American Soldiers: Ground Combat in the World Wars, Korea, and Vietnam

by Peter S. Kindsvatter Narrated by Joshua Swanson

Overview

Some warriors are drawn to the thrill of combat and find it the defining moment of their lives. Others fall victim to fear, exhaustion, impaired reasoning, and despair. This was certainly true for twentieth-century American ground troops. Whether embracing or being demoralized by war, these men risked their lives for causes larger than themselves with no promise of safe return.
Focusing on both soldiers and marines, Peter S. Kindsvatter draws on histories and memoirs, oral histories, psychological and sociological studies, and even fiction to show that their experiences remain fundamentally the same regardless of the enemy, terrain, training, or weaponry.



Kindsvatter gets inside the minds of American soldiers to reveal what motivated them to serve and how they were turned into soldiers. He re-creates the physical and emotional aspects of war to tell how fighting men dealt with danger and hardship, and he explores the roles of comradeship, leadership, and the sustaining beliefs in cause and country. He also illuminates soldiers' attitudes toward the enemy, toward the rear echelon, and toward the home front. And he tells why some broke down under fire while others excelled.



Here are the first tastes of battle, as when a green recruit reported that "for the first time I realized that the people over the ridge wanted to kill me," while another was befuddled by the unfamiliar sound of bullets whizzing overhead. Here are soldiers struggling to cope with war's stress by seeking solace from local women or simply smoking cigarettes. And here are tales of combat avoidance and fraggings not unique to Vietnam, of soldiers in Korea disgruntled over home-front indifference, and of the unique experiences of African American soldiers in the Jim Crow army.



By capturing the core "band of brothers" experience across several generations of warfare, Kindsvatter celebrates the American soldier while helping us to better understand war's lethal reality-and why soldiers persevere in the face of its horrors.

Editorial Reviews

American Historical Review

The best analysis of the nature of twentieth-century American combat available.

Journal of Military History

Kindsvatter's sweeping study is a tour de force.

H-Net Book Reviews

A masterful work.

Publishers Weekly

Command Historian at the U.S. Army Ordnance Center and Schools, Aberdeen Proving Ground, and a retired Army lieutenant colonel, Kindsvatter offers a phenomenological history of the hearts and minds of Army ground troops. Using a comprehensive spectrum of printed and unprinted sources from the subtitle's eras, Kindsvatter argues that soldiers of those times began with unreal images of war that allowed them to memorialize conflict by fictionalizing it. But despite military training, nothing could prepare them adequately for the modern battlefield with its harsh physical environment and extreme emotional stress; the typical progression was from initial confusion through relief at surviving to a period of peak effectiveness. Comradeship was important to that process. So was belief in "America" and "America's cause"; if those constructs vanished as ideals, nothing could replace them. The excitement of battle was also engaging. Besting the enemy was a challenge, allowing pride in a job well done. American soldiers, Kindsvatter finds, were neither too frightened nor too guilt-ridden to kill. Some were reluctant; some enjoyed it; few hesitated to pull their triggers when necessary. Eventually, however, for most combat veterans some event or emotion, usually accompanied by physical exhaustion, triggered loss of confidence or nervous collapse. While improved therapeutic methods made it possible to return many breakdown cases to the line, the best treatment was preventive: relief, temporary or permanent, from combat's alien environment. Much of this book is geared toward commanders or scholars looking to understand troops, but its fascinating, unsentimental arguments about the minds of soldiers are ripe for magazine adaptation. (Apr.) Copyright 2003 Reed Business Information.

Library Journal

While fighting under different circumstances, the typical American soldier from World War I to Vietnam experienced many of the same conditions of warfare and had similar reactions to the stresses of combat. Kindsvatter, a military historian, thoughtfully blends formal studies, veterans' memoirs, and war-inspired fiction to create a riveting documentary account of how soldiers respond as they progress from basic training to the battlefield. The author's analysis of how a small, close-knit unit could impose its own structure and norms, proving a more powerful motivator than the overarching "cause" or high-ranking officers, is especially interesting. A unique study recommended for public and academic libraries.-Elizabeth Morris, formerly with Otsego District P.L., Otsego, MI Copyright 2003 Cahners Business Information.

From the Publisher

"A tour de force of historical research and organization. Anyone interested in the behaviour of soldiers in battle should not ignore this benchmark study."—War in History

"This splendid book deserves serious consideration by all who hold evidence to be a prerequisite for opinion. Highly recommended."—Choice

"This is the kind of book we should encourage our soldiers to read, regardless of their years of service or combat experiences. It might just be better preparation than another trip to the National Training Center, and certainly better than another jaunt to the simulation center."—Army

"Kindsvatter thoughtfully blends formal studies, veterans’ memoirs, and war-inspired fiction to create a riveting documentary account of how soldiers respond as they progress from basic training to the battlefield. His analysis of how a small, close-knit unit could impose its own structure and norms, proving a more powerful motivator than the overarching ‘cause’ or high-ranking officers, is especially interesting. A unique study recommended for both public and academic libraries."—Library Journal

“The best analysis of the nature of twentieth-century American combat available.”—American Historical Review

“Kindsvatter’s sweeping study is a tour de force.”—Journal of Military History

“A masterful work.”—H-Net Book Reviews, H-War

“This illuminating work is about coping with fear at the foxhole level, and it powerfully conveys the psychology and military sociology of combat.”—Booklist

“Offers fascinating, unsentimental arguments about the minds of soldiers.”—Publishers Weekly

“A must read for every military leader.”—Peter Mansoor, author of The GI Offensive in Europe

“A superb, compelling analysis of twentieth-century American combat troops that never loses sight of the individual soldier. An important, meticulously documented contribution to our understanding of men-at-arms.”—Rick Atkinson, author of An Army at Dawn and The Long Gray Line

“Kindsvatter’s book is based firmly on the first-hand accounts of combat by American soldiers and Marines of the World Wars, Korea, and Vietnam. He is a sensitive, skillful mediator between those writers and us.”—Russell F. Weigley, author of The American Way of War

“A vivid portrayal of the savagery of war and its human dimensions.”—Michael D. Doubler, author of Closing with the Enemy: How GIs Fought the War in Europe, 1944–1945

MARCH 2011 - AudioFile

From boot training to combat, from chow to dysentery, author Peter Kindsvatter characterizes military life in the U.S. campaigns in WWI and II, Korea, and Vietnam. Into this mixture of vignettes go the thoughts and opinions of hundreds of combatants and correspondents. Narrator Joshua Swanson, when faced with an inexhaustible supply of brief quotes, pauses slightly before each to set them apart. But his addition of numerous hesitations between words makes his timing irritating for the listener. With little change in volume or emotion, Swanson also fails to add energy to the long disquisition. An excellent section at the end about the integration of blacks into the military in 1949 exposes the little-publicized racial conflicts and inequities that persisted long after the policy revision. J.A.H. © AudioFile 2011, Portland, Maine

Product Details

BN ID:	2940171298012
Publisher:	Tantor Audio
Publication date:	09/29/2010
Edition description:	Unabridged

Videos