The idyllic village on the jacket of The Corpse in the Cellar by Kel Richards gives no suggestion of horrors to come. Setting his novel in 1933, Richards boldly uses C. S. Lewis and his brother, Warnie, as leading characters, combining them with the fictional Tom Morris, pupil of Lewis and narrator of the tale, as the three set out on a walking holiday. Accidents (the destruction of Lewis’s wallet in a fire) and the cumbersome procedures in the nearest village bank are almost cosmic to the modern reader, brain-washed as we are by the convenience and speed of modern systems. When the seemingly impossible murder occurs in the bank vault, Lewis’s powerful brain cuts through the fog of conflicting evidence. Richards’s book is also a strong Christian polemic: Lewis is busy trying to convert his intelligent pupil Tom to follow his own route from atheism to belief. I’m not sure, however, of the readership that is being aimed at: both agnostic lovers of Agatha Christie and believing Lewis fans will be tempted to skip the religious dialectic, and some readers might find the over-use of adverbs to qualify speech – sagely, confidently, heartily, etc. – off-putting. They weaken a strong basic plot. If The Corpse in the Cellar is a meander down a pre-war country lane, False Tongues by Kate Charles is like negotiating a complex modern motorway junction at speed. This is Charles’s sixth novel about Callie Anson, a curare in a busy central-London parish. Anson is persuaded to attend a reunion at her Cambridge theological college, leaving behind her new love, PC Mark Lombardi, currently embroiled in trying to solve the murder of Sebastian Frost, a tall, beautiful teenager found bleeding to death on Paddington Green, in Anson’s parish. We’re not deep in the online world, ruled here by Facebook. Cyber-bullying flourishes: reality is masked, horrifyingly warped, and very difficult for the police to pin down. "A suicide note via Facebook . . . why not? This was the Facebook generation: they lived their lives on the Internet." Charles tells a riveting tale, and helps the reader follow her complex web of more than 50 vividly drawn characters, plus the interaction of the dual setting, plus a group of very different social worlds, by giving a full cast list. Since it’s the first Callie Anson story I’ve read (there are six in the series). I found the list essential, but I greatly enjoyed this modern ecclesiastical mystery, and look forward to reading earlier volumes that are currently being republished by Marylebone House.
A bloodstained version of the world of Barbara Pym.
More than one mystery intersect in another adventure from Kate Charles. She’s an experienced expat author living in England exploring the mysteries of faith, love, family and violence in her books. In this fourth Callie Anson novel, it is her circle of acquaintances who are involved in a variety of actions and decisions, old and new, that drive the story and its sometimes complicated relationships. Callie travels from London to Cambridge to attend a reunion of her classmates, graduates from theological seminary. She will have to confront both the scenes and at least one man with whom she was deeply emotionally involved during her time there: a man who unceremoniously dumped her in a shameful and hurtful way. Around her are arrayed classmates and older theologians who help Callie’s travel to emotional understanding. Meanwhile, the new love of her life, a London policeman who functions as a Family Liaison officer, becomes involved in the murder of a young man in Paddington Square. As intriguing as the convoluted relationships among the religious that are examined in this story are, the murder of a school boy with only a single tenuous link to the other plot, leads to examinations of working and absent parents, stresses in modern society and pressures of various kinds on law enforcement. Together, the development of these separate plot lines present a realistic picture of modern life. These ideas and more are nicely embodied in the characters brought to the page by the author. The messages are many, perhaps too many, but the author’s delicate touch leaves them to the reader to accept or pass over. None is presented in such a way that one feels manipulated or into forced acceptance.Charles nicely places the action in several consummately English locations. No generics here. She’s been called a most English of writers and compared favorably to Agatha Christie in these aspects. All in all an excellent, calm and deliberate story that can leave a reader with considerable food for thought.
If you enjoy James Runcie's Grantchester series, you will love Kate Charles' compelling, updated, clerical mystery. An addictive read from one of my very favorite writers.’
Thoroughly entertaining, even to those of no religious bent.
