Holocaust Representation: Art within the Limits of History and Ethics

by Berel Lang

Overview

Since Theodor Adorno's attack on the writing of poetry "after Auschwitz," artists and theorists have faced the problem of reconciling the moral enormity of the Nazi genocide with the artist's search for creative freedom. In Holocaust Representation, Berel Lang addresses the relation between ethics and art in the context of contemporary discussions of the Holocaust. Are certain aesthetic means or genres "out of bounds" for the Holocaust? To what extent should artists be constrained by the "actuality" of history—and is the Holocaust unique in raising these problems of representation?

The dynamics between artistic form and content generally hold even more intensely, Lang argues, when art's subject has the moral weight of an event like the Holocaust. As authors reach beyond the standard conventions for more adequate means of representation, Holocaust writings frequently display a blurring of genres. The same impulse manifests itself in repeated claims of historical as well as artistic authenticity. Informing Lang's discussion are the recent conflicts about the truth-status of Benjamin Wilkomirski's "memoir" Fragments and the comic fantasy of Roberto Benigni's film Life Is Beautiful. Lang views Holocaust representation as limited by a combination of ethical and historical constraints. As art that violates such constraints often lapses into sentimentality or melodrama, cliché or kitsch, this becomes all the more objectionable when its subject is moral enormity. At an extreme, all Holocaust representation must face the test of whether its referent would not be more authentically expressed by silence—that is, by the absence of representation.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780801876363
Publisher:	Johns Hopkins University Press
Publication date:	05/01/2003
Sold by:	Barnes & Noble
Format:	eBook
Pages:	192
File size:	2 MB
Age Range:	18 Years

About the Author

Berel Lang is a professor of humanities at Trinity College. His many books include Writing and the Moral Self, Mind's Bodies: Thought in the Act, Heidegger's Silence, and Act and Idea in the Nazi Genocide.

Table of Contents

Preface and Acknowledgments
Introduction: Art Within The Limits
Part I: Image and Fact: The Problem of Holocaust Representation
Chapter 1. Writing the Holocaust: Toward the Condition of History
Chapter 2. Holocaust Texts and the Blurred Genres
Chapter 3. The Limits of Representation and the Representation of Limits
Chapter 4. The Facts of Fiction: Three Case Studies in Holocaust Writing
Chapter 5. The Importance of Holocaust Misrepresentation
Part II: Eye and Mind: Reflecting the Holocaust
Chapter 6. The Arts of History
Chapter 7. Translating the Holocaust: For Whom Does One Write?
Chapter 8. The Post-Holocaust vs. the Postmodern: Evil Inside and Outside History
Chapter 9. Art Worship and Its Images
Index

What People are Saying About This

Arthur C. Danto

Berel Lang has achieved in these essays a remarkable and compelling piece of philosophical literary criticism. He aims for nothing less than a demonstration that writings on the Holocaust, however imaginative, cannot escape the form or fact of the history of that event. There is, in this unique case, an internal relationship between truth and poetic representation. It is a powerful and sobering analysis of the limits of art.

— Arthur C. Danto, Columbia University

Richard Stamelman

Berel Lang offers a compellingly original, subtle, and provocative meditation on those historical and ethical constraints that invariably limit the representation of the 'unrepresentable,' the speaking of the 'unspeakable.' Joining philosophical inquiry and historical analysis, literary criticism and art history, Lang presents a new interpretation of the 'blurring'—of literary genres, of artistic forms, of historical discourses, of stylistic conventions—that, in the afterwards of history and memory, extreme trauma imposes on representation.

— Richard Stamelman, Williams College

Herbert Lindenberger

Displaying at once the intellectual precision of a philosopher, the verbal sensitivity of a literary critic, and the concreteness of a historian, Berel Lang has produced an immensely appealing book that will attract readers throughout the humanities. Holocaust Representation brilliantly rethinks and redirects that flourishing new genre, the book about Holocaust writing.

— Herbert Lindenberger, Stanford University

Alvin H. Rosenfeld

Berel Lang's writings on Holocaust representations reveal the broad range of aesthetic and ethical complexities that define this important subject. Lang's essays, historically informed and critically astute, warrant and will amply reward the most careful reading.

— Alvin H. Rosenfeld, Indiana University

From the Publisher

Berel Lang has achieved in these essays a remarkable and compelling piece of philosophical literary criticism. He aims for nothing less than a demonstration that writings on the Holocaust, however imaginative, cannot escape the form or fact of the history of that event. There is, in this unique case, an internal relationship between truth and poetic representation. It is a powerful and sobering analysis of the limits of art.
—Arthur C. Danto, Columbia University

With his profound philosophical grasp of both aesthetic and ethical issues at play in Holocaust literature and art, Berel Lang brings great clarity to the very difficult and complex issues surrounding Holocaust representation—whether by survivors or by the next generation.
—James E. Young, University of Massachusetts, Amherst

Displaying at once the intellectual precision of a philosopher, the verbal sensitivity of a literary critic, and the concreteness of a historian, Berel Lang has produced an immensely appealing book that will attract readers throughout the humanities. Holocaust Representation brilliantly rethinks and redirects that flourishing new genre, the book about Holocaust writing.
—Herbert Lindenberger, Stanford University

Berel Lang offers a compellingly original, subtle, and provocative meditation on those historical and ethical constraints that invariably limit the representation of the 'unrepresentable,' the speaking of the 'unspeakable.' Joining philosophical inquiry and historical analysis, literary criticism and art history, Lang presents a new interpretation of the 'blurring'—of literary genres, of artistic forms, of historical discourses, of stylistic conventions—that, in the afterwards of history and memory, extreme trauma imposes on representation.
—Richard Stamelman, Williams College

Berel Lang's writings on Holocaust representations reveal the broad range of aesthetic and ethical complexities that define this important subject. Lang's essays, historically informed and critically astute, warrant and will amply reward the most careful reading.
—Alvin H. Rosenfeld, Indiana University

James E. Young

With his profound philosophical grasp of both aesthetic and ethical issues at play in Holocaust literature and art, Berel Lang brings great clarity to the very difficult and complex issues surrounding Holocaust representation—whether by survivors or by the next generation.

— James E. Young, University of Massachusetts, Amherst

James E. Young

With his profound philosophical grasp of both aesthetic and ethical issues at play in Holocaust literature and art, Berel Lang brings great clarity to the very difficult and complex issues surrounding Holocaust representation—whether by survivors or by the next generation.
—James E. Young, University of Massachusets, Amherst

Editorial Reviews

Lang (humanities, Trinity College) addresses the relation between ethics and art in the context of contemporary discussions of the Holocaust. He asks questions such as whether certain aesthetic means or genres are out of bounds for the Holocaust, to what extent artists should be constrained by the facts of history, and whether the Holocaust is unique in raising such problems of representation. He argues that when art's subject has the moral weight of an event like the Holocaust, the relationship between artist and content is critical and must face the test of whether its referent would not be more authentically expressed by silence. Annotation c. Book News, Inc., Portland, OR (booknews.com)

Booknews

Holocaust Representation tackles the thorny subject of ethics and art as they bear on works commemorating or referring to the Holocaust.
—James Malpas, Art Newspaper

From the Publisher

Holocaust Representation tackles the thorny subject of ethics and art as they bear on works commemorating or referring to the Holocaust.

Art Newspaper - James Malpas

Holocaust Representation tackles the thorny subject of ethics and art as they bear on works commemorating or referring to the Holocaust.

— James Malpas

Art Newspaper