Like the man says, the more things change, the more they stay the same. It's been close to a quarter-century since
Lou Barlow became the uncrowned king of the lo-fi revolution thanks to his early recordings with
Sebadoh, but while in 2009 he has a number of gifted musicians on hand to help him, and a professional recording studio at his disposal,
Goodnight Unknown shows his songwriting style and musical direction has remained remarkably consistent with the passage of time. Producer
Andrew Murdock, whose previous clients include
Avenged Sevenfold and
Godsmack, helped
Barlow out with these recordings, and
Dale Crover (of
the Melvins),
Sebastian Steinberg (ex-
Soul Coughing), and
Lisa Germano all sat in for the sessions, but outside of the higher fidelity, most of the tunes on
Goodnight Unknown could have been recorded in
Barlow's living room on a four-track, given the simple, uncluttered approach he takes to these songs. This might suggest
Barlow is stuck in a rut, but that's not the way
Goodnight Unknown sounds; instead, these 14 songs are the work of a man who has mastered his defining style, and with this album he's showing he knows how to write a moody but expressive
pop song and bring it to rich emotional life on tape just as eloquently as ever. In some respects this is a long way from
Sebadoh's early days;
"The Right" suggests the grooves of his
Folk Implosion work,
"Sharing" and the title tune rock out simply but decisively (
Crover hardly brings the same level of heaviness to his drumming here that defines his work with
the Melvins, but he reveals a sure rhythmic confidence in his performances), and
"Don't Apologize" is a compelling run-through the heart of darkness. But most of
Goodnight Unknown is built around
Barlow's barely accompanied acoustic guitar and his tales of romantic disappointment, and he hasn't run out of heartfelt variations on his favorite theme; Lord knows what will happen if
Barlow's muse ever starts understanding girls, but their mystery is still a source of lyrical inspiration to him, and he not only hasn't run out of things to say about the subject, he has plenty of good music that suits his heartache.
Lou Barlow is still the poet laureate of hiss and heartbreak, and although the hiss is missing on
Goodnight Unknown, that's the only defining quality he's lost with the passage of time. ~ Mark Deming
