Grit, Noise, and Revolution: The Birth of Detroit Rock 'n' Roll

by David A. Carson

Overview

". . . a great blow-by-blow account of an exciting and still-legendary scene."
—-Marshall Crenshaw

From the early days of John Lee Hooker to the heyday of Motown and beyond, Detroit has enjoyed a long reputation as one of the crucibles of American pop music. In Grit, Noise, and Revolution, David Carson turns the spotlight on those hard-rocking, long-haired musicians-influenced by Detroit's R&B heritage-who ultimately helped change the face of rock 'n' roll.

Carson tells the story of some of the great garage-inspired, blue-collar Motor City rock 'n' roll bands that exemplified the Detroit rock sound: The MC5, Iggy Pop and the Stooges, Mitch Ryder and the Detroit Wheels, SRC, the Bob Seger System, Ted Nugent and the Amboy Dukes, and Grand Funk Railroad.

An indispensable guide for rock aficionados, Grit, Noise, and Revolution features stories of these groundbreaking groups and is the first book to survey Detroit music of the 1960s and 70s-a pivotal era in rock music history.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780472031900
Publisher:	University of Michigan Press
Publication date:	06/19/2006
Edition description:	New Edition
Pages:	416
Sales rank:	1,091,815
Product dimensions:	6.12(w) x 9.25(h) x 1.30(d)

About the Author

David Carson is a Royal Oak native, former Michigan disc jockey, and the author of Rockin' Down the Dial: The Detroit Sound of Radio. He lives in Nashville, Tennessee.

Read an Excerpt

Grit, Noise, & Revolution

the birth of detroit rock 'n' roll

---

By david a. carson

University of Michigan Press

Copyright © 2005 David A. Carson
All right reserved.
ISBN: 978-0-472-03190-0

---

Chapter One

Boogie and the Beat

Before there was rock or R & B, there were blues. In Detroit the blues were personified in the music of John Lee Hooker, an artist whose "electrified sound" would influence future generations of rock and R & B musicians.

He arrived in Detroit by Greyhound bus in 1943, stepping down in Black Bottom, a section of town that rural French farmers had named for its rich soil. The bustling sixty-six-block residential area, east of downtown, running from Brush Street east to Elmwood, and Larned north to Gratiot, was home to most of the city's African American population, at the time numbering more than 150,000. Like Hooker, many of its residents had migrated from the South seeking steady employment in the city's automotive and steel plants. Adjacent to Black Bottom on the northwest was the mainly black-owned business and entertainment district known as Paradise Valley, a five-square-block neighborhood bordered by Vernor on the north, Gratiot on the south, Beaubien on the west, and Hastings on the east. In its prime during the 1930s, the Valley attracted huge mostly white audiences to see the country's top black entertainers. Duke Ellington, Cab Calloway, and Bessie Smith, among others, performed in lavish shows staged at upscale nightclubs such as the B&C, Club Plantation, and the Chocolate Bar.

Although the race riots in the summer of 1943 signaled a decline, the Valley was still ripe with blues and jazz clubs in the mid to late forties. There was El Sino on St. Antoine, Sportree's Music Bar on Hastings, Club Three 666 and the 606 Horseshoe Bar on East Adams, and just down the street (replacing Club Plantation), Club Congo in the Norwood Hotel. Henry's Swing Club was nearby at 1700 Orleans.

As Hastings Street, Black Bottom's main artery, continued north beyond the Valley, there was also plenty of action at spots such as the Ace Bar, the Three Star Bar, the Cozy Corner, and Sunnie Wilson's Forest Club, a huge entertainment center featuring a roller rink and bowling alley, located at Forest and Hastings. To the west was the Cotton Club at Livingstone and St. Antoine, and the Parrot Lounge on E. Canfield. Along with the bars, there were poolrooms, ten-cent movie houses, plenty of after-hours joints, and jam sessions everywhere. Later, Hooker recalled Hastings Street, as being "rough, wide open," a place where "anything goes."

