Battered and broken from the debacle of
Don't Tell a Soul -- the album's failure to take off, followed by a disastrous tour supporting
Tom Petty & the Heartbreakers --
the Replacements were on their last legs when it came time for 1990's
All Shook Down, so worn down that the band ceased to exist for most intents and purposes.
Paul Westerberg even began recording the album as a solo project with
R.E.M. producer
Scott Litt, gradually turning it into the final
Replacements album. It may bear the band's name, but
All Shook Down never quite shakes the feeling of a solo album; above all, it's a writers album, with the focus placed entirely on the songs. To a certain extent, that was true of the ballad-heavy
Don't Tell a Soul, but that felt over-thought from its conception to execution, where there is a light touch to
All Shook Down, despite its plethora of guest musicians, including
John Cale's viola on "Sadly Beautiful,"
Heartbreaker Benmont Tench,
Terry Reid, and a duet with
Concrete Blonde's
Johnette Napolitano on "My Little Problem." Instead of aiming for a crossover hit,
Westerberg has now resigned himself to his status as an also-ran, even embracing it to some extent, so there are no sops to rock radio aside from "My Little Problem," whose bluster is jarring amidst the nimble folk-pop of the rest of the record.
All the acoustic guitars and skipping electric guitars push
All Shook Down far outside of the nascent Zeitgeist of grunge, or the sound of college rock in 1990; although
Westerberg would soon be back in the thick of things with his
Singles soundtrack -- sounding not too dissimilar to this record -- this finds him retreating from the rat race, reflecting on what he's been through.
All Shook Down is designed as a coda to
the Replacements' career, with
Westerberg looking back to "When It Began," pleading that "Someone Take the Wheel" and wrapping the whole thing up with "The Last," as self-aware a final song as
the Beatles' "The End."
Westerberg balances these self-referential slices of autobiography with his self-deprecation and heartbreak, but all this melancholy never feels heavy, not even when he dips into thick sorrow on "Sadly Beautiful" or the disembodied spookiness of "All Shook Down." There's a palpable sense of relief to
All Shook Down, as if
Westerberg realized he dodged a bullet by not becoming a true rock star. This lightness is appealing, especially as it surfaces in his writing, which is surely more considered than it was even on
Pleased to Meet Me, but it has an offhand quality, recalling the casual virtuosity of
Let It Be and
Tim -- it's the same guy, only older but maybe not too much wiser. And as it's true to that spirit,
All Shook Down winds up being a note-perfect denouement to
the Replacements' career, even if it's quiet and careful in a way the band never was at its peak. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine
