Gender, Psychology, and Justice: The Mental Health of Women and Girls in the Legal System

by Corinne Datchi, Julie R Ancis

Overview

Reveals how gender intersects with race, class, and sexual orientation in ways that impact the legal status and well-being of women and girls in the justice system.

Women and girls’ contact with the justice system is often influenced by gender-related assumptions and stereotypes. The justice practices of the past 40 years have been largely based on conceptual principles and assumptions—including personal theories about gender—more than scientific evidence about what works to address the specific needs of women and girls in the justice system. Because of this, women and girls have limited access to equitable justice and are increasingly caught up in outdated and harmful practices, including the net of the criminal justice system.

Gender, Psychology, and Justice uses psychological research to examine the experiences of women and girls involved in the justice system. Their experiences, from initial contact with justice and court officials, demonstrate how gender intersects with race, class, and sexual orientation to impact legal status and well-being. The volume also explains the role psychology can play in shaping legal policy, ranging from the areas of corrections to family court and drug court.

Gender, Psychology, and Justice provides a critical analysis of girls’ and women’s experiences in the justice system. It reveals the practical implications of training and interventions grounded in psychological research, and suggests new principles for working with women and girls in legal settings.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9781479832019
Publisher:	New York University Press
Publication date:	11/21/2023
Series:	Psychology and Crime , #6
Sold by:	Barnes & Noble
Format:	eBook
Pages:	326
File size:	750 KB

About the Author

Corinne C. Datchi is Assistant Professor in the Professional Psychology and Family Therapy Department at Seton Hall University, and a board certified, licensed psychologist in independent private practice. Gender and the family are the focus of her research and practice with criminal justice populations.
Julie R. Ancis is Associate Vice President for Institute Diversity at the Georgia Institute of Technology. A Fellow of the American Psychological Association, she has published extensively in the area of multicultural competence and mental health. She is Past Chair of the Society of Counseling Psychology’s Section for the Advancement of Women.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgments vii

Introduction: Gender, Psychology, and Justice Corinne C. Datchi Julie R. Ancis 1

Part I Women and Girls in Various Justice Settings

1 Women and Family Court: Abuse and Contested Custody Julie R. Ancis 23

2 Women, Domestic Violence, and the Criminal Justice System: Traumatic Pathways Lenore E. A. Walker Carlye B. Conte 48

3 Women, Sex Trafficking, and the Justice System: From Victimization to Restoration Thema Bryant-Davis Tyonna Adams Anthea Gray 75

4 Women and Adult Drug Treatment Courts: Surveillance, Social Conformity, and the Exercise of Agency Corinne C. Datchi 101

5 Women, Incarceration, and Reentry: The Revolving Door of Prisons Elizabeth A. Lilliott Elise M. Trott Nicole C. Kellett Amy E. Green Cathleen E. Willging 127

6 Girls in Juvenile Detention Facilities: Zones of Abandonment Kendra R. Brewster Kathleen M. Cumiskey 151

Part II Specific Populations of Justice-Involved Women and Girls

7 Transwomen in the Criminal Justice System: Sans Justice Alexis Forbes Kevin L. Nadal 177

8 Lesbian, Bisexual, Questioning, Gender-Nonconforming, and Transgender (LBQ/GNCT) Girls in the Juvenile Justice System: Using an Intersectional Lens to Develop Gender-Responsive Programming Angela Irvine Aisha Canfield Jessica Roa 200

9 Women, Poverty, and the Criminal Justice System: Cyclical Linkages Erica G. Rojas Laura Smith Randolph M. Scott-McLaughlin II 224

10 Undocumented Mexican Women in the U.S. Justice System: Immigration, Illegality, and Law Enforcement Anna Ochoa O'Leary 254

11 Women and the Criminal Justice System: A Psychology of Men Perspective Jonathan Schwartz Jennifer Bahrman 280

Conclusion: Gender, Psychology, and Justice: The Case for Systemic Change Julie R. Ancis Corinne C. Datchi 302

About the Contributors 311

Index 315

Editorial Reviews

"Datchi and Ancis have put together a one of a kind, comprehensive, and compelling read. Their book is both scholarly and meaningful. A hallmark of a profound book is that it brings the reader into it, and takes the reader on a journey of discovery. It informs the reader through content knowledge and real experiences that illustrate the challenges in relation to gender and the 'injustice' system. Mental health practitioners, lawyers, judges, and anyone interested in the links between and among the justice system and the intersectionality of gender, race, sexual orientation, and class, in the service of promoting social justice, will find the book an indispensable resource."

Nicholas Ladany

"After reading Julie Ancis and Corinne Datchis groundbreaking book Gender, Psychology and Justice, one realizes that many diverse women and girls, who are disproportionately in poverty and have experienced gender violence, are re-traumatized by laws, justice policies, and the social biases of legal officials of the U.S. Justice System. Victim-blaming and mistreatment of women and girls are unfortunately prevalent in our country, which has led President Obama to say that 'you can judge a nation, and how successful it will be, based on how it treats its women and its girls.' This book is an eye opener for men on the many injustices facing diverse women and girls and serves as a clarion call that social justice work on behalf of diverse women and girls is a moral and ethical mandate."

Kevin Cokley

"This book promotes understanding about the biases and challenges faced by women and girls in our justice system. In promoting such understanding and recommending salient reforms."

New York Law Journal

This book promotes understanding about the biases and challenges faced by women and girls in our justice system. In promoting such understanding and recommending salient reforms.”- New York Law Journal

"Datchi and Ancis have put together a one of a kind, comprehensive, and compelling read. Their book is both scholarly and meaningful. A hallmark of a profound book is that it brings the reader into it, and takes the reader on a journey of discovery. It informs the reader through content knowledge and real experiences that illustrate the challenges in relation to gender and the 'injustice' system. Mental health practitioners, lawyers, judges, and anyone interested in the links between and among the justice system and the intersectionality of gender, race, sexual orientation, and class, in the service of promoting social justice, will find the book an indispensable resource."-Nicholas Ladany,Dean, School of Leadership and Education Sciences, University of San Diego

"After reading Julie Ancis’ and Corinne Datchi’s groundbreaking book Gender, Psychology and Justice , one realizes that many diverse women and girls, who are disproportionately in poverty and have experienced gender violence, are re-traumatized by laws, justice policies, and the social biases of legal officials of the U.S. Justice System. Victim-blaming and mistreatment of women and girls are unfortunately prevalent in our country, which has led President Obama to say that 'you can judge a nation, and how successful it will be, based on how it treats its women and its girls.' This book is an eye opener for men on the many injustices facing diverse women and girls and serves as a clarion call that social justice work on behalf of diverse women and girls is a moral and ethical mandate." -Kevin Cokley,Director of the Institute for Urban Policy Research, University of Texas at Austin

From the Publisher