John Lee Hooker was born just outside of Clarksdale, Mississippi, on August 22, 1917 (though other dates are often cited), the fourth of eleven children. His parents, William Hooker and Minnie Ramsey, were sharecroppers. His father was also a Baptist minister. As a child John Lee sang in the church choir, but spirituals took a back seat to blues music after his sister Alice began dating a guitar player named Tony Hollins, who gave John Lee his first guitar, an old Silvertone model.

Following a divorce, John Lee's mother married William Moore, a farmer highly regarded as a regional blues performer. Moore encouraged his stepson and allowed him access to his record collection, which included blues artists such as Charlie Patton, Blind Lemon, Blind Blake, and LeRoy Carr. Their recordings influenced Hooker, but it was the guitar style of his stepfather that made the greatest impression on the young musician.

At fourteen, wishing to escape farm life, Hooker left home to live with aunts in Memphis, and then Cincinnati. Eventually, he decided to hone his musical skills in the Motor City, believing there would be less competition there than in Chicago, which had already developed a big blues scene. He found a place at a rooming house called Mom's and worked for a while at the Ford River Rouge Plant, before becoming an orderly at Receiving Hospital. From there, he took a daytime janitor's position at the Dodge Main Plant, while at night he played guitar and sang at various house parties, and occasionally had the opportunity to sit in with a club band.

By 1948, after several tough years, Hooker, now married with children and working a day shift at Comco Steel, was still playing mainly for tips at "rent parties," but he was also performing more in nightspots such as Lee's Sensation Bar on Owen, and Club Carribee on East Jefferson. Most often he could be found playing on the small stage at the Apex Bar on Oakland Avenue. It was there, according to Hooker, that a black record store owner named Elmer Barbee heard him playing and invited him down to his shop at 609 Lafayette, which housed a small recording studio in the rear. After cutting a few demos, Barbee introduced Hooker to Bernie Besman, the owner of a minor local label called Sensation Records, and co-owner, along with John Kaplan, of Pan American Music Distributors. As he listened to Hooker's demo tape, Besman was intrigued. He quickly signed him to a personal management contract.

Shortly after the signing, Hooker closed a Saturday night show at the Broadway Capitol Theater, promoted by Bill Randle, a white jazz deejay at WJLB. Randle recalls that Hooker, like a lot of local musicians, used to come up to the WJLB studios on the thirty-first floor of the David Broadrick Tower downtown and "just hang around" during his late night show (the Interracial Goodwill Hour). "Then on Saturday nights we used to do a live jam session remote from Club Sudan (formerly Club Congo), from Midnight to 4 and John Lee would come down and play. The place was always packed." Randle says the concert at the Broadway Capitol Theater in 1948 was Hooker's first major appearance. "It was a very eclectic show and there was a largely white audience. We had Milt Jackson on the bill as well as Tate Huston and Bill De Arango, one of the greatest jazz guitarists of all time. We also had Willie Anderson, a terrific jazz pianist, and then John Lee Hooker. At the end of the show everybody was out on the stage for a really wild jam session." Bernie Besman later described witnessing Hooker's performance at the concert as "one of the most profound experiences" of his life.

Besman arranged for Hooker to record at a session originally scheduled for band leader and pianist Todd Rhodes at United Sound Systems, Detroit's premier recording studio. Located in a two-story brownstone at 5840 Second Avenue, United Sound had been the first independent studio in the country when it opened in 1933. Owner Jimmy Siracuse, a former cinematographer working in the Detroit automotive ad business, had originally built the facility as a full-service film, recording, and design operation. "There was a huge recording studio in the back on the main floor in an area that had first been constructed for film production," recalls Detroit musician and broadcaster Jack Surrell. "It had one of the, if not the only studio in town that could accommodate a full orchestra. There was also a smaller studio in the front." Surrell, an accomplished pianist, had done sessions in both studios and says that Jimmy Siracuse and his son Joe ran the whole thing. "We didn't do too many takes back then. We'd talk about what we wanted to accomplish, and then Jimmy or Joe would run into the control booth and do the actual recording. It was quite a professional operation though, compared to some other little backroom studios around town." Surrell had several releases on the Sensation label in the late forties, including "Detroit Boogie."

