Hell's Traces: One Murder, Two Families, Thirty-Five Holocaust Memorials

by Victor Ripp Narrated by David Colacci

Overview

In July 1942, the French police in Paris, acting for the German military government, arrested Victor Ripp's three-year-old cousin, Alexandre. Two months later, the boy was killed in Auschwitz. In Hell's Traces, Ripp examines this act through the prism of family history. In addition to Alexandre, ten members of Ripp's family on his father's side died in the Holocaust. His mother's side of the family, numbering thirty people, was in Berlin when Hitler came to power. Without exception they escaped the Final Solution.



Hell's Traces tells the story of the two families' divergent paths. To spark the past to life, he embarks on a journey to visit Holocaust memorials throughout Europe.



A memorial in Warsaw that includes a boxcar like the ones that carried Jews to Auschwitz compels Ripp to contemplate the horror of Alexandre's transport to his death. One in Berlin that invokes the anti-Jewish laws of the 1930s allows him to better understand how his mother's family escaped the Nazis. In Paris he stumbles across a playground dedicated to the memory of the French children who were deported, Alexandre among them. Ultimately, Ripp sees thirty-five memorials in six countries. He encounters the artists who designed the memorials, historians who recall the events that are memorialized, and survivors with their own stories to tell.

Editorial Reviews

Publishers Weekly

12/12/2016
Ripp (Moscow to Main Street) travels to 35 Holocaust memorials in seven countries in an effort to better understand the short life of his cousin Alexandre, while ruminating on the functions of memorials. Ripp never met his cousin, though the two were close in age; Alexandre was only three years old when he was taken to Auschwitz and killed, along with other 10 family members on the author’s father’s side. The memorials themselves are given more attention than Ripp’s family history. Some of the monuments are well known, such as the main Holocaust Memorial in Berlin; others are considerably off the beaten path, such as the Grodno Ghetto memorial in Belarus and Jochen Gerz’s “disappearing memorial” in Hamburg, which slowly sank underground and is invisible from street level. Ripp is an engaging and empathic writer who has found a unique, moving way to tell his extended family’s story during the Holocaust and to memorably honor his martyred cousin. Agency: Melanie Jackson Agency. (Mar.)

From the Publisher

"With this act of memory and imagination, Mr. Ripp transforms his cousin from a ghostly memory to a vivid presence whose loss he—and his readers—can more fully grasp." —Diane Cole, Wall Street Journal

"[Hell's Traces]is a travelogue to places that no longer exist and can never be known, to the epitome of the indescribable—the Holocaust . . . Ripp is meticulous in his pursuit, using each memorial he visits as a launching pad to an investigation—often aided by local historians—into his relatives’ lives. It is here that Ripp’s real gift, an intricate talent for empathy, shines through . . . A fine meditation on trying to make sense of history's ultimate senseless act of violence." —Liel Leibovitz, Tablet

"Victor Ripp . . . applies his ingenuity and investigative skills to trying to uncover the reasons behind the murder of his three-year-old cousin, Alexandre . . . [Ripp's] international viewpoint and fluid writing style infuse the pages with color." —Linda F. Burghardt, Jewish Book Council

"Victor Ripp's powerful double-helix of a family memoir traces two very different Holocaust experiences . . . Ripp expands his personal narrative into a rich meditation on memory and the public commemoration of tragedy." —Politics and Prose Bookstore

"[Ripp] takes a journey of remembrance as he attempts to make sense of his family's past . . . With a deft touch, [he] has written one of the more unusual yet effective Holocaust histories. He doesn't preach, just shows." —Library Journal

"Ripp is an engaging and empathic writer who has found a unique, moving way to tell his extended family's story during the Holocaust and to memorably honor his martyred cousin." —Publishers Weekly

"[Ripp] maintains an emotional honesty above all . . . An idiosyncratic work striving for sense and meaning from a family record of enormous loss and obfuscation." —Kirkus

"Hell’s Traces is a brief book that is vast and deep in its fiercely unsentimental consideration of how we remember the Holocaust." —André Aciman

“The Axis of Exile and the Axis of the Holocaust —the two axes that define the space of the Jewish Museum in Berlin—also define the fate of the family of Victor Ripp’s family. While his mother's family chose the Axis of Exile, his father's family was devoured by the Axis of the Holocaust. The story of their lives, interwoven with the author's journey from one monument to another, is more powerful than so many of those made of stone.” —Anna Bikont, author of The Crime and the Silence, winner of the National Jewish Book Award

