"What a remarkable, joyous book. Our culture, like his, is hell-bent on rendering middle-aged women invisible, and yet here are four of them, their lives not only filling every single page of this comic, but brought to us with such intimacy." —Rachel Cooke, The Guardian
"The people and events in Soyeon’s life are often disappointing but she perseveres as a sardonic, stubborn hero who finds contentment in her imperfect relationships and life’s mundane drama."
—NPR Best of 2020
"I... just finished reading Moms by Yeong-shin Ma. It’s a graphic novel about a bunch of women in their early 50s that I thought was really, really beautiful." —Mona Chalabi, New York Times
"[The characters'] greatest challenge, like people everywhere at every age, is loneliness—but even that can’t stop Ma’s fearsome mothers from living their best possible lives."
—Booklist, Starred Review
"A portrait of womanhood and middle-age, where all the women are bright and brash, both victims and fighters." —Sian Cain, The Guardian
"Moms by Yeong-shin Ma... presents a very real perspective of middle-aged women often not seen... as Moms shows, these ladies experience excitement, dreams, and struggles that too often are overlooked."
—BlogCritics
"The moms in Moms are grasping, funny, gross, weird, sad—in other words, they’re a lot more interesting and relatable than middle-aged mothers in pop culture are usually allowed to be... This is a book with bite."
—Bookriot Best Comics of 2020
"It’s extremely relatable, because the character work is so strong. All their hopes and flaws keep the narrative running, and its power increases when we see how badly people can treat each other... D&Q keeps bringing treasures from around the world to Canada. Long may that continue."
—The Toronto Star
"Seeming at first unconventional, one gets the sense that the women in Moms are not necessarily so; Ma simply affords them the type of interiority not usually granted to their demographic, while providing a warts-and-all look at long-term female friendships."
—Winnipeg Free Press
"Offering a unique account of contemporary Korea and the world from the perspective of women who might otherwise be overlooked, [Moms] would be a solid addition to any adult collection."
—Library Journal
"Yeong-shin Ma writes with great sympathy of the struggles of these middle-aged women, portrayed as humans and not caricatures." —Asian Review of Books
09/04/2020
In his first full-length, English-language comic, Korean cartoonist Ma explores the daily lives of middle-aged Korean moms as they work, date, eat, brawl, and stay up too late scrolling through social media. Taking inspiration from his own mother's account of her and her friends' mundane exploits, Ma paints an unflattering portrait of divorced janitor Soyeon and her circle of acquaintances. They are often jealous and petty, they obsess over extra fat and sweat profusely, they cheat and gossip, and they go back time and again to unworthy boyfriends. While most of the moms aren't particularly likable, their foibles are relatable. When the characters show occasional glimpses of depth—such as when Soyeon and a friend attempt to unionize their fellow janitors—readers will root for them. Ma is a master of drawing faces, expressing subtle mood shifts and unspoken thoughts with a single, well-placed pen line. Even the secondary characters are distinct. VERDICT Offering a unique account of contemporary Korea and the world from the perspective of women who might otherwise be overlooked, this is a fresh entry that would be a solid addition to any adult collection.—Ingrid Bohnenkamp, Springfield-Greene Cty. Lib. Dist., Springfield, MO