How to Interpret the Constitution

by Cass R. Sunstein

Overview

From New York Times bestselling author Cass Sunstein, a timely and powerful argument for rethinking how the U.S. Constitution is interpreted

The U.S. Supreme Court has eliminated the right to abortion and is revisiting other fundamental questions today—about voting rights, affirmative action, gun laws, and much more. Once-arcane theories of constitutional interpretation are profoundly affecting the lives of all Americans. In this brief and urgent book, Harvard Law School professor Cass Sunstein provides a lively introduction to competing approaches to interpreting the Constitution—and argues that the only way to choose one is to ask whether it would change American life for the better or worse. If a method of interpretation would eliminate the right of privacy, allow racial segregation, or obliterate free speech, it would be unacceptable for that reason.

But some Supreme Court justices are committed to “originalism,” arguing that the meaning of the Constitution is settled by how it was publicly understood when it was ratified. Originalists insist that their approach is dictated by the Constitution. That, Sunstein argues, is a big mistake. The Constitution doesn’t contain instructions for its own interpretation. Any approach to constitutional interpretation needs to be defended in terms of its broad effects—what it does to our rights and our institutions. It must respect those rights and institutions—and safeguard the conditions for democracy itself.

Passionate and compelling, How to Interpret the Constitution is essential reading for anyone who is concerned about how the Supreme Court is changing the rights and lives of Americans today.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780691252049
Publisher:	Princeton University Press
Publication date:	08/15/2023
Pages:	208
Sales rank:	117,051
Product dimensions:	5.80(w) x 8.50(h) x 1.00(d)

About the Author

Cass R. Sunstein is the Robert Walmsley University Professor at Harvard University and the founder and director of the Program on Behavioral Economics and Public Policy at Harvard Law School. He is the recipient of Norway’s Holberg Prize, which is sometimes described as the equivalent of the Nobel Prize for law and the humanities. His many books include the New York Times bestseller Nudge (with Richard H. Thaler), On Freedom (Princeton), and #Republic (Princeton).

What People are Saying About This

From the Publisher

“Even to one who answers the question—how to interpret the Constitution—differently than Cass Sunstein, this introduction to the topic is refreshingly commonsensical, accessible, and fair-minded.”—Michael W. McConnell, Stanford Law School

“Cass Sunstein, one of the nation’s leading constitutional scholars, provides a citizen’s guide to current controversies over how to interpret the Constitution. Everyone interested in constitutional law and today’s Supreme Court will benefit from grappling with Sunstein’s arguments.”—Mark Tushnet, Harvard Law School, author of Taking Back the Constitution

Editorial Reviews

"Longlisted for the Edwards Book Award, Rodel Institute"

From the Publisher

★ 2023-04-04
An incisive rethinking of the U.S. Constitution.

Sunstein, the founder and director of the Program on Behavioral Economics and Public Policy at Harvard Law School, begins by pointing out the irrefutable fact that “the Constitution does not contain the instructions for its own interpretation.” Thus, “no approach to constitutional interpretation is required or self-justifying.” On those grounds, he briskly swats away every jurisprudentially, philosophically, and historically justified interpretive scheme—“anti-originalist” as well as “originalist,” of the left as well as the right—that has been advanced since the 19th century. All schools and schemes of interpretation fall before his generous-spirited ax strokes. In their place, he argues, there can be only one acceptable, humane approach to judicial interpretation: the search among jurists for a “ ‘reflective equilibrum’ in which [jurists’] judgments, at multiple levels of generality, are brought into alignment with each other” in order to achieve the most democratically acceptable and fairest outcome achievable at the time. “There is no alternative to the search for reflective equilibrium,” writes the author, because “no theory makes sense for every imaginable world.” Though disarmingly and intentionally “simple and straightforward,” as well as open-hearted, common-sensical, and succinct, Sunstein’s text, given its grave and demanding subject, requires readers’ attentiveness. Despite the author’s fair-mindedness, it’s clear that his main targets are the originalist and traditionalist arguments that have recently captured the radical right and are overturning decades of settled constitutional law. Is Sunstein’s interpretive scheme strong enough to halt the further advance of originalist and traditionalist thinking on the Supreme Court? Probably not. But it’s a brave, muscular, and compelling roadblock now standing in the way of originalist ideologues. This book should be in the hands of every law student, constitutional lawyer, judge, and Supreme Court justice.

One of the most significant works about constitutional interpretation in recent years.

Kirkus Reviews

If you've ever found yourself curious about how and why the Supreme Court does what it does--particularly during the past decade or so--this audiobook is for you. Graham Winton offers a measured yet compelling delivery of Sunstein's interpretations of recent major Court decisions and how they impact all Americans. The arguments on the correct way to interpret the Constitution could have led to a dry reading of legal arguments, statutes, and precedent. Instead, Winton gives no hints of his preferences with regard to which interpretations of the law are right or wrong, better or worse. Instead, he lets the facts surrounding recent headline-grabbing cases speak for themselves. This is an educational listen about legal matters that impact us all. J.P.S. © AudioFile 2023, Portland, Maine

OCTOBER 2023 - AudioFile