Publishers Weekly
Scottish policeman Hamish Macbeth tries to avoid a dreaded promotion while solving assorted crimes and crossing swords with pretty reporter Elspeth Grant in his episodic 18th outing (after 2002's Death of a Celebrity). Macbeth knows something is amiss in the village of Stoyre, because the residents have become even more religious and closemouthed than usual. Discovering and rooting out the cause will cost him dearly. All Macbeth's talents are on display as he performs a heroic rescue, outwits some crooks and meets violence with violence. For all his nonchalance, the laconic Macbeth does his best to protect his people and preserve his way of life among them. Beaton fans will rejoice. (Feb. 18) Copyright 2002 Cahners Business Information.
School Library Journal
Adult/High School-The village of Lochdubh, in the Scottish Highlands, seems to be peaceful enough, but Hamish Macbeth, the local policeman, keeps uncovering criminal activity almost by accident. There is something fishy going on over in the isolated village of Stoyre, too. With a clear-eyed understanding of people and an uncommon degree of common sense, Macbeth solves these riddles almost effortlessly. His real problem is not crime, but avoiding promotion; each time he catches a wrongdoer or saves a child, he comes to the attention of his superiors, who feel his talents are wasted in Lochdubh. But his life there, with its cottage police station, his dog, his hens and sheep, and an attractive new journalist on hand, suits Macbeth very well. And though the villagers think him lazy and unambitious, they don't want to see him go, either, as they would lose their police station if he were transferred. The trademark charm of the series-quirky humor, eccentric characters, and dark overtones-is in full swing here; fans will be well pleased, and readers new to Lochdubh can enjoy this as a stand-alone volume.-Christine C. Menefee, Fairfax County Public Library, VA Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information.
Kirkus Reviews
Once again, Hamish Macbeth, sole guardian of the law in Scotland’s Lochdubh village and environs, is fighting the specter of promotion as he tangles—successfully, he hopes, but not too dramatically—with a series of complex puzzles in his bailiwick. Helped at times by local reporter Elspeth Grant, Hamish deals with domestic intrigue, fake insurance claims, and skullduggery at a nursing home in nearby Braikie village. The most worrisome item on his agenda, however, takes him to the village of Stoyre. The entire town seems to be gripped by an outbreak of unholy religious fervor, its church packed with grimly unresponsive worshippers. Is this ferocious newfound piety connected to the bombing of the house owned by Major Jennings, widely regarded by the locals as godless? Hamish is determined to find out. A couple of visits to Stoyre, its cliffs, and the surrounding sea, provide him with some far-fetched possibilities—none of them as bizarre as the actual events behind the town’s sudden and remarkable religious conversion. Beaton (Death of a Celebrity, 2001, etc.) rarely disappoints, and his 19th adventure finds Hamish in top form, with intriguing puzzles to solve, the possibility of a new romance, and ever more inventive ways of avoiding a promotion to higher rank and transfer from his beloved Lochdubh.
