with the eternal Life-giver. Jewish and Christian Scriptures promise that the soul will be reunited with the body in the resurrection on the last day. The soul is created and hence is not eternal in time past; but having been created, it does not finally come to nothing in death.

A corpse is a body without life—that is, no soul resides in the body. Death is defined as the separation of life (that which God breathes into the body) from the body. When the motion of the body ceases, its cardiovascular movement and breathing cease. The life or soul breathed into the body by God leaves the body but thereby does not simply end; it awaits a final reckoning. That end-time event is called the general resurrection. What happens at the end of history is the mystery of bodily resurrection in a glorified body that transcends simple physicality and yet is a resurrection of the same body. Death does not end the life of the soul or even finally of the body, since in the resurrection, body and soul are reunited.

e. Whether Material Creation Is Eternal

Matter is not eternal, since matter is created. Yet matter once created will not be annihilated but will finally be transformed so as to mirror once again the beauty and goodness of the original creation. Once God makes matter, he permits it to continually change, but not so as to be exterminated. The Almighty has sufficient power, of course, to annihilate atoms, but no reason to do so.

Wesley argued for the durability of atomic matter through whatever cosmic changes occur. Though creatures may lose their present form, every subparticle of every atom endures, even while being transmuted, under one form or other, to the fulfillment of time in eternity. Even diamonds, the hardest of physical substances, may under extreme heat be turned to dust, yet as dust they continue.

No creature shares with God the attribute of eternal aseity. This means that God's being is necessary being. It exists without beginning. "Yet there is no absurdity in supposing that all creatures are eternal a parte post. All matter indeed is continually changing ... but that it is changeable does in nowise imply that it is perishable. The substance may remain one and the same, though under innumerable different forms."

The promised new creation implies not the eradication of the old but its transformation . What is promised is a new heaven and new earth where nothing has been destroyed, a full renovation without annihilation. It "will melt" but "not perish." As matter changes in form but with its substance remaining through different forms, so in the case of the soul does life remain after death, yet in a different spiritual form.

(Continues...)

---

Excerpted from John Wesley's Teachings, Volume 1 by Thomas C. Oden Copyright © 2012 by Thomas C. Oden. Excerpted by permission of Zondervan. All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

