This recording, released in 1965, was named one of the 50 greatest of all time by the BBC some years ago and is available in various low-priced reissues. Its fame is partly due to extramusical factors; it features the 20-year-old cellist
Jacqueline du Pré, well before her tragic illness, and the conductor is
John Barbirolli, who was actually heard in the first performance of
Elgar's
Cello Concerto in E minor, Op. 85, and who is still probably the greatest
Elgar conductor of all. The album also marked something of a breakthrough for mezzo-soprano
Janet Baker, but the triumphs are purely musical as well.
Du Pré's performance has a magical youthful quality that is rare; many recordings by 20-year-olds may be technically superior but feel as though the performers have been drilled within an inch of their lives. The blooming, rather somber lyricism of
du Pré in
Elgar's Adagio movement must have been what
Elgar had in mind for this wartime work, and
Baker's sound in the
Sea Pictures is likewise distinctive. This is a work for contralto sung here by a mezzo-soprano. Other singers have done so, but it wasn't a common thing in the 1960s, and
Baker's reading is a standout, with bits of soprano flash illuminating the singer's close reading of the texts. This 2004 reissue from
Warner Classics/
Parlophone has an additional draw in the form of a festive,
Cockaigne Overture, Op. 40, from
Barbirolli and the
London Symphony Orchestra. A classic recording that continues to draw new generations. ~ James Manheim