"A journey through six European countries in quest of the history of two families whose different fates were determined by the Shoah. Hell’s Traces is a profound reflection on the ability of memory to recover meaning from oblivion." —Serge and Beatte Klarsfeld

“Hell’s Traces asks important questions about the tension between private remembrance and public memorialization. Ripp touchingly discovers a truth, something public memorials struggle to communicate: That the memory of those lost in the Holocaust, as well as of those who survived, is preserved only within us, in our own entanglement in history; and that the author himself is the memorial he seeks.” —Glenn Kurtz, author of Three Minutes in Poland

From the Publisher - AUDIO COMMENTARY

"[Ripp] takes a journey of remembrance as he attempts to make sense of his family's past . . . With a deft touch, [he] has written one of the more unusual yet effective Holocaust histories. He doesn't preach, just shows." —Library Journal

Library Journal

12/01/2016
His father was a Ripp, while his mother descended from the affluent Kahan family with international connections. Members of the Kahans largely escaped the Holocaust, migrating to the United States, where they continued to prosper. Descendants of the Ripps have a different story altogether. One of the many Ripp victims of the Holocaust was the author's young cousin Alexandre, who disappeared into the maws of Auschwitz in the fall of 1942. Decades later, Victor Ripp (Pizza in Pushkin Square) takes a journey of remembrance as he attempts to make sense of his family's past. He traces Alexandre's path from his arrest in Paris to his death in Auschwitz, visiting numerous Holocaust memorials in countries such as Austria, Switzerland, Poland, and Russia. The author reflects on how people shape history, even monuments, to sugarcoat past transgressions. Even memorials to the Holocaust can be used to play political games. (He exclaims of a monument in Vienna, "How do you spell 'self-serving?' ") VERDICT With a deft touch, Ripp has written one of the more unusual yet effective Holocaust histories. He doesn't preach, just shows.—David Keymer, Modesto, CA

Kirkus Reviews

2017-01-24
A personal attempt to tackle emotionally the Nazi roundup of a 3-year-old relative to the concentration camps.An American Jew whose family escaped the Nazi death machine when another branch of the family did not, Ripp (Pizza in Pushkin Square: What Russians Think About Americans and the American Way of Life, 1990, etc.) resolved to visit European Holocaust memorials in order to garner a visceral sense of what they expressed—and what they were unable to express. The death of his young cousin Alexandre Ripp, in Auschwitz in 1942, followed his "arrest" with his grandmother in Paris in July 1942 ("arrested suggests more force than needed to take a three-year-old into custody"). This served as a poignant reminder that the branch of the family in Berlin with money, the Kahans, was able to emigrate before the Nazis got them, while the working-class Ripps, namely Alexandre's father, Aron, born in Grodno, Poland, and relocated to Paris, were relegated to hiding and eventual execution. The author visited many Holocaust memorials in Europe—35, he claims—many off the beaten path in Poland and Austria, and he is not easily impressed by the good intentions of famous artists. Above all, the author craved a "personal connection" to the memorials, a sense of being moved intimately and outside the institutional setting. "You have to find your proper place in the particular stretch of history that the memorial invokes," writes Ripp. "Tenuously connected or deeply involved, it doesn't matter which, as long as you are honest." His father had come from Grodno, and his memories of the Poles were not generous; the author often scrutinizes and suspects his handlers and translators along the route for being emotionally expedient. Overall, his memoir is prickly and selective, occasionally haphazard, yet he maintains an emotional honestly above all. An idiosyncratic work striving for sense and meaning from a family record of enormous loss and obfuscation.

Product Details

BN ID:	2940170546411
Publisher:	Tantor Audio
Publication date:	03/31/2017
Edition description:	Unabridged

Read an Excerpt

Hell's Traces

One Murder, Two Families, Thirty-Five Holocaust Memorials

---

By Victor Ripp

Farrar, Straus and Giroux

Copyright © 2017 Victor Ripp
All rights reserved.
ISBN: 978-0-86547-833-6

---

CHAPTER 1

Alexandre Ripp was my cousin on my father's side. In July 1942, the French police in Paris, acting for the German military government, arrested him — though "arrested" suggests more force than needed to take a three-year-old child into custody. Alexandre was killed in Auschwitz two months later.

Over the years, I spoke about my cousin very rarely. I could see that the story of his ordeal was of interest to most people only when patched onto the story of the Holocaust, and that had been told many times over. So many books, films, photographs — there seemed no space left for Alexandre. Then something happened that showed me I was wrong.