---

Table of Contents

Preface 13

Abbreviations 17

Introduction 21

A The Teaching Homily as Christian Doctrine

1 The Scope of Wesley's Teaching

2 The Teaching Homily

3 The Whole Compass of Divinity

B Wesley's Evangelical Connection of Spiritual Formation

1 The Connection

2 The Scope of Wesleyan Connection Today

C My Purpose

1 Why I Write on Wesley: A Note on Vocation

2 Clear Exposition

3 Adhering to Primary Sources

D History and Doctrine

1 The Chief Mentor of Modern Wesley Studies

2 Whether Wesley Was a Systematic Theologian

3 How to Make Practical Use of This Study

Volume 1 God and Providence

Chapter 1 God 35

A Attributes of God

1 The Eternity of God

2 Time

3 The Omnipresence of God

4 The Unity of the Divine Being

5 Relational Attributes: Goodness, Mercy, Holiness, Spirit

6 God, Happiness, and Religion

7 True and False Religion

8 The Wisdom of God's Counsels

9 The First Article of the Articles of Religion: On God

B God the Father, God the Son, God the Spirit

1 On the Trinity

2 Spiritual Worship - On Triune Spirituality

Chapter 2 The Primacy of Scripture 65

A The Authority of Scripture

1 The Primacy and Normative Authority of the Plain Sense of Scripture

2 The Analogy of Faith

3 Spirit and Scripture

4 Scripture, Conscience, and General Revelation

B The Inspiration of Holy Scripture

1 A Clear and Concise Demonstration of the Divine Inspiration of Holy Scripture

2 Wesley as Commentator on Scripture

3 On Corrupting the Word of God

Interlude: God's Particular Method of Working 81

Chapter 3 Tradition 83

A Tradition as the Consensual Reception of the Apostolic Teaching

1 The Unchanging Apostolic Tradition of Scripture Teaching through Changing History

2 Wesley as Editor of Classic Christian Writings

Chapter 4 Reason 93

A On Reason

1 Reason as God's Gift

2 Reasoning Out of Scripture

3 The Case of Reason Impartially Considered

4 What Reason Can and Cannot Do

5 The Imperfection of Human Knowledge

B Natural Philosophy

1 Whether There Is Gradual Improvement in Natural Philosophy

2 On Human Understanding

Chapter 5 Experience 111

A On Experience

1 The Necessity and Limits of Experience in Religion

2 On Spiritual Senses

3 On Living without God-The Parable of the Tree Toad

4 The New Birth of the Spiritual Senses

B On Enthusiasm

1 The Nature of Enthusiasm

2 Types of Enthusiasm

3 How Scripture Corrects Experience

C The Catholic Spirit

1 The Premise of Tolerance

2 Challenging Latitudinarianism

3 To a Roman Catholic-An Irenic Letter

D A Caution against Bigotry

1 Why Bigotry Is an Offense against the Catholic Spirit

2 How the Spirit of Bigotry Is Tested

3 How to Examine Our Own Bigotry

Chapter 6 Creation, Providence, and Evil 133

A The Goodness of Creation

1 God's Approbation of His Works

2 The Free-Will Defense

B Spiritual Creation

1 Of Good Angels

2 Of Evil Angels

C Providence

1 On Divine Providence

2 Special Providence

3 On God's Sovereignty

D Theodicy

1 Whence Comes Evil?

2 The Promise of Understanding in the Future

E Evil

1 On Natural Evil

2 The Groaning of Creation and the General Deliverance

Chapter 7 Man 171

A Human Existence: Created, Fallen, and Redeemed

1 The Anthropology of the Articles of Religion

2 Free Will after the Fall (Article 8)

B The Image of God

1 In His Own Image

2 Whether the Image of God May Be Recovered

C What Is Man? Two Discourses

1 Man in Space, Man in Time (First Discourse)

2 On the Greatness of the Human Soul within Space and Time

3 Suppose There Were Other Worlds

4 I Find Something in Me That Thinks (Second Discourse)

5 Human Life a Dream

6 Heavenly Treasure in Earthen Vessels

7 Countering the Overreach of Natural Science

Chapter 8 Sin 189

A On the Deceitfulness of the Human Heart

1 Why Optimists Forever Misjudge the Human Heart

2 Toward Scriptural Realism about the Human Heart: Why Desperately Wicked?

3 Why Deceitful above All Things?

4 Toward the Mending of the Self-Deceived Will

B On the Fall of Man

1 Why Does God Allow Misery and Heartache in the World He Loves?

2 The Consequence of Sin for the Body-Soul Composite

C Spiritual Idolatry

1 Keep Yourselves from Idols

2 Idolatry in the Form of Sensuality

3 Idolatry in the Form of Pride

4 The Idols of Imagination

5 Inordinate Love of Money and Sex

6 Whether Penitent Faith Can Break the Bondage of Idolatry

Chapter 9 Original Sin 199

A The Doctrine of Original Sin according to Scripture, Reason, and Experience

1 Why Wesley Wrote His Longest Treatise on Sin

2 Whether Sin Is a Socially Transmitted Disease

3 Combating the Deist Denial of Original Sin: A Searching Response to John Taylor

B Evidences of Sin Displayed in the History of Sin

1 Human History Attests the Universality of Corruption

2 Whether Human Corruptibility and Misery Are Found Universally

C Sociological Evidences of the Universality of Human Corruption

1 The Universality of Sin in Nontheistic Cultures

2 The Universality of Sin in Theistic Cultures

3 The Universality of Sin in Predominantly Christian Cultures

4 Whether War Is a Prototype of Social Sin

5 Experiential Self-Examination Confirms the Universality of Sin

6 The Unhappiness of Universal Human History Is Due to the Unholiness of Human Choices

D Learning from Scripture about Original Sin

1 From the Beginning

2 Whether One Suffers from Another's Sin

E Sin and Death

1 Distinguishing Temporal Death from Spiritual Death

2 Whether Redemption in Christ Makes Up for Losses Suffered in Adam

3 The Westminster Catechism on Original Sin

E Adam's Headship with Eve's Cooperation

1 Adam as a Public Person: On Federal Headship

2 The Consequence of Adam's Fall for Subsequent Human History

3 The Abyss into Which Humanity Plunged

4 Distinguishing Original Sin from Actual Sin

G Answering Questions on the Insidious Spread of Sin

1 The Intergenerational Sociality of Sin

2 The Communication of the Sin of Adam and Eve to All Humanity

3 Whether Loss of Communion with God Sharpens the Sting of Unexplained Suffering

4 Whether There Remains a Natural Tendency to Sin

5 Whether Guilt May be Imputed from One to Another

H The Hidden Link between Redemption and Original Sin

1 Original Sin and New Birth

2 Retraining Wesley's Doctrine within Contemporary Culture

I Conclusion

Appendix A Alphabetical Correlation of the Sermons in the Jackson and Bicentennial Editions 225

Appendix B Bicentennial Volume Titles Published to Date 231

Subject Index 232

Scripture Index 240