Christian Science on Trial: Religious Healing in America

by Rennie B. Schoepflin

Overview

In Christian Science on Trial, historian Rennie B. Schoepflin shows how Christian Science healing became a viable alternative to medicine at the end of the nineteenth century. Christian Scientists did not simply evangelize for their religious beliefs; they engaged in a healing business that offered a therapeutic alternative to many patients for whom medicine had proven unsatisfactory. Tracing the evolution of Christian Science during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, Christian Science on Trial illuminates the movement's struggle for existence against the efforts of organized American medicine to curtail its activities.

Physicians exhibited an anxiety and tenacity to trivialize and control Christian Scientists which indicates a lack of confidence among the turn-of-the-century medical profession about who controlled American health care. The limited authority of the medical community becomes even clearer through Schoepflin's examination of the pitched battles fought by physicians and Christian Scientists in America's courtrooms and legislative halls over the legality of Christian Science healing. While the issues of medical licensing, the meaning of medical practice, and the supposed right of Americans to therapeutic choice dominated early debates, later confrontations saw the legal issues shift to matters of contagious disease, public safety, and children's rights. Throughout, Christian Scientists revealed their ambiguous status as medical practitioners and religious healers.

The 1920s witnessed an unsteady truce between American medicine and Christian Science. The ambivalence of many Americans about the practice of religious healing persisted, however. In Christian Science on Trial we gain a helpful historical context for understanding late–twentieth-century public debates over children's rights, parental responsibility, and the authority of modern medicine.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9780801877674
Publisher:	Johns Hopkins University Press
Publication date:	05/22/2003
Series:	Medicine, Science, and Religion in Historical Context
Sold by:	Barnes & Noble
Format:	eBook
Pages:	320
File size:	3 MB
Age Range:	18 Years

About the Author

Rennie B. Schoepflin, Ph.D., is an associate professor of history at La Sierra University in Riverside, California.

Table of Contents

Acknowlegdements
Introduction
Part I. The World of Christian Science Healers
Chapter 1. Mary Baker Eddy: Patient, Healer, Teacher
Chapter 2. Becoming a Practitioner and Teacher
Chapter 3. "Occasions for Hope": Patients and Practitioners
Chapter 4. Separating "True" Scientists from "Pseudo" Scientists
Part II. Christian Science Healers and the World
Chapter 5. Physicians Debate Christian Science
Chapter 6. Therapeutic Choice or Religious Liberty?
Chapter 7. Public Health and the Protection of Children
Chapter 8. Century of Promise, Then Peril
Appendix: Court Cases Involving Christian Science Practice
Notes
Archives Consulted
Bibliographical Essay
Index

What People are Saying About This

Norman Gevitz

This work is a significant contribution to our understanding of Christian Science. Where it breaks new ground is in its careful and dispassionate examination of the activities and challenges posed to ordinary Christian Science practitioners either during the lifetime of Mary Baker Eddy or thereafter.

— Norman Gevitz, Ph.D., Ohio University College of Osteopathic Medicine

Ronald L. Numbers

Provides a remarkably readable and balanced account of Christian Science healing, from the evolving theories of Mary Baker Eddy to the bedside and dispensary practices of her followers. Drawing on fresh sources, including courtroom testimony, Schoepflin for the first time opens the door to the workaday world of Christian Science practitioners.

— Ronald L. Numbers, Hilldale and William Coleman Professor, University of Wisconsin—Madison

From the Publisher

This work is a significant contribution to our understanding of Christian Science. Where it breaks new ground is in its careful and dispassionate examination of the activities and challenges posed to ordinary Christian Science practitioners either during the lifetime of Mary Baker Eddy or thereafter.
—Norman Gevitz, Ph.D., Ohio University College of Osteopathic Medicine

Provides a remarkably readable and balanced account of Christian Science healing, from the evolving theories of Mary Baker Eddy to the bedside and dispensary practices of her followers. Drawing on fresh sources, including courtroom testimony, Schoepflin for the first time opens the door to the workaday world of Christian Science practitioners.
—Ronald L. Numbers, Hilldale and William Coleman Professor, University of Wisconsin—Madison

Editorial Reviews

This well-documented volume, with its extremely well-written chronicle of the dialigue between Christian Science and modern medicine, makes the very interesting point that Christian Science's emphasis on spirituality as relevant for the cure of disease has finally 'come of age'.
—Research News and Opportunities in Science and Theology

A densely researched narrative of how this unusual, but enduring, form of medicine and religion developed. Through detailed accounts of testimony given in various legal proceedings, Schoepflin captures—often in their own words—the flavor of exchanges between Christian Scientists and those in the emerging establishment of allopathic medicine.
—New England Journal of Medicine

Clearly written and well argued, Schoepflin's excellent study moves beyond the prescriptive literature-focused and Eddy-centered scholarship to show what practitioners and their patients did and thought near the turn of the century.
—Choice

From the Publisher

Clearly written and well argued, Schoepflin's excellent study moves beyond the prescriptive literature-focused and Eddy-centered scholarship to show what practitioners and their patients did and thought near the turn of the century.

Choice

This well-documented volume, with its extremely well-written chronicle of the dialigue between Christian Science and modern medicine, makes the very interesting point that Christian Science's emphasis on spirituality as relevant for the cure of disease has finally 'come of age'.

Research News and Opportunities in Science and Theology

A densely researched narrative of how this unusual, but enduring, form of medicine and religion developed. Through detailed accounts of testimony given in various legal proceedings, Schoepflin captures—often in their own words—the flavor of exchanges between Christian Scientists and those in the emerging establishment of allopathic medicine.

New England Journal of Medicine