I was in Berlin's Jewish Museum to see the exhibit Berlin Transit, about the influx of Russian Jews into Berlin in the 1920s. The Kahans, my family on my mother's side, had been a wealthy and philanthropically active émigré family in that city, which made them a good exemplar of the exhibit's theme. Two rooms were devoted to the Kahans.

After an hour spent considering the mementos and documents and photos and wondering how all of it might be connected to the life I was living (ex-professor of Russian literature, comfortable Colonial with paid-up mortgage, three-year-old Honda in the driveway), I decided to have a look at the rest of the museum. The layout was unusual. The architect had designed a building that was itself a sort of exhibit. Strolling through it should be as meaningful an experience as looking at any of the paintings hanging on the walls.

The scheme of the interior kept me moving along toward an intersection of three corridors, two of which especially got my attention. One was marked "Axis of Exile" and opened onto a garden. The other, "Axis of the Holocaust," ended in an askew, dimly lit room that suggested a prison cell or, once I let my imagination go, a physical analog of shapeless horror. That Jews had few options as the Nazis took control was old news, but the Kahan family exhibit that I had just seen made me look at those two corridors in a particularly personal way.

The Kahan family in Berlin, several generations' worth, numbered some thirty people, and without exception they escaped the Final Solution. When Hitler came to power, most moved to Palestine; others went westward, eventually to the United States. They had found their way through the first corridor, but my cousin Alexandre had been forced into the second. His mother, both grandmothers, three granduncles, a grandaunt, and three of his cousins also died in the Holocaust. And while the Kahans got a commemorative exhibit, the Ripps who were killed by the Nazis didn't even have a grave.

Of course the museum had its own goals, and that was fine. Museums have to attract an audience, and they design their exhibits accordingly. My sense of a miscarriage was personal. In my mind, the Ripps and the Kahans were linked. My father married into the Kahan family, but that did not make him any less Alexandre's uncle. My mother was Alexandre's aunt, but she never stopped thinking of herself as Zina Kahan's daughter. But a kinship diagram wouldn't tell the whole story. The two families were socially and emotionally intertwined.

If the histories of the two families were plotted on a graph, there would be numerous points of convergence. One would mark the German occupation of Paris, when Alexandre's father, Aron — always Aronchik to friends and family — hid in the Kahans' vacated business office on Rue de la Bienfaisance. That convergence deserves an asterisk to connote a wrinkle of fate. The office was vacant only because the Kahans had managed to get out of Paris just before the Nazis took control.

There were also moments when the lines on the graph would be far apart, as the two families followed their dissimilar paths. The Ripps went from Grodno, in what is now Belarus, to Paris, while the Kahans began in Poland before passing through Baku, in Azerbaijan, and pausing for a decade in Berlin. But the lines would still be on the same graph because they equally traced how the two families were pushed across the map of Europe by the twentieth century's catastrophes.

One more link between the families: Put photos of me and Alexandre both at age three side by side. Everyone remarks on the resemblance. But there's a difference that shadows the resemblance. I escaped the Nazi trap and Alexandre didn't. His murder is a key moment in the history of the two families, casting a bleak light on many events that went before.

* * *

When I got back to the States after seeing the Berlin exhibit, I tried to write about the two families. But I couldn't get it to work. The words lay lifelessly on the page as in some antique chronicle. The events occurred long ago, I couldn't grasp what made them move one way and not another. I had to find something in the world around me that would make the past appear more vivid.

That, I realized when I thought about it, is what memorials do. They exist in the present but take their meanings from the past, they bring history closer, and that was what I needed. I understood that memorials typically evoke the lives of famous men and women and events of global significance, not the histories of two families like the Ripps and the Kahans who had little claim to public attention. But that was only one way to look at it.

Consider this: When I saw Maya Lin's Vietnam Veterans Memorial, my first thoughts were about how political decisions made thousands of miles from the battlefield had caused many Americans to die. I recalled that politicians talked of communism on the march, about something called the Domino Theory. The memorial prompted thoughts about the sweep of great historical events. That was my initial response, but it was not the only one. I thought about my own connection to the Vietnam War — how luck and circumstance had kept me out of harm's way, how one friend escaped the draft by going to Canada, how another was a medic in the Mekong Delta. Memorials can trigger different messages, some more personal than others.

The story of the Kahans and the Ripps that I wanted to tell was ultimately a Holocaust story, so it would be Holocaust memorials that I should see. I planned to visit as many as I could include in a short itinerary. They would certainly remind me of how the Nazis killed six million Jews, and a refresher of that history lesson is always worthwhile. But I hoped that some memorials would also spark to life the story about the different destinies of the Kahans and the Ripps.

