Reviewer: Alain Touwaide, PhD (Ronin Institute)
Description: The title only hints at the content of this book. It certainly is about abortion and contraception in Greece over almost 150 years. And, of course, it is about "medicine, sexuality, and popular culture" as the subtitle adds. However, the book goes further than that - it is a It is a multi-spectrum analysis that approaches the topic identified by the title from multiple angles, including demography, andrology, herbal medicine and practices, surgery, ethics, and religion, and the Pill.
Purpose: In the field of fertility decline studies (developed from the 1960s on), Greece was an exception, characterized by a different (later) timing than other countries. This book aims to reexamine this apparent exceptionalism. To do so, it provides the data that have never been introduced into the study of the Greek cases. Data have been collected from multiple sources, principally the personal [oral] histories of women and physicians, in addition to relevant scientific literature, official statistics, women's magazines, and the press. The author has amassed an unprecedented collection of primary data, which provide a solid foundation to her study.
Audience: The readership of this fine analysis will be as broad as its range of sources, from demographers to historians of medicine, including gynecologists and physicians, policy makers and also women. But it will also be of interest to students as a model of a cross-disciplinary study of a historical analysis of personal choices and practices.
Features: This 350+ page book systematically screens the process of fertility control (be it anticonceptional practices or abortion) from the raw demographic facts to the personal conviction and beliefs of the actors of the process (not only women, even though they are the major protagonists, but also physicians). Step by step, the author untangles the many components of pregnancy, from its impossibility (sterility, not only female but also male) to its rejection, including the undesirable pregnancy, and the social dimension of all such facts (particularly in a traditionally masculine society). The author delves a great deal into the abortifacient mechanism and substances (the emmenagogues), to further survey the structural/societal context of abortion, with the law, economics, personal ethics, and the church. She then moves to the practice and medicalization of abortion and contraception from the individual sexual life and regulation to surgical and medico-pharmaceutical practices.
Assessment: This is a masterpiece of fine analysis of a process all too often reduced to either charlatanism (the witches' herbs) or hyper-medicalization (the Pill). The author moves with great ability and sensitivity on a difficult, very personal field, avoiding both to protect herself behind dry statistics or to unmask and reveal the hidden life of women and men struggling with life (its making or its un-making). In a certain sense, this is a book about Greece entering the modern world, with the history of fertility control from the independence of the country and its official modern form, to the first studies of fertility. In this view, the book covers the transition of Greek society from a traditional mode to a medicalized society, with the consequences and modes of this transformation, including the control of fertility and the ways of doing it. It is thus much more than the history of fertility control; it is the analysis of a country that transitioned from a traditional way of life to the modern structure of societies, dominated by science and medicine, with the implications of this type of society. The control of fertility is, in a certain way, an observatory to approach the most recent evolution of a country.
Abortion and Contraception in Modern Greece is a work of enormous breadth and depth that will reward anyone interested in the biopolitical technologies, knowledges, and practices that helped shape the specific history of Greece’s population since the establishment of the modern Greek state.” (Eugenia Georges, Journal of Modern Greek Studies, Vol. 39 (2), October, 2021)
“This well-researched and erudite book is also a thoroughly engaging read. ... it will appeal to social, cultural and demographic historians as well as medical professionals. … By setting out such a well-rounded account of fertility decline and the evolution of birth control in Greece, Hionidou has thrown down a gauntlet to researchers elsewhere to broaden their perspectives and take a fresh look at fertility-related behaviour during their country’s first demographic transition.” (Eilidh Garrett, Continuity and Change, Vol. 36, 2021)