Publishers Weekly
★ 01/16/2023
Journalist Grant’s auspicious debut documents the pregnancy, birth, and initial postpartum experiences of three first-time mothers associated with Portland, Ore.’s Andaluz Waterbirth Center. The story of Jillian, a midwifery student turned birth center office manager, gives Grant the chance to chronicle the history of midwifery and portray a classic birth center experience (“The small building seemed to possess its own sense of time, as if it was a self-contained island floating separately from the rest of the world”), while sections profiling T’Nika, a Black nurse with aspirations of working in labor and delivery, include discussions of racial disparities in healthcare and what happens when circumstances require birth plans to be changed. The difficult pregnancy journey of Alison and her husband Steve touches on infertility, miscarriage, and the anxiety that medicalized birth experiences can produce. Throughout, Grant maintains a sense of intimacy while contextualizing each woman’s experiences with analysis of medical, legal, and cultural matters. Though most U.S. births happen in hospitals with obstetricians rather than midwives, Grant’s focus on one corner of maternity care allows her to show that even best-case scenarios have practical and emotional complexities. It’s an enlightening and accessible portrait of maternal healthcare in America. (Apr.)
Editor's Choice Porchlight
A much-needed perspective on childbirth.
Editor's Choice Porchlight
A much-needed perspective on childbirth.
Rainesford Stauffer
"A true feat of intimate, illuminating reporting, Birth is a profound examination of the deeply personal and structural forces that shape life-defining choices, experiences, dreams, and futures."
Atossa Araxia Abrahamian
Grant captures the inherent drama of giving birth with keen insights into the social and political forces that shape pregnancy and motherhood in America. A must-read for anyone who has been born!”
Evette Dionne
As we navigate an endless number of crises, Rebecca Grant’s thorough reporting about one such issue—reproductive health in all its facets—is lighting a pathway forward. Birth is a testament to Grant’s impeccable reporting and storytelling skills, pulling back the curtain on pregnancy in America while also pushing us to understand what the stakes are and what it will take to move forward. Birth is the kind of book that should be on the shelves of every obstetrician and gynecologist in a country where giving birth is as dangerous as it has ever been.
The New York Times Book Review
An important book . . . Grant is a good storyteller, subtle and compassionate.
Publisher’s Weekly (starred review)
An enlightening and accessible portrait of maternal healthcare in America.”
Kirkus Reviews
2023-02-23
A freelance journalist follows three women through pregnancy and childbirth at a Portland, Oregon, birth center.
Grant, who writes about reproductive rights, health, and justice, trains her investigative eye on maternal health, following her subjects from preconception through the postpartum period. The three mothers whose experiences anchor the book (a teacher, a nurse, and a birth center administrator) all chose to use a birth center, “a middle ground between the home and the hospital”—a choice made by only a few percent of American women each year. Birth centers generally don’t offer pharmacological pain relief and are the “domain” of a “small but mighty category of birth workers: midwives.” Grant’s subjects all had slightly different reasons for deciding to give birth outside of a hospital, but a few commonalities emerged: wanting to feel more “in control” during labor; a desire for a personalized, nurturing care environment; and a fear of the so-called “cascade of interventions,” the process by which, during a hospital birth, one obstetrical strategy, such as induction via Pitocin, can create situations requiring greater intervention, such as a C-section. The author skillfully interweaves the personal stories of her subjects and their families with a clear and engaging history of American childbirth practices over the years. The “modern midwifery system,” Grant writes, “can be traced back to the 1600s,” when women crossing the Atlantic “became midwives by necessity” when babies were born aboard ships. These de facto birth workers included both enslaved African women and the wives of White colonists. For the next several hundred years, midwifery retained a stronghold in Southern Black communities “due to a profound suspicion of white healthcare providers.” In the 20th century, a concerted effort on the part of the medical community moved birth out of the home and into the hospital—and, as the author notes, into the hands of largely male obstetricians.
A significant and compelling sociological investigation.
