OCTOBER 2022 - AudioFile
Narrator Tovah Ott delicately balances grief and magic in this eerie fantasy audiobook. Twelve-year-old Eden can’t escape the numbness that has been consuming her since her mother’s death. When she visits Safina Island to connect with her unexplored heritage, Eden follows a black cat into the woods and becomes trapped in Everdark, a world of endless night inhabited by restless spirits. Ott voices Eden with a soft wistfulness that grows into strength as Eden finds power within herself. Ott doesn’t hold back on bringing the darkness and horror of this story into her vocal performance. Her creepy tone will wring genuine chills from listeners as Eden learns of the tragedies that lay the foundations for the nightmare world of Everdark and struggles to escape before it’s too late. N.M. © AudioFile 2022, Portland, Maine
Publishers Weekly
10/03/2022
Following her botanist mother’s death, 12-year-old Eden Gardener travels with her father to her mother’s birthplace, which her mom mysteriously left following a grave injury at age 12. On Safina Island, off the coast of Georgia, Eden meets her extended maternal relations—descendants of the formerly enslaved inhabitants who’ve owned the north side of the island since the Civil War’s end—as they prepare to celebrate the anniversary of purchasing the land. She encounters, too, a bevy of frightening creatures in her mother’s childhood sketchbook, including a hauntingly beautiful witch in a spirit world known as Everdark. After passing into Everdark through a dark portal, Eden learns that the Witch of Everdark wants to take Eden as her own daughter; it will require all of Eden’s wits, and the magic she inherited from her mother, to escape. Strong (Just South of Home) sets an impeccable scene, imbuing Safina Island with a turbulent history and fully fleshed culture that stands in stark relief to Everdark’s opulence. Though interactions can have an RPG feel, undercutting character connection, Strong portrays the island’s mythos, and Everdark’s extraordinary dangers, to bone-chilling perfection. Ages: 8–12. Agent: Patrice Caldwell, New Leaf Literary & Media. (Sept.)
Anne Ursu
"A deliciously creepy and suspenseful Southern Gothic story that engages with the consequences of the country’s monstrous past while also beautifully centering the story of a girl frozen by grief at the loss of her mother. What makes this book truly ingenious is the way Karen Strong shows that the salve to both these societal and personal wounds can be found in the same way: finding joy and love in community and a deep connection to family past and present. This is a phenomenal book."
Dhonielle Clayton
"A haunting enchantment, Eden's Everdark transports readers into a spirit world full of spectacular adventure, heart-wrenching truths, and a constellation of characters to be remembered long after the story is finished. A can't be missed novel working in the beautiful folkloric tradition of Black American storytellers."
Samira Ahmed
"Eden's Everdark hums with magic and mysterya novel brimming with unsettling secrets, quiet beauty, and fierce love. Karen Strong creates an enchanted world that reminds the reader that their light can shine, even in the darkest, most desperate hours. A sensitive and lyrical portrait about the complexities of grief, the power of hope, and of finding ourselves wherever we are."
Hanna Alkaf
"Karen Strong uses her particular brand of magic to weave a spine-tingling tale of ghosts and grief, and how we can be haunted by both in equal measure. A beautiful story that embraces the darkness, but always makes room for those glimmering threads of hope and love to shine through."
Kelly Barnhill
Karen Strong has performed a magic trick, weaving a story built on heartbreak and hope, tender intimacy and the sweep of history, sinister ghosts and debilitating grief, and tied it to a place that felt so real I could taste the salt in the air, and feel the gentle touch of familial love. I felt a profound connection to Eden - her sorrow and pain, her deep need to belong, her deep and suffocating fear, and her profound courage. She is a clear-eyed and indomitable heroine. Eden's Everdark is an intricate tale, both terrifying and heartbreaking, and it asks an important question: how do we free ourselves from the ghosts of the past? And how do we prevent the evil of others poisoning ourselves? This novel is stunning, moving, and marvelously strange. I loved every page.
