Sixteen-year-old Kelly believed everything that her first love, T., said to her. He was a gorgeous hunk and her brother's best friend On the night of Kelly's junior prom, T. steps in to take the place of her sick date, saving the day and treating her like a lady. After their romantic evening, they walked alone on the beach and T. made a promise to Kelly. “Let's go on a date every day. And on your eighteenth birthday, I'll ask you to marry me.” After that night, however, he was gone and the promise went unfulfilled. Now five years have passed and T. has unexpectedly showed up in her life again... What should Kelly do?