* * *

I decided to go and see the Holocaust memorial in New Jersey's Liberty State Park. It was a random choice, but I had to begin somewhere and it wasn't that far from home. Negotiating the exuberant traffic on the turnpike was probably not the best way to get into the right mood, but once off the exit ramp and into the park I slipped into another mode of existence. The tree-lined driveway was some two miles long, and by the time I reached its end I felt something approaching reverence. New Jersey doesn't often get this still and quiet. It helped that it was the middle of a workweek — only one family of picnickers to be seen, a few cyclists, a virtually empty parking lot.

The memorial is set off by itself in a treeless space that opens onto a view of the Hudson and the Manhattan skyline beyond. It is some fifteen feet high and consists of two blackened bronze figures. A helmeted American soldier, pants tucked into his boots, carries a concentration camp survivor in his arms. The soldier is robust and strong — he needs only one hand to hold up his burden. The other figure is so thin that his ribs are visible, and his limp body suggests a nearness to death. He clings to the soldier to keep from falling.

The inscription on the pedestal, "Dedicated to America's Role of Preserving Freedom and Rescuing the Oppressed," underscores the obvious. The soldier is the focal point of the memorial, the concentration camp survivor is a prop to emphasize the soldier's generosity of spirit, his heroic nature. And the Holocaust was an opportunity for Pax Americana to show its stuff.

When I looked beyond the memorial, Ellis Island and the Statue of Liberty loomed in the middle distance. The triptych — memorial, island, statue — was almost certainly not accidental. Grouped with those two national icons, the memorial took on some of their significance. It became part of a celebration of the values America endorses. "The Star -Spangled Banner" playing in the background was all that was needed to complete the composition.

Heading back to my car, I stopped off at the information desk to pick up some literature. I learned that the memorial was created by Nathan Rapoport, a Polish sculptor whose works are also on exhibit in Warsaw and Jerusalem. That was information worth noting. It underscored something that should have been obvious but kept slipping out of focus — that the memorial I had just seen was not the spirit of the Jewish people set in stone with no human intervention, but something built by one man with his own ideas about the Holocaust. It was a Nathan Rapoport production.

I had been struck by how few people were in the park. When I asked the ranger on duty about this, he spoke up for his domain.

"You should see it here on a holiday. Fourth of July, when the big ships sail by into the harbor, this place jumps."

I could picture it. Fathers and sons playing catch, barbecues heating up, teenagers reveling. America at play, at its unbuttoned best. But what did it do to the meaning of the memorial to be in the middle of such pleasures and excitements? The aesthetic merit of this memorial aside — agitprop, in my opinion, grandiose — the trip had taught me something important about all memorials. The setting counts. A nation's spirit always seeps into the meaning of a memorial placed within its borders. Liberty Park is likely an extreme example, but any Holocaust memorial set in America would have some Americana in its system. Which is why I had to go to Europe. That was where the destinies of the Ripps and the Kahans had played out.

There were many memorials to choose from. My web search brought up a map showing close to a thousand. The icons were clustered in Central Europe, where guilt was thick on the ground, and that was where I would start my trip. I packed a laptop and a camera, checked that my passport was valid, and got going.

Could a stone pillar or a bronze plaque or whatever else constitutes a memorial cause events that took place more than seven decades ago to appear vivid? I would soon find out.

* * *

My first stop was Germany, where a recent survey found more than two hundred Holocaust memorials. This suggests how strenuously Germans have been trying to come to terms with their past. But it also suggests how hard it is to get that business right.

Berlin's Memorial to the Murdered Jews of Europe is the most visited Holocaust memorial in the country, included in just about every tourist itinerary, and that was where I would go first. But I wanted to get some local comment before having a look. Michael Cullen was the editor of Jewish Voices from Germany, an English-language monthly, and a mutual friend had told me he had been active in the debates surrounding the memorial's construction. When we met at a café near his apartment in the Charlottenburg district, it didn't take much to get Cullen talking.

"It took fifteen years to get an agreement to move forward. Why? No blueprint to follow. A country honoring those it killed. Not the usual thing, is it?

"Then the location. Some wanted it in the camps, the scene of the crime. Many Jews insisted on the city center, so Berliners would have to face their past every day. Everyone had an opinion. One camp survivor insisted it shouldn't be where he would pass it on the way to work each morning.