At the time, John Lee Hooker was usually accompanied in clubs by pianist James Watkins and drummer Curtis Foster, but on this occasion he was asked to record alone. His technique, learned from his stepfather Will Moore back in Mississippi, made extensive use of "hammering" one-chord guitar figures, bare-fingered on the strings of an old Stella acoustic guitar with an electric pickup, while stomping his feet to the beat. He had a nonrhyming singing style that was at times out of rhythm but nonetheless effective.

The initial United session on September 3, 1948, produced Hooker's first smash hit, "Boogie Chillen," which he had also written about his early days on Hastings Street. "The thing come into me. It was just a funky old lick I found. I heard Will Moore do a song like that when I was a little kid down South, but he didn't call it 'Boogie Chillen.' But it had that beat," recounted the musician in a later interview. It was a driving but hesitant beat, with Hooker adding a stark, chilling vocal, and staccato guitar breaks, followed by the cry: "Boogie chillen!" According to the singer-composer, he had taken "boogie" from piano-driven boogie-woogie, and gave it an entirely new feel.

Bernie Besman leased the song to Modern Records, a Los Angeles label owned and operated by the Bihari brothers. Released on November 3, 1948, the recording reached number 1 on the R & B charts at the start of 1949. "When 'Boogie Chillen' first come out, everywhere you went you would hear that, 'cause that was a new beat to the blues then," said Hooker. "Sally Mae" was featured on the flip side. As part of his recording deal, Hooker received a thousand dollars up front and the promise of a cent and a half royalty.

He quickly followed up with a string of top 10 R & B hits on Modern, such as "Hoogie Boogie," "Hobo Blues," "Queen Bee," and "Crawling King Snake." His biggest was 1951's "I'm In the Mood," where over a slow, bluesy beat, Hooker's voice could be heard in an echo effect, singing the memorable line: "Nighttime is the right time ... be with the one you love." The haunting sound had been created by Joe Siracuse using the new technique of overdubbing Hooker's vocal onto the master. The record spent four weeks at number 1. All these early classics were cut at United Sound in Detroit.

John Lee Hooker's music was in such demand that he released records for other labels using pseudonyms, such as Johnny Lee, John Lee Booker, Texas Slim, Delta John, and the Boogie Man. "[Elmer] Barbee would come to me late at night and say, 'Man, I got a deal! This record company want to do something with you. I know you under contract, but we can change your name,'" claimed Hooker. As he felt that he wasn't getting paid in a timely fashion by Modern Records, John Lee saw no problem with the clandestine midnight sessions that paid him cash "right on the spot."

By mid-1952, as a result of serious health problems, as well as business differences with Modern Records, Bernie Besman relocated to Southern California. Hooker began working directly with Modern. Joe Bihari took over as producer, flying in from L.A. for the sessions at United Sound, still engineered by Joe Siracuse.

When Hooker's contract with Modern expired at the end of 1954, he signed a recording deal with Vee-Jay Records of Chicago, but he continued to live in Detroit and perform locally with his own Detroit-based band, the Boogie Ramblers, which he had formed in 1953. "I spent all my best years right there in Detroit," Hooker told Living Blues magazine. "Yeah, they was real good to me."

"Few musicians have been able to figure out what John is playing, let alone copy it," said writer Dave Sax. Hooker had no imitators, and because of this, Detroit never developed its own identifiable blues style the way Chicago had. There were certainly talented blues artists in the Motor City, such as guitar and harmonica players Eddie Burns and Eddie Kirkland and pianists Boogie Woogie Red and Detroit Piano Fats, all of whom played with Hooker early on. There were also Little Sonny, Baby Boy Warren, Calvin Frazier, and Washboard Willie. But none were able to break out nationally. In other parts of the country "Detroit blues" meant John Lee Hooker.