More than one mystery intersect in another adventure from Kate Charles. She's an experienced expat author living in England exploring the mysteries of faith, love, family and violence in her books. In this fourth Callie Anson novel, it is her circle of acquaintances who are involved in a variety of actions and decisions, old and new, that drive the story and its sometimes complicated relationships....Callie travels from London to Cambridge to attend a reunion of her classmates, graduates from theological seminary. She will have to confront both the scenes and at least one man with whom she was deeply emotionally involved during her time there: a man who unceremoniously dumped her in a shameful and hurtful way. Around her are arrayed classmates and older theologians who help Callie's travel to emotional understanding. Meanwhile, the new love of her life, a London policeman who functions as a Family Liaison officer, becomes involved in the murder of a young man in Paddington Square. As intriguing as the convoluted relationships among the religious that are examined in this story are, the murder of a school boy with only a single tenuous link to the other plot, leads to examinations of working and absent parents, stresses in modern society and pressures of various kinds on law enforcement. Together, the development of these separate plot lines present a realistic picture of modern life....These ideas and more are nicely embodied in the characters brought to the page by the author. The messages are many, perhaps too many, but the author's delicate touch leaves them to the reader to accept or pass over. None is presented in such a way that one feels manipulated or into forced acceptance....Charles nicely places the action in several consummately English locations. No generics here. She's been called a most English of writers and compared favorably to Agatha Christie in these aspects. All in all an excellent, calm and deliberate story that can leave a reader with considerable food for thought.
A nice mystery with a important message for today of cyber bullying and its effects on our youth. Two very independent women that were former classmates meet at their theology school reunion and the mystery takes off from there. I found the book has a good flow, the two stories interact well and it is very enjoyable to read. Well Done. I highly recommend False Tongues as a very enjoyable read. Thank you for the advance reading copy.
"Revisiting the past was a bad idea. Callie Anson knew that..." With an opening like this we know already that Callie will indeed revisit her past, and that we are ready to go along for the ride. It is an opening that does not disappoint....Callie is just one week back at her old theological college at Cambridge. How much can happen in a week filled with sessions designed to help the newly turned-out ministers, like Callie, navigate the rough waters of the real world? As it turns out, a great deal....At times it's almost as if this novel is two different books combined into oneyet by the end, author Kate Charles ties up everything in both storylines. While Callie visits her old school, her somewhat ambivalent fiancé Detective Marco Lombardi, remains in London investigating the murder of fifteen-year-old Sebastian Frost. The two major storylines are so distinct that it was hard for me to define the connections that pulled them into a cohesive whole, since the only thing tying them to each other is the relationship between Marco and Callie. Without giving anything away, I will say that it is through a brief conversation with Callie that Marco is able to uncover a key piece of evidence in his murder case....Major themes of the story are cyber bullying, the complications modern families face on a daily basis, and the wide range of issues facing twenty-first century couples. Charles hits on other themes too, including alienation, misunderstandings, teen angst, the effects of bullying, an inability to make commitments, and the exacting results of malicious gossip....One of the greatest strengths of False Tongues is the development of the many disparate characters, while a major weakness is the sheer size of that cast of characters. In the first twenty pages, we meet no fewer than nine characters, plus the murder victim and an emotional Italian family of six. Twenty more pages give us eight additional characters. At some point I began to wonder: "Which of these people will be hanging around to play major roles, and which will quietly fade away? Surely all of them can't remain..." Surprisingly, most of them do....And what a cast of characters! From London to Cambridge, Callie and Marco find themselves dealing with old friends and loversand a brand new murder. False Tongues is the fourth book in Kate Charles's Callie Anson Mystery Series. It was only after I finished the book that I realized that Callie, the main character, never deals directly with the murder case. She spends the week at that reunion of old classmates in Cambridge, where a few mysteries do rear their heads, but it is Marco who must help solve the murder of nerdy teenager Sebastian back in London....The size of the cast nearly did me in as a reader. I wanted to keep reading this book, because the characters were interesting, the stories were engaging, and the writing was excellent. But it was almost too much work to keep everybody straight. I'm glad I persevered. False Tongues is a worthwhile read, both for fans of mysteries and of stories of interpersonal relationships. It was fun to watch Callie loosen up a bit as her week at Cambridge progressed. She probably grew up more in that week than in the previous year.
Story Circle Book Reviews
Easter Monday should be a quiet day for clergy and lay alike. But when the missing-persons report called in by doctors Miranda and Richard Frost matches up with the body of a 15-year-old boy found stabbed in Paddington Green, DI Neville Stewart doesn’t get the Bank Holiday. He pulls in Family Liaison Officer Mark Lombardi to work with the family and to fend off a bulldog reporter, Lilith Noone, who is seeking to break open a big story. The investigators, both police and press, are put off the trail by the reluctance of the victim’s privileged friends to tell the whole truth. Meanwhile, Callie Anson, curate in the Paddington parish and Lombardi’s fiancée, is attending a retreat and reunion in Cambridge of her class of deacons. There, rumors and gossip obscure the truth about the real relationships among both faculty and the reuning deacons. As in others in this series, Callie is not actively involved in the case, but she does unwittingly provide Lombardi with the key to its solution during a telephone conversation. The story works as both a well-crafted mystery and a novel of human relationships.