Home by Christmas: The Illusion of Victory in 1944

Home by Christmas: The Illusion of Victory in 1944

by Ronald Andidora
Home by Christmas: The Illusion of Victory in 1944

Home by Christmas: The Illusion of Victory in 1944

by Ronald Andidora


    Qualifies for Free Shipping
    Choose Expedited Shipping at checkout for delivery by Wednesday, December 6
    Check Availability at Nearby Stores

Related collections and offers


By September 1944, Allied forces had broken out from the Normandy beachheads, liberated Paris, and found themselves poised on the German border. As this offensive gained momentum, Patton and Montgomery, hoping to exploit the enemy's temporary weakness in the West, concocted their own alternatives to Eisenhower's broad front strategy. Each proposed a single thrust aimed directly into the German heartland, designed to bring the troops home by Christmas. This study examines this so-called broad front-single thrust controversy and concludes that the idea of early victory was wishful thinking—a product of the erroneous and dangerous assumption that the Nazi regime was already tottering on the brink of collapse.

Precisely because of its lightning pace, the Allied advance resulted in severe logistical problems, limiting Patton's proposed operation to only ten combat divisions, while Montgomery's closer proximity to the coast might have allowed for as many as sixteen. But it should have been obvious that either thrust faced certain destruction against the 250 divisions still fielded by the Wehrmacht on all fronts in September. In light of this substantial German military capacity, despite serious losses and strategic setbacks, the single thrust could not have been a decisive war-ending maneuver. In fact, Andidora argues, it could not even have provided for its own security against the forces that would have coalesced against it. Rather than unnecessarily prolonging the war, as some have argued, Eisenhower's decision to stay the strategic course probably averted a military disaster.

Product Details

ISBN-13: 9780313317514
Publisher: Bloomsbury Academic
Publication date: 11/30/2001
Series: Contributions in Military Studies Series , #216
Pages: 224
Product dimensions: 6.14(w) x 9.21(h) x 0.56(d)

About the Author

RONALD ANDIDORA is an independent researcher. His previous publications include Iron Admirals (Greenwood, 2000) and numerous articles for Military History Magazine, World War II Magazine, Parameters, and the Naval War College Review. He worked for more than twenty years in the Pennsylvania Senate.

Table of Contents

Marriage of Convenience
The Heart of the Enemy
Ways and Means
Success and Stalemate
Agonizing Appraisal
Breakout and Meltdown
Plague of Options
A World Turbaned Upside Down
Competing Panacea
The Harsh Mistress
Past Imperfect
Single Thrust Refuted
The Illusion of Victory

From the B&N Reads Blog

Customer Reviews