Many of these lesser-known blues artists made recordings in small backroom studios, such as Elmer Barbee's. There was also Sam's Record Shop at 3419 Hastings Street, run by Sam Taylor, and "Joe's Record Shop" nearby at 3530 Hastings. Owner Joe Battle, who liked to call himself Joe Von Battle, would lease many of his masters out to various national and regional labels. He would issue some locally on his own JVB label. Von Battle's biggest sellers, however, were the sermons of Reverend C. L. Franklin, recorded at the New Bethel Baptist Church at Linwood and West Pennsylvania, where the pastor's three daughters Carolyn, Erma, and Aretha Franklin sang in the choir each Sunday.

Independent of Bernie Besman, Hooker had also cut some tracks for Von Battle that were leased to Chicago's Chess Records.

One memorable Von Battle recording on JVB was a raucous piano-driven boogie-woogie track called "LeRoy Sent Me," by a Detroit outfit known as Joe Brown and His Kool Kats. It had been written in 1949 for LeRoy White, Detroit's first black deejay, whose nightly show, Rockin' with LeRoy (successor to the Goodwill Hour), aired R & B from ten to midnight over WJLB: "Rock, rock, rockin' with LeRoy all night long," wailed the shouting chorus in a song that was a harbinger of things to come.

In the early fifties, vocal groups were the hottest craze in rhythm and blues. In Detroit, the Royals were street corner harmonizers from Dunbar High School. Members included Charles Sutton (lead and tenor), Henry Booth (tenor), Lawson Smith (baritone), and Sonny Woods (bass). Alonzo Tucker was their arranger and sometime guitarist.

In November 1951, the Royals entered an amateur contest at the renowned Paradise Theater located at 3711 Woodward Avenue. Johnny Otis, at the time a band leader as well as a talent scout for King and Federal Records, the big Cincinnati-based independent labels, was in the audience. In a later interview, he recalled that although the show was "supposed to have been an hour, it turned into three hours because there was so much talent in Detroit." Later, Otis put a call through to his bosses, telling them: "I sure found some people here." His Detroit talent picks that night were Jackie Wilson, Little Willie John, and the Royals, but he remembers seeing "others with equal potential during that evening." When the King/Federal people arrived to audition Otis's talent discoveries, they passed on both Wilson and John, signing only the Royals, because, according to Otis, "they were a vocal group" at a time when, "suddenly—it was all vocal groups."

The label chose a song Otis had written expressly for Jackie Wilson to sing at the audition, called "Every Beat of My Heart," for the Royals' first release in April 1952. The record wasn't much of a hit outside of Detroit, and the group's other releases failed to reach the charts. When Lawson Smith left to enter the service, he was replaced by a singer working in more of a gospel and country blues tradition. The singer's name was Hank Ballard.

Hank Ballard was born in Detroit in 1927, the son of a truck driver. At age seven, after the deaths of his parents, he was sent down to Bessemer, Alabama, to live with relatives. Country and gospel music had a profound influence on Ballard, but he also enjoyed listening to big band belters such as Jimmy Rushing and Al Hibbler as well as the smooth style of Nat "King" Cole.

At age fifteen, he ran away and returned to Detroit. At the time, the city was teeming with aspiring rhythm and blues groups. According to Ballard, "You couldn't walk down the street without hearing groups that sounded like they should have a hit record." He tried to sing in the style of high-voiced Clyde McPhatter, at the time the wildly popular lead vocalist with Billy Ward's Dominos, but after observing how difficult it was for solo artists to get signed by record companies, Ballard realized he needed to be part of a vocal group.