Hayley Chewins
"Gorgeous, lush, and sparkling with strangeness, Eden's Everdark is a heartfelt, thrilling story about what it means to reckon with the past—and fight for the future."
Heather Kassner
"As haunting as it is heartfelt, Eden’s Everdark is a fantastically eerie tale of bound spirits and eternal night, rooted in family and blooming with love. Strong’s writing absolutely shines with magic."
School Library Journal
08/26/2022
Gr 3–6—After Eden's mother dies, she travels with her father to Safina Island, GA, to meet her mother's family. Eden's ancestors were enslaved people from the Civil War era who cultivated cotton and sugar cane. After the war, the Gardner family stayed for generations, but Eden and her family have never visited. Eden's mother left the island when she was Eden's age, 12, never to return, though she carried forth the gardening gene, becoming a botanist and professor. When Eden finds her mother's childhood sketchbooks containing island flowers, marshland plants, and animals, she is intrigued. One sketchbook looks to be a dark mirror of Safina Island, with a monster-like dog, a black cat lurking, and stormy oceans and dark skies. Children drawn have deep indigo skin with tiny silver stars, and mouths frozen into eternal screams. A woman drawn is the "Witch of Everdark," and when Aunt Susanna tells Eden her mother created this spirit world from her dreams, Eden feels pulled to discover the truth behind her own nightmares. Eden finds a path into Everdark and, upon entering, realizes there is no way out, and that the witch wishes to claim her spirit. With stunningly descriptive prose, Strong has created two worlds, both Safina Island and the spirit world that entraps Eden. Eden must face her grief bravely, while holding tight to her family and their roots. VERDICT Darkly suspenseful; both readers of fantasy and those looking for a creepy, ghostly tale will find much to keep them rooted in this electric novel.—Michele Shaw
OCTOBER 2022 - AudioFile
Narrator Tovah Ott delicately balances grief and magic in this eerie fantasy audiobook. Twelve-year-old Eden can’t escape the numbness that has been consuming her since her mother’s death. When she visits Safina Island to connect with her unexplored heritage, Eden follows a black cat into the woods and becomes trapped in Everdark, a world of endless night inhabited by restless spirits. Ott voices Eden with a soft wistfulness that grows into strength as Eden finds power within herself. Ott doesn’t hold back on bringing the darkness and horror of this story into her vocal performance. Her creepy tone will wring genuine chills from listeners as Eden learns of the tragedies that lay the foundations for the nightmare world of Everdark and struggles to escape before it’s too late. N.M. © AudioFile 2022, Portland, Maine
Kirkus Reviews
2022-06-08
A grieving girl accidentally slips into an alternate magical world inhabited by eerie, mystical creatures from her dead mother’s sketchbook.
Twelve-year-old Eden is mourning the loss of her mother when she and her father make their first visit to Safina Island, off the coast of Georgia, to meet her maternal relatives. Eden’s connection to them is tenuous, mostly consisting of the birthday cards containing pressed flowers sent by her great-aunt; Eden’s mother left the island when she was 12 following a bad accident, and she never wanted to return. Eden and her dad are going to participate in the annual celebration honoring the family’s purchase of half the island after they received their freedom from slavery. While staying in her mother’s childhood room, Eden looks through old boxes in the closet and finds, among the many sketchbooks containing nature drawings, one filled with creepy and terrifying images of a land called Everdark. Eden starts traveling there in her dreams until one day, while following a black cat around the island, she enters a portal, becomes trapped in this world, and must use her own hidden magic to find a way out. The complex narrative portrays multifaceted characters as it weaves together history, magic, and grief. Readers will enjoy the strong pacing along with learning about the island’s well-described mythology and root magic. Most characters are Black.
A textured, suspenseful story that traverses an island’s timeline and a family’s heritage. (Paranormal. 9-13)