"A big problem was the design. One proposal was a field of yellow flowers in the shape of a Star of David like what the Nazis forced Jews to wear on their clothing. The Jews as victims. Several proposals were like that. There was a lot of shouting against that approach. As I said, everyone had an opinion."

Cullen had the world-weary manner of a veteran who had made it back from the trenches. He had fought the good fight and had his war stories as testimony to his efforts, but the battle was behind him.

I asked him if he was okay with the memorial as it was finally designed.

"Let's say I've come to terms with it. It's good that it's so abstract that it can have different meanings for different people. The Holocaust was a lot of things, not just one thing."

* * *

A soft rain was falling when I arrived at the memorial, which accentuated its bleak unwelcoming aspect. There was no marked entrance and no obvious path through the 2,711 granite steles that were arranged in a rectangular grid the area of a New York City square block. Some of the steles were three feet high, others ranged up to fifteen feet. None had inscriptions, only a blankness where I expected something. No Holocaust victims were named, none of their stories were told. There was an oppressive air of sadness and loss, but you had to work to pick out the doomsday vibe of the Holocaust.

I could see the outer edge of any row I was in, but upon reaching it I had no sense that I had arrived at a destination. There was always another row to walk down, and another row after that. As I passed some of the taller steles, the surrounding neighborhood disappeared from view, disorienting me. Nothing to do but keep walking till I had enough of walking. Forty-five minutes later I still was uncertain how the memorial was a statement about the Holocaust.

I was mulling this over when, rounding a corner, I almost bumped into a couple wearing cutoff jeans and Go-Gator T-shirts, the guy photographing the girl, who was grinning clownishly as she peeked out from behind one of the steles. My instinct was to tell them, "Hey, this is a memorial, show some respect. Stop fooling around."

But I stayed silent. I had just a minute before admitted my uncertainty about the memorial's meaning. How could I say this couple's fooling around was over the line when there was no clear line? If they wanted to treat the memorial as a playground, there was nothing I could point to in order to show they had gotten it wrong.

Jews in the millions murdered. Families shattered, traditions desecrated. Shouldn't a Holocaust memorial acknowledge these facts in a way that can be easily grasped? Do you have to decipher a Holocaust memorial before its meaning is clear? But what I knew about the pedigree of the memorial suggested that the uncertainty I felt was intended.

Peter Eisenman, who designed the memorial, has declared his affinity for deconstruction, a mode of thinking that spread, seemingly unstoppably, through academic circles in the 1970s. Deconstruction holds that there is no single truth. It uses terms like "the free play of meanings" and argues that coherence is a false ideal. Eisenman built ambiguity, which deconstruction insists on, into the steles of his Berlin memorial.

I descended the steps to the information center. It had not been in Eisenman's original design but was added later at the insistence of the local organizing commission as an antidote to the memorial's puzzling austerity. A young woman checked my rain poncho and wished me a perfunctory good day, and I took that as a sign that I was back in the workaday world. Here there was none of the mystery of the blank steles of the memorial above ground. Indeed, one question that had troubled me there was answered directly. The Holocaust, which the memorial suggested was a tragedy beyond any earthly specifics, was given names and faces.

There were photographs of Jews being rounded up by the Gestapo, Jews at forced labor, Jews in the death camps. The biographies of some of the victims were spelled out. A Lithuanian businessman and his four sons all killed in Treblinka. A Polish farmer and his family of seven buried in a mass grave near Lodz. Particular lives, various nationalities. But it struck me that the exhibit actually argued against individual destiny. All the stories led to the same ending — it made it seem that the way it was, was the way it had to be.

This depiction of the Nazi killing machine at work was depressing. I was left in awe of the implacable power of evil. All of which made me appreciate, as I hadn't before, the ambiguous story told by the memorial. At least it didn't just repeat history as it had been written by the Nazis.

Walking through the exhibit, I found it impossible not to think of the members of the Ripp family who had been killed. Viewed from one angle, their fate seemed controlled by the same iron logic that seemed to control the fate of the Jews shown in the photographs. For them also, the sequence of events that led to their murder was locked into place. But was the way that it was really the way it had to be? Over the years, I had toyed with that question, but I resisted considering it at length. What was the point of worrying about what was over and done long ago? But now in the information center, that question nagged at me again. Was there a particular missed turn that had sent Alexandre and the other members of the Ripp family down the path to their death while the Kahan family had found a detour to safety?

(Continues...)

---

Excerpted from Hell's Traces by Victor Ripp. Copyright © 2017 Victor Ripp. Excerpted by permission of Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

---

Videos