At the Ford plant where he worked, Hank would sing the harmonies of popular songs to the rhythm of the assembly line. Sonny Woods of the Royals also worked there, and, after hearing Hank, invited him to sing in several contests at the Paradise Theater. When Lawson Smith left for the army, Hank Ballard agreed to take his place, although he felt that the Royals were "singing for the older crowd," that they were "stuck in the Orioles mold." He told the other group members that they needed to "modernize" their sound. "It took me some time to convince these traditional rhythm and blues types to get with a modern, urban sound," Hank recalled.

(Continues...)

---

Excerpted from Grit, Noise, & Revolution by david a. carson Copyright © 2005 by David A. Carson . Excerpted by permission of University of Michigan Press. All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.

---

Table of Contents

Contents

Preface....................ix
Acknowledgments....................xi
1. Boogie and the Beat....................1
2. Fame and Fortune....................11
3. Freewheelin' in the Motor City....................18
4. Motown and Other Sounds....................33
5. The Village Is on Fire....................57
6. On to the Hideout....................68
7. So You Wanna Be a Rock 'n' Roll Star?....................75
8. A Whole Lotta Soul, a Whole Lotta Funk....................90
9. Birth of the Noise....................98
10. A Mythical Figure....................107
11. Summer in the City....................120
12. Hippies and Head Shops....................127
13. Hits and Misses....................131
14. Something in the Air....................142
15. Seger on the Rise....................150
16. A Night at the Grande....................153
17. Enter the Stooges....................158
18. On the Front Lines with the MC5....................164
19. Total Assault: Kickin' Out the Jams....................174
20. Up against the Wall and Beyond....................183
21. The Detroit Pop Festival....................195
22. Voices of the Counterculture....................202
23. I Wanna Be Your Dog....................215
24. "Uncle Russ"....................218
25. First Train out of Town....................223
26. 1970....................228
27. The Big Bust....................260
Epilogue....................278
Notes....................297
Bibliography....................331
Selected Album Discography....................345
Index....................349

Editorial Reviews

"I've never read or seen a more complete history about the Motor City/Michigan music scene than what Carson has written. He has done a remarkable job telling the story of all the singers, artists, and musicians that had a part in the making of one of the greatest musical cities in the world."
—Johnny "Bee" Badanjek, legendary drummer for Mitch Ryder and the Detroit Wheels, the Rockets, and the Romantics

Johnny "Bee" Badanjek

"There are few happy endings here, but a great blow-by-blow account of an exciting and still-legendary scene."
—Marshall Crenshaw

Marshall Crenshaw

"Talk about popular music in the 1960s and most people immediately think of Motown. . . . Carson celebrates that other Detroit Sound in his new book Grit, Noise and Revolution: The Birth of Detroit Rock 'n' Roll. . . . Carson's book sets things right with a story that will [give readers] an appreciation for a Detroit rock scene in the 1960s that was as vital as any in the world. [It also] includes an excellent gallery of photos that capture the shifting look of popular music from the early 50s to 1972, Detroit style."
—Livonia Observer

Livonia Observer - Hugh Gallagher

"Carson chronicles Detroit pop music between World War II and Motown Records' early-1970s removal to L.A., delineating loud, intense Motor City acts from John Lee Hooker to Bob Seger and drawing lines of influence between black and white acts. . . . More great pop than one city should produce, and Carson's got the skinny on it all."
—Booklist

Booklist - Mike Tribby

" . . . Grit hits the meat of the matter . . . . If you are a fan of the Detroit scene from the late '60s or early '70s, you won't regret grabbing this one."
—bookgasm.com

bookgasm.com - Bruce Grossman

"[A] groundbreaking and impeccably researched treatise on Detroit's storied, influential, revered and in some instances overblown rawk prototype, a timeline with stops at 1940s blues, 1950s RB, and 1960s Motown and garage. . . . Carson digs deeper into the story than just the bands, exploring the role of the audience, radio stations, managers, promoters, producers, and the vortex from which it all seemed to spiral out of control; the Grande Ballroom. . . . It's tempting to describe Grit, Noise, and Revolution as definitive, but there's simply nothing else out there to compare it to in terms of breadth, cheap voyeuristic thrills and, above all, readability."
—Clark Paull, I-94 BAR

