Ecumenical Ecclesiology: Unity, Diversity and Otherness in a Fragmented World

by Gesa Elsbeth Thiessen (Editor)

Overview

This is a rich collection of fifteen articles by European, North American and Asian theologians who are concerned with the concept, life, unity and future of the church. It offers a wealth of broad perspectives on ecclesiology by scholars from Catholic, Protestant and Orthodox backgrounds.

The first section, 'Perspectives on Ecumenical Ecclesiology', comprises reflections on postmodern ecclesiologies as well as on the development and problems concerning ecumenical methods and models of unity. The second section, 'Communion Ecclesiology and Otherness', provides some pertinent deliberations on how an ecclesiology of communion can integrate otherness. In particular, Zizioulas' communion ecclesiology is critically examined, the possibility for a retrieval of Eucharistic theology between Catholics and Orthodox is put forward, and Tillard's communion ecclesiology is appraised as offering resources for innerdenominational otherness.

The final section, 'Ecclesiology in Global Contexts', considers critically the possibility of evangelical ecclesiology as an answer to ethnic impaired Christian community. The role of the (Catholic) Church and its values in Europe and vis-à-vis the European Constitution is examined. The Church of Nigeria's Constitutional Revision (2005) and its ecclesial- ecumenical implications comes into focus, and three notable concepts of unity, as developed by three Indian scholars, S.K. George, John Sadiq and Karem David, are evaluated.

Finally, the Japanese diaspora in the States is appraised as a place where a particular Japanese Christian vision could emerge through the "internationalist ecclesiology" developed by Japanese Christian missionaries.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780567009135
Publisher:	Bloomsbury Academic
Publication date:	11/15/2009
Series:	Ecclesiological Investigations , #5
Pages:	272
Product dimensions:	6.40(w) x 9.30(h) x 1.00(d)

About the Author

Gesa E. Thiessen lectured for many years at Milltown Institute of Theology and Philosophy, Dublin. An Adjunct Assistant Professor at the School of Religion at Trinity College Dublin, Visiting Scholar at Sarum College, Salisbury, and a Research Fellow at the University of the Free State, Bloemfontein, South Africa, she has published widely on theology and the arts and on ecumenical ecclesiology. She is a non-stipendiary minister in the Lutheran Church in Ireland.

Table of Contents

Acknowledgements viii

Contributors ix

Preface Linda Hogan xii

Introduction Gesa E. Thiessen 1

Part I Perspectives on Contemporary Ecumenical Ecclesiology

1 Driving the Haywain: Were Stands the Church 'Catholic' Today? Gerard Mannion 13

2 Seeking Unity: Reflecting on Methods in Contemporary Ecumenical Dialogue Gesa E. Thiessen 35

3 The Struggle for an Organic, Conciliar and Diverse Church: Models of Church Unity in Earlier Stages of the Ecumenical Dialogue Miriam Haar 49

4 Church and Covenant: Theological Resources for Divided Denominations Edwin C. van Driel 62

5 Comprehensive Vision: The Ecumenical Potential of a Lost Ideal Andrew Pierce 76

6 Integrity, Alternative Aggressions, and Impaired Communion Wendy Dackson 88

Part II Communion Ecclesiology and Otherness

7 The Church and the 'Other': Questions of Ecclesial and Divine Communion Paul M. Collins 101

8 Being Church: A Critique of Zizioulas' Communion Ecclesiology Travis E. Ables 115

9 Retrieving Eucharistic Ecclesiology Radu Bordeianu 128

10 Communion Ecclesiology and Ecumenical Experience: Resources for Inner-Denominational Otherness Brian P. Flanagan 143

11 Evangelical Ecclesiology as an Answer to Ethnic Impaired Christian Community? An Inquiry into the Theology of Miroslav Volf Eddy Van der Borght 161

Part III Ecclesiology in Global Contexts

12 On Being a European Catholic: The Politics of Inclusion Encounters an Ecclesiology of Exclusion Julie Clague 175

13 Instruments of Faith and Unity in Canon Law: The Church of Nigeria Constitutional Revision of 2005 Evan F. Kuehn 190

14 Sacral Authority and Pastoral Ministry: A Shamanistic Inculturation of the Protestant Church in Korea Hak Joon Lee 205

15 Confucianism, Internationalism, Patriotism and Protestantism: The Ecclesiological Matrix of Japanese Christian Activists in Japan and the US Diaspora Madeline Duntley 223

Index 239

Editorial Reviews

'Ecumenical Ecclesiology" is a useful and insightful guide through the complex contemporary debate on how the church could be one without losing its many faces and particularities. It offers a rich variety of contributions from diverse denominational and cultural backgrounds committed to the re-evaluation of older models of ecumenism while sharing their desire for the church's celebration, witness and service in the world not to be disrupted by divisions.' - Ivana Noble, Protestant Theological Faculty, Charles University of Prague, Czech Republic--Sanford Lakoff

'Guided by an editor at once theologically critical and ecumenically compassionate, these authors follow her lead in bringing historically informed theory to bear on the contemporary contexts and practices of ecclesial bodies. The volume delivers what the best of such collections achieve: a range of provocative questions sure to incite further academic inquiry with confidence and newfound ecumenical purpose.' - Bruce T. Morrill, Boston College, Chestnut Hill, Massachusetts, USA--Sanford Lakoff

'Those with a serious interest in theology, but who think that ecumenism has become a boring and interminable debate among clerics, will be pleasantly surprised by this volume. It shows that internal divisions, especially in the Roman Catholic Church and the Anglican Communion, have now reached the stage of ecumenical problems in their own right, though in both cases the resources are there to tackle them. New light is shed on 'communion' ecclesiology in Orthodoxy and the sharp disagreements to which it gives rise. Running through these more classical themes are the tensions caused by gender, ethnicity and inculturation, with striking examples from Korea and Japan. Starting from the core notion of the ecumenical, the book exemplifies its relevance to a wide range of contemporary issues.' - John D'Arcy May, Irish School of Ecumenics, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland--Sanford Lakoff

"The idea for the volume was kicked around at various international conferences on religion during the years leading up to the centenary of the 1910 World Missionary Conference, which is recognized as the birth of the modern ecumenical movement. Theologians from Europe and the US offer perspectives on contemporary ecumenical ecclesiology, communion ecclesiology and otherness, and ecclesiology in global contexts. Among their topics are reflecting on methods in contemporary ecumenical dialogues, theological resources for divided denominations, questions of ecclesial and divine communion, retrieving eucharistic ecclesiology, instruments of faith and unity in canon law in the Church of Nigeria constitutional revision of 2005, and the ecclesiological matrix of Japanese Christian activists in Japan and the US diaspora." -Eithne O'Leyne, BOOK NEWS, Inc.

From the Publisher