Against Political Equality: The Confucian Case

Against Political Equality: The Confucian Case

by Tongdong Bai
Against Political Equality: The Confucian Case

Against Political Equality: The Confucian Case

by Tongdong Bai

eBook

$22.49  $29.95 Save 25% Current price is $22.49, Original price is $29.95. You Save 25%.

Available on Compatible NOOK devices, the free NOOK App and in My Digital Library.
WANT A NOOK?  Explore Now

Related collections and offers


Overview

How a hybrid Confucian-engendered form of governance might solve today’s political problems

What might a viable political alternative to liberal democracy look like? In Against Political Equality, Tongdong Bai offers a possibility inspired by Confucian ideas.

Bai argues that domestic governance influenced by Confucianism can embrace the liberal aspects of democracy along with the democratic ideas of equal opportunities and governmental accountability to the people. But Confucianism would give more political decision-making power to those with the moral, practical, and intellectual capabilities of caring for the people. While most democratic thinkers still focus on strengthening equality to cure the ills of democracy, the proposed hybrid regime—made up of Confucian-inspired meritocratic characteristics combined with democratic elements and a quasi-liberal system of laws and rights—recognizes that egalitarian qualities sometimes conflict with good governance and the protection of liberties, and defends liberal aspects by restricting democratic ones. Bai applies his views to the international realm by supporting a hierarchical order based on how humane each state is toward its own and other peoples, and on the principle of international interventions whereby humane responsibilities override sovereignty.

Exploring the deficiencies posed by many liberal democracies, Against Political Equality presents a novel Confucian-engendered alternative for solving today’s political problems.


Product Details

ISBN-13: 9780691197463
Publisher: Princeton University Press
Publication date: 12/24/2019
Series: The Princeton-China Series , #2
Sold by: Barnes & Noble
Format: eBook
Pages: 344
File size: 567 KB

About the Author

Tongdong Bai is the Dongfang Professor of Philosophy at Fudan University in Shanghai and a Global Professor of Law at New York University School of Law. His books include China: The Political Philosophy of the Middle Kingdom.

Table of Contents

Preface xi

Acknowledgments xvii

Notes on Abbreviations, Key Terms, and Translations xxiii

1 Why Confucianism? Which Confucianism? 1

Has History Ended? Message from a Rising China 1

Which Confucianism? 3

The Philosophical Approach to Early Confucianism 5

Can Early Confucian Texts Be Read Philosophically? 9

How to Read Early Confucian Texts Philosophically 13

Early Confucianism as a Modern Political Philosophy 19

2 Confucianism on Political Legitimacy: For the People, of the People, but Not by the People 32

Confucian Equality 32

Confucian View of Political Legitimacy: Of the People, for the People… 34

… But Not by the People 43

The Confucian Middle Way: Between Equality and Hierarchy, and between Mobility and Stability 47

3 A Confucian Hybrid Regime as an Answer to Democratic Problems 52

Four Problems with Democracy 52

Nonmeritocratic Solutions and Their Fundamental Limit 58

The Confucian Hybrid Regime 67

4 The Superiority of the Confucian Hybrid Regime Defended 83

Internal Challenges to the Superiority of the Confucian Hybrid Regime 83

Incompatible with Liberal Democracy? 97

5 Compassion as the New Social Glue in the Society of Strangers 110

Introducing Humaneness and Compassion 110

Compassion as a Modern Virtue 114

The Cultivation of Compassion: From What Is Near to the "Transcendent" and the "Eternal" 125

The Hierarchy of Universal Care 133

Effectiveness of Compassion 135

6 Conflict in the Expansion of Care: The Private versus the Public 138

The Issue of the Private versus the Public 138

Early Confucians' Solutions 140

Han Fei Zi's Challenges 149

An Alternative Model in the Republic 154

Comparisons between the Two Models 159

A Confucian Criticism of the Contemporary Evasion of Virtue 165

A Confucian Argument for Gender Equality 171

7 Tian Xia: A Confucian Model of National Identity and International Relations 175

Patriotism Justified and Restrained 175

The Civilized and Barbaric Distinction and a Confucian World Order 180

Is Nation-State the Only Path to Modernity? 187

8 Humane Responsibility Overrides Sovereignty: A Confucian Theory of Just War 214

A City on a Hill: "Isolationism" as International Intervention 214

The Strength of the State and the Justice of War 217

The Self-Preservation of a Humane but Small State 220

The Duty to Protect by a Humane and Powerful State 223

A Mencian Theory of Just War 226

Compared with "Human Rights Override Sovereignty" and the Responsibility to Protect 230

Problems with Mencius's Theory 234

9 A Confucian Theory of Rights 240

Four Camps on the Compatibility between Confucianism and Liberal Democracy 240

Problems with Democratic Ideas as the Metaphysical Foundation of Liberal Democracy 245

A Revised Rawlsian Answer 249

Confucian Rights 257

An Example: Confucian Animal Rights 268

Compatibility between a State's Promotion of Virtue and Liberalism 278

Postscript 285

Environmental and Technological Challenges: A Synthetic Answer 285

Realizing the Confucian Alternatives? 288

References 291

Index 305

What People are Saying About This

From the Publisher

"Bai possesses a rare combination of expertise in contemporary political philosophy and classical textual exegesis. He occupies his own well-defined territory in the intellectual and ideological landscape of contemporary Chinese political thought, and Against Political Equality is a welcome and much-needed addition to the field."—Justin Tiwald, San Francisco State University

"In this rich, engaging, and important book, Bai’s perspective is that of a contemporary political philosopher influenced by both early Confucianism and Rawls. He thinks creatively about the challenges and needs of contemporary polities, and Against Political Equality is well-argued, provocative, and methodologically sound. This is a significant contribution to the emerging literature on Confucian political philosophy, and will attract much notice."—Stephen C. Angle, Wesleyan University

From the B&N Reads Blog

Customer Reviews