I-94 BAR - Clark Paull

" . . . a comprehensive account of the legendary Detroit scene . . . . Carson's work fills a hole in the literature that has existed for far too long, and is highly recommended to anyone concerned with the cultural politics of the 1960s, and the history of rock music more generally."
—The Gazette, Newsletter of the Mid-Atlantic Popular/American Culture Association

The Gazette - Dr. Douglas Sherry

". . .an impressive book and definitely a great resource for students of Detroit rock history. . . . The heritage of Detroit music is well-represented here, Grit, Noise, and Revolution documents a legacy of bold, powerful Detroit music, a tradition that has yet to die."
—Drastic Plastic Press

Drastic-Plastic.com - Craig Campbell

". . . the first book to chronicle the Detroit music scene during that city's glory years from 1965-1972. . . . A variety of factors, ranging from changing musical tastes to skyrocketing ticket prices eventually spelled the end of Detroit's vibrant rock scene, making this engrossing time capsule of the way things were all the more noteworthy."
—Tierney Smith, Discoveries for Record CD Collectors (Dubuque, Iowa)

Discoveries for Record & CD Collectors - Tierney Smith

". . . Carson brings a wealth of knowledge and detail to his account of Michigan rock. . . . [F]or those who want a record of what happened, and especially for those who believe that Motown was the be-all and end-all of Detroit music, Carson recounts a valuable story."
—Steve Waksman, Michigan Historical Review

Michigan Historical Review - Steve Waksman

"Even if you know little or nothing about Detroit rock roll to begin with, you'll come away from Grit, Noise and Revolution awestruck at the stories provided by Carson and with a new appreciation for the musical and artistic legacy created during the period covered by the book. For those hungering for more info on this vital and still-influential era, Carson has provided an extensive bibliography for the academically inclined to pursue as well as a select discography for those who would rather experience this great music firsthand.Any true fan of rock roll should add Grit, Noise and Revolution to their music bookshelf 'cause dammit, man, it just doesn't rock any harder than this! Kudos to David Carson for his exhaustive, entertaining history of one of the Reverend's favorite times and places in rock roll."
—Rev. Keith A. Gordon, Alt. Culture Guide

Alt. Culture Guide - Rev Keith A. Gordon

"Carson reveals in rich and engaging detail exactly why the Motor City is world renowned as a musical mecca."
—Dennis "Machine Gun" Thompson, MC5

Dennis Thompson

". . .[a] definitive history of Detroit's early rock scene . . . . Carson spends considerable space chronicling the rise of legendary bands such as the MC5, Iggy and Alice Cooper, and he recounts the downfalls . . . "
—Detroit Free Press

Detroit Free Press - Bill McGraw

"What the book does magnificently is provide the context and show the connections within a music scene filled with powerful DJs, club owners, label heads and—oh, yeah—an abundance of badass visionary musicians."
—Metro Times Detroit

Metro Times Detroit - Brian J. Bowe

Considering all the unconventional rock artists who hail from the Detroit area-the MC5, Iggy Pop, Alice Cooper-it's ironic that this history is so bland. Still, Carson (Rockin' Down the Dial: The Detroit Sound of Radio) raises the Detroit region's profile as one of the most fertile musical centers in the country, chronicling the city's glory years, from the emergence of blues legend John Lee Hooker in the late 1940s to the early 1970s, when drugs, booze, and changing tastes brought things to a close. While Motown fans will feel cheated by the slim coverage of Detroit's most famous record label, readers will still need a scorecard to keep track of the dozens of bands and artists born in and near the Motor City; its influence has continued in recent years with the rise of the White Stripes, Eminem, and Kid Rock. With so many well-known acts, this book will have appeal outside of the Detroit region. Recommended for the Detroit region and other larger pop music collections.-Lloyd Jansen, Stockton-San Joaquin Cty. P.L., CA Copyright 2005 Reed Business Information.

Library Journal