A Consequentialist Defense of Libertarianism

by Richard Fumerton University of Iowa

Overview

In A Consequentialist Defense of Libertarianism, Richard Fumerton argues that empirical facts concerning consequences must always play a crucial role in a plausible defense of freedom. After making distinctions between morality and law, he defends the view that it is a fundamental mistake to think that the law should always, or even usually, attempt to mirror morality. With this framework in place, Fumerton addresses various controversial questions concerning when the law ought to side with freedom. He offers a nuanced defense of several positions shared by many "moderate" libertarians.

This consequentialist defense of freedom offers a fresh perspective on some very old philosophical debates. As more people become frustrated with a perceived lack of principled attempts by established political parties to appreciate important concerns people have involving their desire for freedom, the issues discussed in this book are particularly timely.

Product Details

ISBN-13:	9781793632067
Publisher:	Lexington Books
Publication date:	08/24/2022
Pages:	232
Product dimensions:	5.95(w) x 9.05(h) x 0.58(d)

About the Author

Richard Fumerton is F. Wendell Miller Professor of philosophy at the University of Iowa.

Table of Contents

Preface

Part I: Theoretical Controversies: The Importance of Consequentialist Reasoning

Chapter 1: Level Distinctions and a Philosophical Dilemma

Chapter 2: Law, Rationality, and Morality

Chapter 3: Controversies in Meta-ethics and Meta-rationality

Part II: Defending Freedom

Chapter 4: Mill’s Defense of Freedom

Chapter 5: Consequentialist Arguments for Freedom of Thought and Expression

Chapter 6: Social Libertarianism

Chapter 7: Economic Libertarianism

Chapter 8: Summary

References

Editorial Reviews

In this wide-ranging study of political theory, ethics, and public policy, Fumerton attempts to incorporate consequentialism and libertarianism. The definition of libertarianism in this volume is indeed "flexible" (p. 197), especially when compared to the traditional view of libertarianism as advocating for constraining and diffusing power. The problem with libertarianism, and the need for interweaving libertarianism with consequentialism, results from the prevailing "'rights-based' conception of rationality and morality" (p. x) found in contemporary libertarian theory. If libertarianism can incorporate some critical elements of consequentialism, namely, certain "constraints" (p. xi) on what can be achieved in the social and political realms, the faulty and impractical limitations of libertarianism can be overcome. Guided by an imaginative reassessment of John Stuart Mill and consequentialism, the author suggests that new policy approaches to the issues of free expression, social life, and economics can replace the "confusing distraction" of debates over rights (p. 15)… [T]he "appeal for more humility when it comes to the political positions one takes on controversial issues concerning freedom" (p. 13) constitutes an enduring scholarly achievement. Recommended. Advanced undergraduates through faculty.

Choice

"It might seem that consequentialism and libertarianism make strange bedfellows. But for Richard Fumerton, in this tour de force of a philosophical journey ranging from metaethics to public policy, they make a happy marriage."

Larry Alexander

Libertarianism valorizes individual freedom, and on the traditional libertarian view, that freedom is demanded and secured by individual rights. Consequentialism is often thought to be antithetical to libertarianism precisely because it cannot accommodate such rights, instead requiring significant personal sacrifice for the greater good. In A Consequentialist Defense of Libertarianism, Richard Fumerton turns this debate on its head, advancing a consequentialist libertarianism that is more subtle than most extant rights-based versions of libertarianism and anything but doctrinaire.

John Oberdiek

In this wide-ranging study of political theory, ethics, and public policy, Fumerton attempts to incorporate consequentialism and libertarianism. The definition of libertarianism in this volume is indeed "flexible" (p. 197), especially when compared to the traditional view of libertarianism as advocating for constraining and diffusing power. The problem with libertarianism, and the need for interweaving libertarianism with consequentialism, results from the prevailing "'rights-based' conception of rationality and morality" (p. x) found in contemporary libertarian theory. If libertarianism can incorporate some critical elements of consequentialism, namely, certain "constraints" (p. xi) on what can be achieved in the social and political realms, the faulty and impractical limitations of libertarianism can be overcome. Guided by an imaginative reassessment of John Stuart Mill and consequentialism, the author suggests that new policy approaches to the issues of free expression, social life, and economics can replace the "confusing distraction" of debates over rights (p. 15)… [T]he "appeal for more humility when it comes to the political positions one takes on controversial issues concerning freedom" (p. 13) constitutes an enduring scholarly achievement. Recommended. Advanced undergraduates through faculty.

Choice Reviews

"Richard Fumerton’s A Consequentialist Defense of Libertarianism is a tour de force working through many major issues in ethics, political and legal philosophy, epistemology, and philosophy generally, done by one of the most distinguished philosophers of our times. Fumerton’s judgments on these issues are well-organized and clearly expressed in a manner accessible to lay readers, and yet despite such widespread  accessibility, there is no sacrifice of the kind of philosophical sophistication achievable only by one who has spent a lifetime maturing his judgments about such issues."

Michael S. Moore

"A masterful, rich, and lucid overview of what consequentialism is and how consequentialism approaches policy questions. Taking on abortion, the legalization of recreational drugs, and taxes, Fumerton explains in compelling terms why policies that preserve and protect social and economic freedom are likely to have the best consequences for communities."

Colleen Murphy